Fostair to Luforbec saves NHS money - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

21,701 members24,472 posts

Fostair to Luforbec saves NHS money

GreyGasp profile image
8 Replies

My GP is changing my prescription from Fostair 200/6 to Luforbec. I can see that this reflects NICE guidelines and will save the NHS money; it has similar active ingredients, but I can't find any statement of equivalent or improved efficacy.

If someone has recently had a similar change in their prescription I would be interested to hear from them. Does Luforbec work better, worse or the same for patients?

Written by
GreyGasp profile image
GreyGasp
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
8 Replies
Troilus profile image
Troilus

My prescription is for Fostair, but a couple of times I was issued with Luforbec. I couldn’t really get along with it - started having mild symptoms- maybe my technique I don’t know. I asked if I could have the Fostair and was told they are both the same. I stuck to my guns, reiterating that while that might be the case for some unknown reason the Luforbec didn’t work as well for me. That was accepted and I am back with my Fostair.

However, the must be some difference as once opened Fostair can be used for 5 months where it is only 3 for Luforbec.

GreyGasp profile image
GreyGasp

Thanks for your feedback. Without objective, comparative clinical studies, there is no substitute for the shared, lived experience of those with a similar issue.👍

Poobah profile image
Poobah

If you look to the top right of this page, you'll see a list of related posts. There's been quite a few members facing the same issue as yourself and, from what I've read, they all experience a drop in effective treatment when changing from Fostair to Luforbec. If your doctor insists on the change, I would start recording your daily peak flow results, symptoms and number of times you need to take your Ventolin/rescue inhaler. This personal evidence should help demonstrate that Luforbec is not effective.

DannyQ profile image
DannyQ

Hi I'm on Fostair 100/6 and the tried to change me over to lubfrec, but there was not a chance I was going to allow that because Fostair has been a game changer for me, the reason I refused because lubfrec is a generic they might have the same ingredients but the processes will be completely different and the best way for me to describe it is if you and I were to make a cup of tea using the same ingredients they would more than likely taste completely different and it's the same with generics. Fostair spent years perfecting there processes before coming to market whereas a generic is rushed to market to try and compete but are rarely as effective. Also on this age you will find plenty of people that have had adverse affect when there GP has changed them from fostair to Lubfrec, so I would say if your in control of your Asthma using Fostair I would suggest you push back with your GP as they save £8 per device by changing you

I hope this helps

Scrofulous profile image
Scrofulous

I've had two changes. I was swapped to Luforbec maybe two years ago. I had nothing but trouble with the inhaler, not the actual drug. I kept getting too much, to the extent that I couldn't inhale it because it burned, or made me jittery. It appears to be the metered dose mechanism. One morning I'd had enough and asked GP to put me back on Fostair. No sooner had I begun taking it I remembered the awful irritation it caused my throat, leading to constant throat clearing and hoarseness. Being a pain in the bum, I changed back to Luforbec because I don't get side effects. To prove to myself that it was the mechanism, I put the Luforbec in the Fostair inhaler, and lo and behold, no problem. I realise it's not a viable long term solution but am seeing resp nurse on 6th Dec to discuss options. So, long answer to short question, Luforbec drug works well for me. Hope for you too.

redstar9 profile image
redstar9

Starting to think that this may be an issue for me at the moment. Having a serious exacerbation since switching from Fostair to Luforbec. I also had issues being switched from Ventolin to generic salbutamol inhaler so now back on Ventolin

Wodie profile image
Wodie

I am sure it will be different for each user.The saving is £8 odd a month per patient.

My experience has been short. I have persevered for 6 weeks with the luforbec .

Conquered the cough response to first inhalation. However, as time has progressed my asthma has deteriorated to a level I havent experienced for long time. Back on Fostair

redstar9 profile image
redstar9

I have switched back to Fostair after experiencing an extended exacerbation of my asthma. Since being back on Fostair I have felt much better and have been able to wean down off steroid tablets.

You may also like...

Fostair or Luforbec

My husband has been changed from Fostair to Luforbec by the GP. Presumably to save costs. They are...

Luforbec

problem after being switched from Fostair to Luforbec? I got changed over in December and got very

Luforbec review

negative about any changes to my asthma medication, but I am struggling with Luforbec. I use a...

Luforbec COPD

I am all for saving the NHS money but surely people’s wellbeing should come first. Has anyone else...

medical practice changing my inhaler for no apparent reason

message from my medical practice to say they are changing my inhaler from Fostair to Luforbec as...