Acapella Flutter: Just wondering if... - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

56,062 members66,695 posts

Acapella Flutter

Milandra17 profile image
33 Replies

Just wondering if anyone else on here has used one of these.

I'm in my second one but both of them seem to be defective in that the "flutter" doesn't work properly. With the most recent one it's been rubbish from the start. My surgery aren't familiar with the device and at the moment I can't imagine I'll be able to have a face to face meeting with a member of the Respiratory Team.

Have I just been unlucky with this device?

Written by
Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
33 Replies
Damon1864 profile image
Damon1864Volunteer

Mine work fine, hope you get it sorted, have a lovely day and take care of yourself 😊 Bernadette xx 🌈

cofdrop-UK profile image
cofdrop-UK

I’ve had many acapellas which have worked fine. However the first one I had which wasn’t from the hospital and the one I have had recently were both rubbish.

It might be helpful to get in touch with whoever prescribed it or if you purchased it, it is up to the retailer to sort a replacement out for you. Don’t let them fob you off asking you to send it back to the manufacturers, your contract is with the retailer.

Good luck

Cx

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to cofdrop-UK

Thanks, both came from the pharmacy at my GP surgery. They're on prescription. I suspected the first one wasn't working properly and it was confirmed by the Respiratory Team. The surgeries andvpharmacies really have no idea about them.

Oshgosh profile image
Oshgosh

I find with my acapella, sometimes the metal strip doesn’t flutter properly.

I turn it over a couple of times:hav a quick blow and wait for it to work. There doesn’t seem to be an exact science to it;I’m sorry. I can be any more help. Hope this helps a bit. Stay safe

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to Oshgosh

Thank you,that's the sameproblem that I'm having

Oshgosh profile image
Oshgosh in reply to Milandra17

Sorry forgot to say. If the mucus is a thick,sometimes I use the Acapella at the same time as the nebuliser.its a bit of a faff,but it does help.

Toria2 profile image
Toria2

I'm on aerobika flutter device so I'm not sure about yours but I didn't want to go back to the hospital because of the outbreak and I was really surprised to find quite a few good utube videos on my mobile phone even how to use with my saline nebuliser which I find really helpful.

I hope yours is there aswel

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to Toria2

That's a good idea, thank you

MarilynSakkis profile image
MarilynSakkis

I love mine....bought on Amazon. Use it 2x day and should use more.

Oshgosh profile image
Oshgosh

Never thought of looking on YouTube . Thank. You.

coral12 profile image
coral12

mine works very well green 1. it does help get phlem up i use it twice a week .normally. wen im bad i use most days.i was in hosp for 9 days a year last feb with flu/pneumonia. i was given mine then

Joy123 profile image
Joy123

I was prescribed one, did absolutely nothing for me. Apparently, some people get relief with it and some don’t. I’m obviously the latter! Keep well. Joy.

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to Joy123

When my original one actually worked it did help. My problem is that it is now defective as is the replacement

MoyB profile image
MoyB in reply to Joy123

When I first got mine I was shown how to use it by the resp nurse and I felt the vibrations. Since getting it home, it has never seemed to work as well. I thought I was probably doing something wrong so put it to one side and left it. Then a little while ago, I gave it another go and it seemed to work. Since then, it hasn't. After reading these posts, I'm now thinking that it could be a faulty device, but am also bearing in mind the fact that you haven't had much success with one either so maybe they don't suit everybody. xx Moy

stanns profile image
stanns in reply to MoyB

They are not easy to get on with, keep trying it will work.

Joy123 profile image
Joy123 in reply to MoyB

I was given mine by the Brompton hospital, the physio told me some get benefit from using it and some don’t! Maybe you’re like me Moy? One Of those it doesn’t help/suit. Joy.

Pokermon profile image
Pokermon

They do take a bit of practice.

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17

When it worked it worked. No amount of practice is going to help when the device is defective

B0xermad profile image
B0xermad

Hi milandra17,I have flutters on a regular 6mths basis last 5yrs and I put them in milton fluid completely stripped down ,so when re assembled they sometimes need to be shaken to get the movement back working right.often trying a couple of times a lot of messing about but some do play up some are ok

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17

Thank you, but this latest one has been faulty from the start. I'll try giving it a good shake though!

DaisyEric profile image
DaisyEric

It's difficult to put your head in the right position to make it flutter. Very much an individual thing i think. My sister has her head in a completely different position with hers.

B0xermad profile image
B0xermad in reply to DaisyEric

The flutter is definitely harder to use than the acapella,as you have to tilt upwards and is awkward

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to B0xermad

Sorry, my fault but it's an Acapella Choice that I have problems with

Neville33 profile image
Neville33

I use an aerobica device...twice a day for 20 minutes each time...works well, plus nebulize 7 percent saline twice a day

Beth1949 profile image
Beth1949

There is a certain way that you breath into it that makes a big difference.

Take a deep breath and place the acapella to your mouth, blow out by mouth using your diaphragm. If done correctly, it should make a low vibrating sound and you should feel the vibration in your lungs. Don't breath out too fast, just alittle faster than you would normally breath out.

Hope this helps, Beth

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to Beth1949

Thank you. That's how ive been taught to use it but the device isn't functioning correctly

Knittingnora55 profile image
Knittingnora55

What is it ? I haven't herd of it before

lKeith profile image
lKeith

Miandra17

Hi

I think you have been very unlucky. I have one which works OK but it does take a while to have an effect say 10 mins.

IKeith

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to lKeith

When i got the first one it worked well

lKeith profile image
lKeith in reply to Milandra17

Milandra17

Hi again

Did you try the carbocistein and the acapello together?

IKeith

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to lKeith

I've never been offered carbocistein. I've been well for over a year and no longer need to attend the consultant's clinic. I went from constant chest infections for 2 years to nothing. No idea how or why but hope it lasts

lKeith profile image
lKeith in reply to Milandra17

Mirandra17

Hi again,

Glad to hear that you have no flare ups, lets hope it stays that way.

The carbocistein was prescribed for the purpose of getting up the mucus, if you haven't seen your GP lately ask him about it with the acapello machine.

Keep well. keep safe.

IKeith

Milandra17 profile image
Milandra17 in reply to lKeith

My GP doesn't really have any input re my bronchiectasis. I go straight to the Respiratory Team and they've never mentioned this drug. If i get to the state i was in previously i will be sure to mention it though, thank you

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Acapella alternative

I ordered a replacement acapella mucus clearing device through the GP surgery a week ago, the...

FLUTTER DEVICE

Hi all, I went back to the docs on Friday as I am very sob of late and am finding it difficult to...

How to use Aerobika flutter device

Hi, it's my first post here, tho I've been reading all the helpful posts about bronchiectasis for a...

flutter device used to improve breathing

I have just read a post concerning a flutter device for the removal of phlegm and mucus. I am...

Flutter Device

Hi all, I am having so much difficulty with constant coughing, I have been given exercises with...