MORE RECENT RESEARCH: I previously... - Functional Neurol...

Functional Neurological Disorder - FND Hope

5,900 members3,164 posts

MORE RECENT RESEARCH

Dave_1 profile image
8 Replies

I previously posted an article on White matter and some felt it was a little old. This article, and I do not pretend to understand it all, was published 30th October 2019. What it does show is that by highlighting the FND case and condition some professionals are starting to take note. They are asking for more research, about time to. What a placebo pathway is I am sure someone out there will tell us.

The Journal of Neuropsychiaty and the placebo pathway.

neuro.psychiatryonline.org/...

David

Written by
Dave_1 profile image
Dave_1
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
8 Replies

"In conclusion, we provide a mechanism-based rationale that supports the potential use of placebo effects for the treatment of FND". Trying to argue it's not a real disease after all?

Dave_1 profile image
Dave_1 in reply to

Are they trying to find out why in most illnesses a similar perceived improvement is seen with medication and placebo. Are they starting to question more thoroughly just what's happening in the brain.

My only concern is that if research is not carried out multidisciplinary then like telling history there will be a biased view point.

Junebeatle profile image
Junebeatle

The placebo pathway or effects is when the mind/body adapt to treatment (improvement) when no treatment was actually received. For example, in say a anti-depressant drug trial the placebo group receiving the sugar pill and not the actual drug, reports improved mood and reduced depressive symptoms. They were unaware they were receiving a pill that does nothing, yet still gain perceived benefit.

Hope that explains it well.

Dave_1 profile image
Dave_1 in reply toJunebeatle

Thanks, a minefield.

artmom profile image
artmom

Afraid I can’t face reading another article tonight (though thank you for your time and effort on the research front and please don’t stop!), but isn’t that exactly what they think when they dx fnd? I just read on another thread someone’s neuro saying ‘I love giving this dx as it means the patient will get better’ (I paraphrase). That if you ‘believe’ in the dx you’re more likely to get better. That you just have to believe that what’s wrong with you is not organic therefore think-away-able, and you’ll be fine. All this is eminently treatable with a placebo? But I don’t think being told it’s ‘all in your mind’ is a placebo, it’s just a lack of treatment. And that’s what a dx of fnd gets you by and large.

Dave_1 profile image
Dave_1

Or does it mean have a positive attitude, to believe in improvement.

Any condition will respond better to a positive outlook.

Sure as hell doesn't mean it's easy.

artmom profile image
artmom

Actually no I don’t think they do mean that. I think they mean, if you accept this is in no way based in any physical malfunction you will get better. Immediately in some cases. That’s very different from having a positive approach. It’s blind faith. Faith healing? That’s what it says to me anyway. Not the same as a placebo. Guess maybe it’s a fine line?

Dave_1 profile image
Dave_1 in reply toartmom

Thanks Artmom, all views are welcome. Thats what this forum is all about.

Just one final point, we need to look at removing the mind/body barrier and treat the individual holistically for the best outcome.

Take Care

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

A little more research of interest...

My community friends. Technical info...Certainly over my head... But may be relevant in search for...

FND and ASD

I wondered how many members here had been diagnosed with ASD or are on the spectrum, as this...
Lady4 profile image

Recent FND diagnosis

So I'm interested to find out and learn about FND. Around 4 weeks ago I went to bed (totally...
ChrisH1987 profile image

Diagnosis Method of Functional Neurological Disorder

My first post, eek! I hope it's useful to someone. Basically I think the article I stumbled on...
medsoph profile image

Research paper discussing differentiating between various diagnoses of the fnd-type.

I think I found this in the comments on the David Tuller article, but not certain. So if it’s...
artmom profile image

Moderation team

See all
FND_ profile image
FND_Administrator
hope4fnd profile image
hope4fndModerator
DNE92 profile image
DNE92Moderator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.