Different Normal Peak Flow Value Scales? - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

22,474 members24,860 posts

Different Normal Peak Flow Value Scales?

5 Replies

Hello

New to forum, but not to having child with asthma.

Can I have thoughts, please.

Our child uses the Mini Wright Low Range PF meter (EN Standard 13826). At almost 4ft 5 inches tall, the Clement Clarke Normal PFV scale would suggest a predicted PEFR of 233. Our GP practice use the EMIS computer system and according to Practice Nurse, when she input our child's details, their average Peak Flow should be 260/270. Now, this is quite a bit different and obviously has implications when we are self monitoring at home with Peak Flow meter (eg they say need to speak with Nurse if PF falls below 240, yet Clement Clarke chart would suggest even 233 is an acceptable PF). Any suggestions as to why there should be such a difference?

Thanks in advance.

Read more about...
5 Replies

use this as a more accurate prediction.

clementclarke.com/products/...

Do not assume that it's 100% accurate, upto 80ltrs/min lower would still be within a normal range.

Thanks for your input. That link would be fine if it was for an adult, but we are talking about a child of under 15yrs.

yaf_user681_23350 profile image
yaf_user681_23350

Hi my Son who is 10 has always had really high peak flows 380 when well, he does lots of sports, so the charts they use are useless for us.We mark his peak flows down and use his highest as when things are well and we have a plan on what to do as the peak flow drops. If it gets to 200 we have to get him into hospital. This may seem high but he deteriorates rapidly and needs specialist help.

My peak flow is 350 my highest so we are all different. I take our peak flow meter with us to appointments. Don't let them tell you things are fine if you feel they are getting out of control, you are the best judge.After eventually getting an appointment, I have spent precious minutes arguing with GPs over peak flows when my Son was seriously ill.Ended up taking him to hospital myself where I was shouted at and told him I should have seen a doctor sooner!!Just trying to follow the rules.Now older and wiser I cut out the middle man.

Good luck

kate

Sorry, didn't realise it never went right down to 0 for age. I'd go with the value from the GP, it has a higher predicted, so you'd basically be getting help sooner when things start to go wrong.

I'll agree with the previous post that it's only a prediction, my predicted is 646, yet I have a personal best of 750. Don't go by peakflows alone though, symptoms and how you feel should also guide you.

KateMoss profile image
KateMoss

Please remember there can be a natural variation with each peak flow meter.

Perhaps take yours / your child's with you to see the asthma nurse etc

Also, check which type of meter scale is being used.

A few years ago, all meter scales were Black (UK version). All new peak flow meters should have a new scale on - the EU scale in line with .... the EU! this is usually yellow.

This will show a difference. As will any chart or software that has any variant.

Kate

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Low peak flow

I am being treated as if I have asthma since I developed a cough at the end of July 2018. I have...
Mas1 profile image

peak flow meters

Hya, Just wondering if anyone else has ever got different readings? I meant to say. I keep an eye...

Help understanding Peak Flow readings

Can someone help me understanding Peak Flow? When I use my peak flow meter I blow around 390. But...

Predicted Peak Flow

Should nurses/docs etc. use predicted peak flow or your known best peak flow when working out the...

peak flow - how often

I had asthma as a child, though 'grew out of it' and have not used any inhalers for years. Though...

Moderation team

See all
Homely2 profile image
Homely2Administrator
Lysistrata profile image
LysistrataAdministrator
ALUK_Nurses profile image
ALUK_NursesAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.