problems with spiriva capsules? - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

56,315 members66,940 posts

problems with spiriva capsules?

wilki-e profile image
55 Replies

recently i have had a problem with the spiriva capsules being empty,during the last few months i had to obtain extra issues.last month no fewer than 10 of the 30 issued were empty! last night i had 12 fail on me before one worked,is this a problem others have come across if so the quality control at the facility that produces them needs to be examined otherwise it is costing the nhs a lot of money,thankfully as a pensioner i do not have to pay but i still pay my taxes!

Written by
wilki-e profile image
wilki-e
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
55 Replies
y_not profile image
y_not

"12 fail on me before one worked" - do you mean that they didn't "rattle" or did you open them to check? There is only a very small amount of white powder in each capsule and they often don't rattle (for me).

If you actually took 12 doses then don't worry - the overdose ceiling is way higher than that!

Sometimes mine rattle, other times they don't - I just check that the holes are in the capsule and that it's sealed in the foil until moments before use (if you accidently pull the foil too far and expose the next capsule then destroy it as exposure to the atmosphere ruins it).

There seem to be a lot of comments on the Internet about them being empty but in most cases it turns out that people think they are empty because they didn't rattle.

Hope it helps

wilki-e profile image
wilki-e in reply toy_not

thanks to all for their input,i checked each capsule after trying them,no sign of any white powder which is what i expected to see.i have kept the empty ones and will submit them to the pharmacy when i run out.very best to all.

y_not profile image
y_not in reply towilki-e

That's interesting - I have a few "spares" (from the days when my memory doesn't catch up with my body!) so I'm going to open a few and see ... will let you know the outcome. Many thanks

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply towilki-e

i doubt that your pharmacy will be interested. nothing will come of it. i would suspect that the nhs , doctors and the pharmacy companies were dazzled by the supplier presentation of their products.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply towilki-e

you must wonder how many people world wide take this medication when in fact they are not receiving anything.

Mooskie profile image
Mooskie in reply toy_not

Yes, i was first aware because of no rattle, but i also took the capsule and inspected it very carefully and could not see one trace of powder. also i did not get the feeling of powder in the back of my throat (which always happens with full capsule).

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply toMooskie

this is a common problem with this product. the producer of spiriva must review all sites of their product and viewed comments. yet i have not seen any comments by the company. i think it is a case of them thinking that the problems will go away. no point in contacting the company.it needs an investigation by the medical regulators .

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply toeuphemia123

my spiriva problem solved. my gp has put me on braltus tiotropium capsules which are see through, which mean i can see the medication before,and the empty capsule after use.

tinkle123 profile image
tinkle123 in reply toy_not

Me too, you can't tell by shaking them but you can tell when you inhale whether it's full or empty. It's a very good medication but I've found that MANY elderly people can't use the inhaler because it's not easy for them to get that BIG inhalation. A new design of inhaler, I think, would be of great benefit to COPDers

frankpres profile image
frankpres in reply toy_not

no-some capsules are empty, not experienced 12, but 1-2 or 3 out of 30 regularly. you have obviously not experienced an empty capsule- you would know immediately.

victoriablue profile image
victoriablue

I have complained about this countless times over the past few years. Nearly had words with the chemist as I went back to say I was running low. In the end I spoke to the nurse I see and she said anymore problems just to ring her she gave me an extra prescription to make up.

Tetrazzini profile image
Tetrazzini

Ask for the new Spiriva Respimat Inhaler. It does the same job.

newlands profile image
newlands

Don't think I would know if it was empty !

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply tonewlands

try a sample of capsules open them before use.

katieoxo60 profile image
katieoxo60

Hi I have been using this drug method for quite some years and only come across a couple of duds i.e one did not peirce because it was mishapen, it did not rattle either. And I have had the odd empty one with no sign of white powder. If you have 12 duds I would go and discuss with the pharmicist who dispensed as it could be a faulty batch or your misunderstanding.Agree with others the white powder is only a minute amount in each capsule.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply tokatieoxo60

if it is a faulty batch it is world wide. what misunderstanding could there be if a capsule is empty.

Badbessie profile image
Badbessie

Within a number of COPD groups this subject as been brought up. I know from listening to others that a few people have experienced duds. Whilst in hospital 2 of the 6 people in my bay actually showed the respiratory nurses the problem and capsules were found to be empty. From what I understand this started to happen just before Christmas. The pharmacist took details but what the outcome was I do not know.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply toBadbessie

the pharmacy will hit a brick wall. the manufacturer is not prepared to accept that there is a problem. it is the fault of the user.

That happened to me with Spiriva so the nurse gave me the inhalator type instead. That might be an option for you.

tamariki profile image
tamariki

Try and get QVAR and Anoro Ellipta. I was given that instead of Spiriva and find it's much better.

Charliegeorge profile image
Charliegeorge

Our spriva.has been changed to a different and cheaper version , they work just the same really .

northernlass profile image
northernlass in reply toCharliegeorge

Mine's been changed to Braltus and capsules are clear so you can see and check afterwards that you've inhaled all the powder. I think it's better like this AND could explain why my chest has been so bad on random days with no 'apparent' reason.

bogo3995 profile image
bogo3995

I have heard from several people that they have a problem with empty spiriva capsules. I order mine online. Never had a problem. MUCH cheaper than here in the states.

ditowler profile image
ditowler

I have had problems with spiriva capsules also, I get very cranky because they cost me 49.00 a month

lovejoyliz profile image
lovejoyliz

Hi Wilki-e

Yes I had the same problem and therefore I changed over to Spiriva Respimat inhaler which is so much easier to use, so you might like to ask your doctor to make this change for you.

