Omega 3 major risk factor: Did anyone... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,968 members39,314 posts

Omega 3 major risk factor

Tryfan profile image
20 Replies

Did anyone read report in Daily Express or as in my case from a news feed. A Dr Carlos Zapata opines that Omega 3 supplements are a major risk factor in Afib.

I have been taking Omega 3 as a supplement and recently have had more frequent attacks. Could of course be coincidental or additive the many other risk factors associated with this condition. Any Thoughts?

Written by
Tryfan profile image
Tryfan
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
20 Replies
Rainfern profile image
Rainfern

Does anyone still believe anything they read in the Daily Express?! I take plant based Omega 3 without any issues.

kitenski profile image
kitenski

From a quick google this appears to be a single persons view reported by some UK news outlets. I can't see any links to large studies, nor are his views backed up by other consultants/Drs from what I can see?

The article I just read says

These videos and messages are not intended, nor should they be taken as a medical indication that goes beyond that of your treating physician. Take note and discuss it with your specialist so that they can put it in your clinical context.”

Jajarunner profile image
Jajarunner

They will interact with blood thinners though. I have a bleeding disorder, made worse by blood thinners, dark green leafy veg and fish oil. 🙄

TillyBoss profile image
TillyBoss

I read that but thought it was because of effects anticoagulants and a fib

Tomred profile image
Tomred

I stopped taking omegas 3 about 5 years ago as had read a similar article at that time, i still have increasing afib.

YES! Once again we are all different. I have shared my story many times that I discovered that omega-3's put me into AF.

I currently have joined Dr. Davis's Inner Circle and just last night we had our zoom call with him. Just as a refresher, he is a cardiologist, turned more holistic in his approach to health.

The presentation he gave last night was on the importance of Omega 3's. It is very impressive as to what they do.

At the end of his presentation there is time for Q & A. I got to ask him why when I take a fish oil supplement that it causes me to go into AF. His answer was, that perhaps I have some Fibrosis. Which yes I could have because of having AF for many years. Yes, for some people fish oil has a negative effect.

The solution for me is to make sure I take enough magnesium and to actually eat fish when I can. There is always the risk of too much mercery of course. When eating fish you also get Tauren. I asked him could I be low in Tauren, of course how could anyone know that without testing. However, there is a possibility that could be.

Anyway, the bottom line is definitely yes, some of us cannot take an Omega 3 supplement without it affecting us and it will put us into AF.

Tryfan profile image
Tryfan in reply toPeacefulneedshelp

Thank you for your considered reply. It's only 24 hrs since I ceased. Coincidence or not. I haven't noticed any blips or ectopic beats today. I'll monitor myself over the next week and see if anything changes.

Peacefulneedshelp profile image
Peacefulneedshelp in reply toTryfan

do as I did one I suspected it was fish oil supplement. stop them for say maybe a month or two and then take one see what happens. for me I had stopped for a good 9 months and then took one. 6 hours later I was in Afib and it happened twice. several hours apart. Now I have stopped again and have not had any Afib for about another 9 months. so I will take that as a good thing.

Astrojupiter profile image
Astrojupiter

this is well know effect. Also those on blood thinners, it will enhance the effect of blood thinning. Low dose does not cause afib however. I am thinking of starting it at low dose, but my family members with afib, I recommend against it since they are on blood thinners.

HITT exercise also. I decided is not worth the risk.

Tryfan profile image
Tryfan in reply toAstrojupiter

Thank you.

Petaca profile image
Petaca

a few months ago I read an article on Dr John Day’s website about discontinuing Omega 3 as it promoted AFib.

He mentioned that he was stopping it himself.

Tryfan profile image
Tryfan in reply toPetaca

Interesting thank you. Its only 24 hrs since i ceased. Coincidence but i haven't noticed any blips or ectopics. Ill self monitor a d see what happens.

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49

Hi

I read that Omega 3 should only be increased in natural food rather than a supplement with those who are diagnosed with AF.

cheri JOY. 76. (NZ)

Tryfan profile image
Tryfan in reply toJOY2THEWORLD49

good point. I understand that fish ( which I do eat, I don't eat meat) nuts and seeds are a good source of natural Omega 3. Anything else?

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49 in reply toTryfan

Hi there

Walnuts especially, salmon especially although oily fish like trevally and kawawhai. Brazil nuts, I think seaweed.

Other important food for you beets - beetroot and the tops.

Olive Oil. Avocado Oil.

I eat lots of fish. Tuna and the huge fish could have mercury.

King Oscar Sardines best, small and tasty.

There nust be oil in banana skins - some folks eat them baked etc. green bananas have more nutrients in them . Samoan folks eat the green i n deserts etc. I use the skins on my dry skin on my legs!

Have fun finding other items of fruit and veg.

Keep up healthy eating. JOY

JOY2THEWORLD49 profile image
JOY2THEWORLD49 in reply toTryfan

Hi

Olive Oil. Virgin

Avocado Oil

JOY

Jishuang44 profile image
Jishuang44

I take Omega 3 fish oils every day along with turmeric, both of which can increase blood thinning. I also eat a lot of dark, green, leafy vegetables. I haven’t had any ill effects so far, but obviously everyone’s metabolism is different.

MisterD22 profile image
MisterD22

Sardines and Salmon, wild caught, are high in Omega 3, and low in mercury. Sardines have arsenic, no more than 1 can a day from a 1 minute search. I also saw somewhere to limit salmon to once a week, and sardines to 3/wk, so that's what I do. The internet has a lot of good and bad info. NIH, Cleveland Clinic, and livestrong have lots of info. Mayo clinic limits how much it says.

Mark

Tryfan profile image
Tryfan in reply toMisterD22

Thank you. As a fisherman in the UK eating wild salmon - you may as well say eat a Unicorn. Unfortunately wild salmon stock in the UK including Scotland are greatly depleted. Global warming, pollution, over fishing at sea and natural predation all to blame.

MisterD22 profile image
MisterD22 in reply toTryfan

I buy it in a can, the fish are caught in Alaska. :) Very convenient that way. The farmed salmon from the east coast does not have the omega 3 content of the wild fish. No preservatives at least, but some salt. The sardines/sprats come from Poland mostly, some salt in there too. Over here "fresh" fish in the grocery store means it was only thawed once, so we never really get "fresh" salmon. We fished out the sardines here, Monterey California used to have a commercial fishery.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

High Omega 3 levels and AF

This trial indicates that there is a link between high Omega 3 levels and AF: "Dose-Related AF Risk...
MarkS profile image

Apixaban and Omega 3

Has anyone had advice from their EP or GP regarding Apixaban and Omega 3 supplements.? The only...
shorttail profile image

Edoxaban and Omega 3

I am considering going onto Edoxaban, as that is the drug our Drs have been told to prescribe as...
Sixtychick profile image

omega 3 supplement

Good morning everyone. I saw my cardiologist yesterday as I’m having a new knee next week and for...
Lakky12 profile image

Too Much Omega 3 triggering AFib?

I care for a family member with an AFib history. It has recently reared its head again after...
Mulan1 profile image

Moderation team

See all
HollieAdmin profile image
HollieAdminAdministrator
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.