LESS dopamine, not more could halt progre... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

27,431 members28,798 posts

LESS dopamine, not more could halt progression of PD??

india245 profile image
13 Replies

this is a topic which has been discussed before, but there is a new video on YouTube about it.

Unfortunately, I can’t link to it (I hope somebody can tell me how to copy and paste the links on my phone), but if you search for the video on Parkinson’s disease education channel, you should find it

Written by
india245 profile image
india245
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
13 Replies
mk2002wi profile image
mk2002wi

youtu.be/Jo2DgYtOVFc?si=ai_...

Is this the one?

india245 profile image
india245 in reply tomk2002wi

That’s the one – thank you so much for posting 🙏🏻

park_bear profile image
park_bear

When Dr Sackner-Bernstein visited this site I asked him how dopamine could be the problem when a number of genetic mutations affecting alpha synuclein are known to cause Parkinson's. He had no answer.

MarionP profile image
MarionP in reply topark_bear

Very important point. He could have at least said "I can't answer that one." I hope he did take the trouble to say "I don't know about that one" and "I don't have a good answer," or something similar.

park_bear profile image
park_bear in reply toMarionP

He did not respond.

michelagvolpe profile image
michelagvolpe

It could be interesting to stay undercorrected with dopamine and do a lot of physical exercises in order to exploit the plasticity of the brain to try to move better through new pathways. In this way, dyskinesias are reduced.

pearlette profile image
pearlette in reply tomichelagvolpe

I did try that when I was first diagnosed. But I did not really keep up the level of exercise. I have never liked serious exercise or sport but am not inactive.

It probably helped my balance.

Buckholt profile image
Buckholt

If his trial goes ahead, then I guess we’ll know then if he is on to something or not

Michel0220 profile image
Michel0220 in reply toBuckholt

If anyone is interested Jonathan Sackner Bernstein has a website (rightbrainbio.com/) where you can subscribe to his blog.

MarionP profile image
MarionP in reply toBuckholt

I guess we will see, but people with a confirmed conflict of interest in proving their theory tend to have pressures in selection, size, method, oversight, etc. and he sounds like a practitioner rather than a researcher so there is no implied ability in training (and ethical devotion to validity) as a scientist to work against conscious and unconscious bias in experiment design and evaluation. Witness the 100-120 million that guy at Harvard Medical School made off of the fraudulent research he conducted in this lab on reservatrol, creating his own company on the hype of what I think I was his intentionally bogus mercantile research pitch and then selling it.

blackbear701 profile image
blackbear701

Call me obtuse, but if less dopamine is the answer, shouldn't we all feel great?? Disclosure - I did not watch the video.

gigiwillms profile image
gigiwillms in reply toblackbear701

That's what I was thinking...in the five years from my diagnosis to start of mucuna and c/l, wouldn't my tremor and rigidity have fixed itself?

SanMateoPD profile image
SanMateoPD in reply togigiwillms

Yeah, the guy seems smart but if his theory is true, testing on a single patient should have the reverse effect of what mainstream medicine supposes. I know it's very complicated, but if he's right, it's vital. Is there really no way in the world to just "find out" whether his idea is real, just for himself or single individuals who *know* privately whether or not it works, and go from there?

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Protein: Do we need more - or less?

I've heard this argued both ways. Currently, I'm of the opinion that we can do without as much as...
JAS9 profile image

Dr Berg recommends this form of Vitamin E to help stroke, PD, Alzheimers and more!

Dr Berg's YouTube channel has more than 9 million subscribers (including many of you, I'm sure). I...

Could dopamine be too much? Or is it a wrong Diagnostic PD 5 years ago?

I was diagnosed 5 years ago with PD , started then on levodopa carbidopa (Sinemet) , I am now on 2...
Bouffere85 profile image

"Could microbes trigger the symptoms of Parkinson's disease?"

I posted a video on Art's recent FMT post pretty late and most people probably missed it....
rescuema profile image

TMJ APPLIANCE USED TO CORRECT SYMPTOMS OF PD...

Has anyone received relief your parkinson symptoms by using a TMJ APPLIANCE. I saw a video that...
Drevy profile image

Moderation team

See all
CPT_Aleksandra profile image
CPT_AleksandraAdministrator
CPT_Anaya profile image
CPT_AnayaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.