fishtail profile image
fishtail

I too have this problem occasionally,the quality control appears to be very poor.

jackdup profile image
jackdup

How does everyone know the capsules are empty? If you open them after using them you would expect them to be empty,

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply tojackdup

Not difficult, open them before use.

jackdup profile image
jackdup in reply toeuphemia123

But why would you waste capsules by opening them? I have never heard of anyone opening capsules when used in an inhaler or taking them orally before.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply tojackdup

[edited]

jackdup profile image
jackdup in reply toeuphemia123

A lot of medications that are taken orally also come in capsules and if you are suspecting your Spiriva capsules are empty it would stand to reason other medications that come in capsules are perhaps also empty. I've just never heard of people taking them apart to see if there is anything in them. If you want to be a big spender would you not have to open all of the capsules as just because one had medication or one was empty doesn't mean the rest of the batch will also be full or empty.

in reply tojackdup

I've been on Spiriva for two years & have never had an empty capsule. I've never opened one, but as you inhale you can detect the powder. Several of my drugs come in capsules. It would never occur to me to check if they're empty.

jackdup profile image
jackdup in reply to

Me either and am sure regulators would fine drug manufacturers if they found that to be the case.

in reply tojackdup

The MHRA enforces the regulations very strictly. If something gets repeated often enough on the internet, people believe it.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply to

how do you know that you have never had a empty capsule. live dangerously and open a sample capsule before use.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply tojackdup

ok live in ignorance.

bigaitch666 profile image
bigaitch666

yes you have my sympathy on this matter happens to me on a regular basis complained to my doctors about this and my chemist it needs to be sorted out in my opinion

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply tobigaitch666

see my note today.

1redkite profile image
1redkite

I too have had this happen, but always order more well in advance.

charliesmith50 profile image
charliesmith50

Unless you open them b4 use how would you tell if they were empty ? shine a very powerful torch through one , shake it , maybe they could be made from clear material.

I have had the odd one that has disintegrated , with the result as if you were sucking,. down a tube tunnel. What happens to bit out of the hole ? I used a capsule took it out and swallowed it thinking it was my blood pressure tablet .

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply tocharliesmith50

how about opening a couple before use.

Mooskie profile image
Mooskie in reply toeuphemia123

no way to know if it is empty! by opening then you have wasted a dose!

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply toMooskie

by opening a sample capsule before use should not be a big issue.

Mooskie profile image
Mooskie

YES! i also have some spiriva packs that were empty. i called my pharmacist and told him. he seemed very surprised!!! i would say one out of 15 would be empty!! i am in Canada.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply toMooskie

i conclude that this is a wold wide problem.

Nikilet profile image
Nikilet

I also take this medicine and have wondered at times if there's anything in there. I have opened capsules only after I have used them and found no residue of any kind. It's a shame for what they charge for this. I can't understand why they haven't come out with a generic for this.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply toNikilet

how about opening a couple before use.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply toNikilet

to have a generic alternative depends when the licence period runs out, ie the period to recover r and d costs.

gemlady12 profile image
gemlady12

I live in the U.S. and Spiriva cost a small fortune. I am on Medicare. I also had problems with the vials being empty, too; maybe not as much as you, but for the cost, it was ridiculous. I now use alldaychemist.com as my asthma/copd meds would be about $1200 a month in the U.S. And at "allday" it's maybe $100 tops. I switched over to the inhaler form of Spiriva. It's two puffs and you might ask if that's available in the UK.

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply togemlady12

the capsules is a world wide problem. if the company had any sort of quality control they would know this by the amount of powder left over after production .

crabbybill profile image
crabbybill

Agree seems lots of them are empty

mefinder47 profile image
mefinder47

I've mentioned to the pharmacist at Walgreen's that I have found empty capsules in my Spiriva prescription. I felt that they were empty because the literature that comes with the medication said that if you don't hear the rattle, it's not good. The pharmacist said she had lots of complaints of the same thing from others. She said to notify the manufacturer, with the lot #, which is printed on the box, and they may replace those that are defective. I haven't tried that yet.

Mooskie profile image
Mooskie in reply tomefinder47

in my opinion, i think the pharmacy should contact the drug manufacturer! my pharmacy said the same thing to me!!

euphemia123 profile image
euphemia123 in reply tomefinder47

walgreens own boots the largest chemist chain in the uk, not good.

Nikilet profile image
Nikilet

I actually wrote to the company about this and they called me back. I got a lot of side stepping and no results. It's a shame that something can't be done because the price of this medication (and so many others) is actually prohibitive unless you are very wealthy, even with insurance. There is NO excuse for any problems with it. I have since been put on Stiolto Respimat in place of the Spiriva. It's helping me more, but then maybe that is because I wasn't getting any medication a lot of times with the Spiriva because of empty capsuls.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

spiriva problems

a common theme runs through correspondence empty capsules or tiny doses of medication.i have...
euphemia123 profile image

Plastic in Spiriva capsules

Hi I’ve been on Spiriva 18 micro inhalation powder hard capsules for two and a half years now. I...
Kiwiflyer8 profile image

Spiriva

Hi how do you find Spiriva to use i have been taking it for a while but have had a few u t i and i...
nottowell profile image

Spiriva

Hi all need a little advice about my copd last year I was told I have copd my spirometry test was...

Spiriva Respimat

I have been taking Spiriva Respimat powder inhaler for some months now. The problem I have is it...
Tony277 profile image

Moderation team

See all
AsthmaandLung profile image
AsthmaandLungAdministrator
moderator_AandLUK profile image
moderator_AandLUKAdministrator
Claire_ALUK profile image
Claire_ALUKAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.