Faulty Bone Scan: I was diagnosed with... - Bone Health and O...

Bone Health and Osteoporosis UK

5,591 members2,461 posts

Faulty Bone Scan

Tlflom profile image
6 Replies

I was diagnosed with 31% bone loss in 2 years. After pursuing multiple specialist appointments. I ended up at a bone clinic. After a few questions the doc announced she did not believe the DEXA results. I was rescanned immediately.

The density was unchanged from the previous 6 years at the low end of normal! FYI, dramatic changes with no known causes might be a false reading. Guess who will be doing my DEXA from now on?

I was trained to perform Dexa and it is all computer automated so I don't know how it could be a tech error unless the daily calibrations were off.

Written by
Tlflom profile image
Tlflom
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
6 Replies
Jumpey profile image
Jumpey

So distressing that this happened. And those years of concern and worry.And great news for the future! X

Met00 profile image
Met00

From what I've read (but you'll obviously know more about this), DEXA machines should be recalibrated regularly and individual operators need to check their own calibration on a regular basis too. Although there's a lot of automation, it's possible to align the body wrongly, even to the extent of including the wrong vertebrae (hopefully that's extremely rare!) and also interpret the data incorrectly, for example by reference to the wrong database. What a good job the doctor at the bone clinic was on the ball!

Tlflom profile image
Tlflom in reply to Met00

For the tech running the dexa, there isn't much to do or get wrong. It is all pretty automatic. Which is why I totally trusted the result. Doing a regular xray does require positioning, dialing up the technical factors, and post processing. So a faulty dexa is either bad QA which is usually the beginning of each day and or faulty equipment. Both are quite concerning. I have not been able to reach the imaging director.

Met00 profile image
Met00 in reply to Tlflom

You might be interested in this study: "technical errors were identified in 90% of patients and affected interpretation in 13%. Interpretation errors were present in 80% of patients; 42% were major" and "Conclusion: DXA technical and interpretation errors are extremely common and likely adversely affect patient care" (researchgate.net/publicatio....

Tlflom profile image
Tlflom in reply to Met00

Thank you. This sight left me with more questions (not a bad thing). I am always looking for good research, have saved the link and will be spending some time on it. Thanks again.

StormyRon profile image
StormyRon

Thank you for the heads up

You may also like...

NHS Bone Scan - how often?

Hello All, I have just had a bone scan and been diagnosed with spinal osteoporosis. My last scan...

Trabecular Bone Scans

to be small boned and have low DEXA scores tend not to fracture despite having a low DEXA score....

Bone scan or risk assessment

aware of osteoporosis after breast cancer treatment 3 1/2 yrs ago. I had a DEXA scan in 2014 when...

Bone Density Scan

How often is it recommended to have a Bone Density Scan? Mine was about a year and a half ago....

FORSTEO, TERAPARATIDE, AND BONE LOSS.

lost 30% of my bone density. The reports also reveal that in the time between the end of my...