Some drugs not weight based - Bone Health and O...

Bone Health and Osteoporosis UK

6,305 members2,766 posts

Some drugs not weight based

SpaghettiIsGood profile image
13 Replies

I got the idea for this because I had just read about two people on here who got violently ill from taking a bone med injection.

Some drugs that are not weight based, like flu and covid vaccines, which are made for overweight people as well as thin people. Or, one could think of it as made for a man, as it's always recommended that a man can have more of something safely, like alcohol.

I know a drug I take for r.a. is not weight based. That means I'm getting the same dose that a 300 pound person gets? How can that be? At least aspirin is weight based, sort of, as they have age recommendations on the bottle.

Written by
SpaghettiIsGood profile image
SpaghettiIsGood
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
13 Replies
Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase

I hadn’t thought of that before - when you think of it I suppose a tiny little elderly lady is prescribed the same amount of bisphosphonate as someone young or an adult man.Maybe someone who knows will tell us more 🤔

SpaghettiIsGood profile image
SpaghettiIsGood in reply toFruitandnutcase

The men I know who get the flu vaccine don't have side effects. The women I know get sick from it.

Met00 profile image
Met00 in reply toSpaghettiIsGood

That would make a very interesting study, not just for flu vaccine, but Covid vaccine and a whole range of medications. Having said that, I had side effects from my Covid vaccines, but have been fine with the flu one.

Fruitandnutcase profile image
Fruitandnutcase in reply toMet00

I was fine for all three covid vaccines and my flu one. My husband felt a bit off colour with his covid ones - can’t remember what he said about the flu one - I was fine with the flu one. There’s a lot more of him than there is of me too.It would make an interesting study though. Why are some med doses decided by weight and not others?

Just been looking at weight based dosing of medications. It seems to be common in babies and young children but not in adults with the result that obese adults may be getting too little medicine and severely underweight adults may be getting an overdose.

This paper has more about it and it looks like it has a lost of drugs that are prescribed by body weight

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

SpaghettiIsGood profile image
SpaghettiIsGood in reply toMet00

I had little side effects from j&j vax, but did with flu vax.

Good link you posted, very informative and supported by around fifty studies.

SpaghettiIsGood profile image
SpaghettiIsGood in reply toMet00

Well there goes my vaccine theory, unless you're an exception.

Met00 profile image
Met00 in reply toSpaghettiIsGood

But my husband didn't react to any of them, so your theory still stands.

SpaghettiIsGood profile image
SpaghettiIsGood in reply toMet00

Thank you for that!

MollyStark profile image
MollyStark

It's a good point. My husband occasionally takes a sleeping tablet and wakes up feeling fine and refreshed in the morning.

My sister was prescribed the same sleeping tablets once. She is tiny, a very small build. She said she was asleep all night and most of the next day. When she finally managed to get up she felt heavily drugged and it scared her!

NJBINNN profile image
NJBINNN

I had a bad reaction to my first Zolendronic acid infusion last year and OP problems since. I am underweight (43Kilo) and don’t know if this was taken into account. I am vey reluctant to have another.

M3745 profile image
M3745

I have been asking the same question for years. I am a small person and get more side effects from medications. My dermatologist is the only one who recognizes this. There is a medication that she prescribes for my cystic acne that I am the only one she prescribes 50mg where most of her patients are overweight and they get the standard dosage of 100mg. She said 100mg would be too much for me because it is a potassium sparing drug and that could be dangerous for me. So if an over the counter medication calls for 1 or 2 pills, I always start with the 1. I took a nighttime cold medication the other night and felt so lethargic and awful the whole next day. They do go by weight for animals so why not humans.

AnnieW55 profile image
AnnieW55

Not medication but: Calcium, can a 50kg body really process the same maximum amount of calcium, said to be 500mg, at one time as say a 100kg body? When I was given Adcal the calcium part was 600mg and I was supposed to take two a day - that was with no regard for my dietary calcium.

Jubux profile image
Jubux

I was recently shown a syringe for use in medication for dogs. Rather than measurements in cc, the marks up the side were per kg of dog!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Scaring women into taking dangerous drugs? Something to think about.

There is an interesting article regarding the recent big ‘surge’ in women being diagnosed with...
MiaLee profile image

weight loss and zoledronic acid

hi,I have been reading reports that zoledronic acid can cause weight loss, that's ok for people who...
Radars profile image

Weight training with osteoporosis

Hi,I have recently been diagnosed with osteoporosis, it is classed as severe,I am waiting for the...
Radars profile image

what's the point of osteoporosis drugs

I have been reading a lot on here about people who have had medication and are in immense pain with...
Radars profile image

34, Osteoporosis and scared of drugs

Hello all So just seen my GP regarding many matters including my recently diagnosed osteoporosis...
Chaucer89 profile image

Moderation team

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.