Choosing a treatment centre/surgeon - British Heart Fou...

British Heart Foundation

50,147 members31,648 posts

Choosing a treatment centre/surgeon

capercaille profile image
20 Replies

I'm pretty sure I will soon need mitral valve surgery (preferably minimally invasive) but how on earth do I find out/decide who/where is the best?

Written by
capercaille profile image
capercaille
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
20 Replies
Yumz199725 profile image
Yumz199725

Have you spoken to your consultant about your options? Hopefully one of your options is minimally invasive surgery. I will need valve replacement surgery to fix my bicuspid aortic valve and my only option is open heart surgery so it's major surgery. Have you been given a date yet for your surgery?? X

capercaille profile image
capercaille in reply to Yumz199725

Thanks for your reply – no, I have yet to get/see a surgical consultant to properly discuss my particular symptoms, so no date either. So far I've only been seen by cardiac physiologists who do my ultrasounds and report to a cardiologist. It's finding the right surgeon, not just the local one I may be referred to by my local hospital, that is my initial concern. But probably just need to have that initial conversation with whoever, then sort the rest. Thanks again!

Yumz199725 profile image
Yumz199725 in reply to capercaille

Hope you can get the right surgeon and get a date for your surgery soon x

I guess you’re looking for private centres / surgeon as I think on NHS it’s whoever cardiologist / hospital picks as most appropriate for your case?

If and when you see a cardiologist they may be able to advise. Often they do private work as well as NHS but again they will probably recommend the ones they routinely work with.

I don’t think I’d have the confidence or knowledge to find a surgeon myself.

I hope you find someone you’re happy with👍 I’m sure someone will be along soon who has also searched out surgeons!

capercaille profile image
capercaille in reply to

Thank you! But no, not private (can't afford that!): but with NHS you are entitled to choose where you are treated, although many don't as they simply don't know you can. Also, with waiting lists so long, they are encouraging people to travel further for treatment…I have done a fair amount of research but it's SO difficult to weigh up things. I will wait to discuss when I see someone…thanks again.

in reply to capercaille

Ok I read it as private, yes I am aware can choose on NHS - good luck with your search. Do you have particular concerns about your local surgeons?

capercaille profile image
capercaille in reply to

Thank you again – just seeking best option.

in reply to capercaille

You need to get yourself into the NHS system first assuming they agree you need surgery. Then there can be options and advice offered when you air your concerns about the local lot. Good luck.

dlowell profile image
dlowell

Dr Stephen Brecker Mayo Clinic

mayoclinichealthcare.co.uk/...

roughquest profile image
roughquest

I’d have a private cardiac consultation with a Dr who is also NHS on the same practice. In fact I’ve done just that and got referred back into the NHS, if your lucky in the same hospital. I can’t speak highly enough of the Brompton, in comparison to the lack lustre trust just 30 miles away.

Sally_Scott profile image
Sally_Scott

I had new mitral valve at St Thomas’s in London in January. Tbh reading your message I would have thought that your cardiologist would be telling you if you need this and then referring you on. So have you just diagnosed yourself and you think you need a new mitral valve?

capercaille profile image
capercaille in reply to Sally_Scott

No, awaiting decision, but just want to be well prepared.

TriumphLover profile image
TriumphLover

Hi, I’m 11 weeks out after aortic valve replacement and some other stuff. My surgeon was recommended by the consultant. I done some research on him but my thinking was I’m not really qualified to assess him. I spent more time on deciding between tissue or metal valve. Decided on tissue, which turned out was the surgeons speciality, particularly with a “mini “ opening ( 2/3 opening instead of full ).

So my advice would be to match your prognosis with the surgeon if anything.

capercaille profile image
capercaille in reply to TriumphLover

Thank you – helpful advice.

TriumphLover profile image
TriumphLover in reply to capercaille

No problem. If you have any questions about the procedure let me know, happy to help. Had some great help from this site before I went in.

Good luck.

capercaille profile image
capercaille in reply to TriumphLover

Thanks again…

Hanibil profile image
Hanibil

Try Mr Roberto Casula, you will be able to contact him through the Wellington hospital St John’s Wood London. He replaced my aortic valve and repaired my aortic root , by minimal invasive surgery back in 2005 and am still alive and kicking.

capercaille profile image
capercaille in reply to Hanibil

Thank you – this is very useful/interesting: he is actually one of the surgeons in the dept. of my local NHS hospital so I may well meet him!

Hanibil profile image
Hanibil

would that be St Mary’s

capercaille profile image
capercaille in reply to Hanibil

It would.

You may also like...

appointment with Surgeon

a loss as to how I do this .. is this like a job interview where I need to prove I am worthy of...

Choosing a defibrillator

collapsing during a run. Does anyone have any tips on how to chose between the two types of...

Post Op meeting with Surgeon

should ask as I'm sure I'll have 10 minutes to grill him before I never see him again. I'm also...

Meeting my Surgeon tomorrow..

don't get me wrong I do realise there is need for this surgery and I am eternally grateful that I...

UPDATE on seeing the surgeon

and I still do. To me it seems the best thing to do to get the best results for now and the future....