Why are people still using the BMI? - Weight Loss Support

Weight Loss Support

114,599 members60,928 posts

Why are people still using the BMI?

Jefflindholm profile image
1 Reply

I see a lot of posts in which people talk about their BMI. Why do people still use it? No one takes it seriously. Think about this: if a muscular football player and his sedentary, alcoholic grandmother were both the same height, they would have the same BMI! It tells us nothing of value.

I have lost about 50 KG and I have about 10 more to lose. The BMI tells me to lose another 40. That would put me in the hospital. I use weightzone.com because it gave me much better advice than the BMI. It tells me to lose between 9 KG and 14KG, which makes sense.

Written by
Jefflindholm profile image
Jefflindholm
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
1 Reply
fibronfedup profile image
fibronfedup

Link doesn't work

You may also like...

BMI

I have been taking part in the NHS 12 week weight loss programme and am on the Twelfth week and...

BMI

these BMI stats really make any sense ? Just had a look and according to the chart I need to lose 5...

What's the \"Healthy BMI\" badge for?

as I can tell. The maintainer badge says you have succeeded; the weight lost badges tell people how...

BMI , weight loss and muscle

measuring my waist. I have the usual old man belly and that calculation isn’t far from the BMI...

still can't figure this website out

this week64.2 kg getting there slowly4. 2kg to lose then it's maintainers club for me i am...