Gp diagnosis : Hi I was told by my Gp... - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

56,238 members66,863 posts

Gp diagnosis

monjii profile image
19 Replies

Hi I was told by my Gp back in December that I have the start of emphysema. I went because I had a cold I could not shake. I have had no tests done, no xrays and I gave been worrying about it ever since. I do struggle with breathing when I run, but should I be getting further tests done?

Written by
monjii profile image
monjii
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
19 Replies
Diddydriver profile image
Diddydriver

I really don't think how you GP can say that you have emphysema without first having an X-ray. You haven't said that he/ she has given you any inhalers. I would go back and ask to have an X-ray and ask what sort of meds you are likely to be taking. Don't worry too much until you have a firm diagnosis.

monjii profile image
monjii in reply toDiddydriver

Thank you. It's bizarre isn't it ? I will call my Gp today. Many thanks

Jeremy76 profile image
Jeremy76 in reply toDiddydriver

My initial visit to a doc about my emp involved a stethoscope and a couple of taps on the back.

He was certain had it and after a follow up MRI scan, he was proved correct.

Don't waste time just go straight to your local hospital and tell them you having chest pains. They have to ex ray you and if they find anything they will give you treatment and advice.

Good luck.

monjii profile image
monjii in reply to

That's what I thought! Thanks

Asa2 profile image
Asa2

According to NICE the umbrella that your GP should follow. You need to have a spirometry test and a full blood profile done for diagnosis to be confirmed

monjii profile image
monjii in reply toAsa2

That's really helpful thankyou

in reply toAsa2

Very true Asa. A spirometry test is usually done to comfirm a diagnosis. An x-ray should be done as well but often isn't. This is to to rule out any other causes. x

Asa2 profile image
Asa2

X ray is also part of the diagnostic tools

To rule out other problem.

So get back to your GP with this message.

Hello there, what an amazing GP to be able to diagnose emphesemia with no diagnostic tools. No, you need to insist on being referred to a chest consultant at a hospital. Even an xray isn't sufficient to make a diagnosis. There are so many different lung conditions. The worst thing is that you have had this word thrown at you with no suggestion of treatment or support. Kick them into touch. Goodluck.

juney_99_antique profile image
juney_99_antique

GP's still getting away with murder! So inefficient it beggars belief.

I think that at the least you should have a spirometry test - it might be a good idea to call the helpline and get advise how exactly what treatment you should be receiving. You can call the helpline on 03000 030 555 Lines are open Monday to Friday from 9am to 5pm. Good Luck TAD xx

Nanny1086 profile image
Nanny1086

I think that was wrong of GP to make such a rushed diagnosis ,,,,ask for chest X-ray ,,,,,and what medication you need to be taking ,,,,,,,if any ,?

Dmactds profile image
Dmactds

Amongst all other suggestions, you really should consider changing doctors, this one seems daffy; also, you give no mention of how old you might be and of your general lifestyle except mentioning that you 'run'.

Please realize that as we age things start happening, for better or worse, to our bodies and there's usually no stopping it. At this point, you really shouldn't panic.....

Regards,

Duncan

monjii profile image
monjii

Thanks to you all. Great advice.

frank65 profile image
frank65

change your doc

tomc profile image
tomc

To diagnose Emphysema you need a spirometry test, blood test and a CT Scan as X-rays do not show Emphysema very well.

This is what my consultant has said to me... On an x-ray Emphysema is not seen..#

On my CT scan it is clearly visible...

Tom.

SusanneH profile image
SusanneH

I'm very surprised your GP has made this diagnosis without having sent you for an x-ray or C.T scan its a bit irresponsible of him.I would insist on being sent for the proper tests.

monjii profile image
monjii

Am going for an xray today. Then have to wait 10 days for results. ...so we shall see. Cheers guys i really appreciate your help.😊

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

diagnosis

My GP has been telling me for years i have COPD but never had any symptoms only mild Asthma. How...
raypowers profile image

NSIP diagnosis

I’m new here. My husband has been off sick for 18 mths, struggling for 3 years. Nothing could be...
Letitgo profile image

I'm new and awaiting GP diagnosis

Hi everyone, Happy New Year. I'm really struggling here with breathing. This is my story in a...
gwtoxz profile image

New diagnosis

Had ct scan done in December which shows pleuritic thickening & scarring. Referral to thoracic...
Mismatch profile image

DIAGNOSIS????????????????

after quiting smoking I was given a spiro test by the practice nurse and was told that I had COPD,...
mishawaka profile image

Moderation team

See all
AsthmaandLung profile image
AsthmaandLungAdministrator
Claire_ALUK profile image
Claire_ALUKAdministrator
moderator_AandLUK profile image
moderator_AandLUKAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.