Inconsistency between peak flow meters - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

22,474 members24,860 posts

Inconsistency between peak flow meters

PaulRosedene profile image
10 Replies

I have to confess to being a bit of a nerd. I was kept twice daily records of my peak flow religiously for a couple of years. I would recommend this, even for non nerds.

But I recently had to get a new meter. The previous one was stuck full of unwanted gunk.

Lo and behold my peak flow jumped by two hundred points. All of my detailed analysis was now useless.

But which meter should I believe ?

Has anyone else found the same with their meters ?

Written by
PaulRosedene profile image
PaulRosedene
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
10 Replies
Blue-Breeze profile image
Blue-Breeze

I take my peak flow x4 a day (before and after meds) I replace my meter yearly at my GP surgery and wash the one I'm using regular. This is from the Asthma Lung site...Clean your peak flow meter by washing it in warm soapy water, rinsing it with clean water, and leaving it to air dry.

As for your predicament could it be the gunk that stop the accurate recording? Just a thought.

PaulRosedene profile image
PaulRosedene in reply toBlue-Breeze

Oh, you are good. How often do you clean it ?

Blue-Breeze profile image
Blue-Breeze in reply toPaulRosedene

They are in soak now. I should clean them more often than I do, but I do try monthly at least.

peege profile image
peege in reply toBlue-Breeze

Cripes, I've never washed mine 😬, it's years old in a drawer.

PaulRosedene profile image
PaulRosedene in reply topeege

It never occurred to me to wash the meter. But they do get a bit grimy !

lakelover profile image
lakelover

As I understand it, the change in your readings on a daily basis is more important than the level they are at. Therefore you should only worry if things get erratic on your new meter. a few years ago I had an accident & my peak flow dropped quite a lot, but is stable at this lower level & I feel just as well. The nurse commented it was low but was happy when I said what had happened & no-one has worried since.

PaulRosedene profile image
PaulRosedene in reply tolakelover

My peak flow would get to 500 on the old meter on a good day. Today I got to 780. The readings stop at 800. But I agree that it's the movement that is indicative.

L8Again profile image
L8Again in reply toPaulRosedene

I would suggest that the new meter is faulty.

Graph of peak flows
Younie profile image
Younie in reply toL8Again

Not necessarily, im Female with a prediction of 450 but my best is 750 which was confirmed through spirometry

Africanleopard profile image
AfricanleopardVerified User

Hi PaulRosedene

Different peak flow meters , even of the same manufacturers type, can give different results.

So you should always use the same meter. So once you have used your new meter for a month or so, you will be clear what your ‘best reading’ ( ie normal )for that meter is.

The key value of a peak flow meter is that it tells you when your readings are going down or fluctuating ( more than 20% indicates your asthma is out of control.

Readings below 60% of your best means you are having a severe attack and need to follow your self management plan and see a doctor urgently .

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Peak Flow Meters

Hi everyone, if you have been diagnosed with asthma, a peak flow meter could really prove to be...
Helen0909 profile image

peak flow meters

Hya, Just wondering if anyone else has ever got different readings? I meant to say. I keep an eye...

Peak Flow Meters

Does anyone else experience problems after using their peak flow meters? My best peak flow is 600...

New peak flow meter

Hello all, I hope you're all in good health. Recently my peak flow meter completely stopped...

Help understanding Peak Flow readings

Can someone help me understanding Peak Flow? When I use my peak flow meter I blow around 390. But...

Moderation team

See all
Homely2 profile image
Homely2Administrator
Lysistrata profile image
LysistrataAdministrator
ALUK_Nurses profile image
ALUK_NursesAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.