A quick Covid19 note.: Just a quick... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,404 members38,740 posts

A quick Covid19 note.

momist profile image
20 Replies

Just a quick post to say that I heard this morning about a friend of mine who has recovered from Covid19 about three months ago. She has cancer, and was due for an operation. She has been again tested positive for the virus, after attending the hospital for a pre-op. YOU CAN GET IT TWICE!

Be careful out there everyone.

Written by
momist profile image
momist
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
20 Replies
10gingercats profile image
10gingercats

Yes. My son and his wife thought they had it in early March and have now tested positive for it.

They are responsible people .My daughter in law thinks hers possibly came through her work in a public place even though she protects herself.

BobD profile image
BobDVolunteer

I have heard of many many apparent false positives so unless a person has been ill I am a little sceptical.

wilsond profile image
wilsond in reply toBobD

Me too Bob. Also that the test picks up traces of " dead" virus cells over the next few months .

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50 in reply toBobD

I agree with you too Bob.

KMRobbo profile image
KMRobbo in reply toBobD

bbc.co.uk/news/health-54696873

Research indicates COVID 19 antibodies decline rapidly so you can get it more than once.

meadfoot profile image
meadfoot

Sorry to hear your friend is struggling and wish them a speedy resolution where possible,

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50

So annoying for your friend. Did the covid make her poorly the first or this second time?

momist profile image
momist in reply tojeanjeannie50

Sadly, both.

jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50 in reply tomomist

That's not good to hear. Has she any idea how she caught it?

Finvola profile image
Finvola

Thank you for posting momist. Poor lady - I hope she has some more resistance to it this time.

It seems the tests pick up dead leftover virus "pieces" and come up with positive results, when in fact it has gone. There's a story of 3 guys being stuck in Florence for 61 days continually testing positive when they weren't.

Singwell profile image
Singwell

You can get any virus twice. Hopefully after the first time you develop antibodies so you fight it off more easily the second time. That's the theory behind herd immunity. Hope your friend is OK.

Ppiman profile image
Ppiman

Life must be very difficult these days for your friend, goodness me. I have read that the test can give a "false positive" in the sense that in some people it can react to antibodies or viral remnants from a past infection. If your friend isn't experiencing symptoms this second time around, then might that be the case?

Steve

MarkS profile image
MarkS

The tests for Covid have a false positive rate of between 0.8% and 4% (from The Lancet). A total of 30m tests have been carried out so far in the UK, so between 240,000 and 1.2m will be false positives.

900,000 people have tested positive so far. So the proportion of those who do not really have the virus is potentially very high.

So I think almost certainly one of your friend's tests was a false positive, so you can relax, it is very unlikely your fried caught Covid twice.

Belle11 profile image
Belle11 in reply toMarkS

As KMRobbo replied above, unfortunately research has found that immunity can wane quite fast, reported on BBC radio 4 this morning.

"Levels of protective antibodies in people wane "quite rapidly" after coronavirus infection, say researchers.

The Imperial College London team found the number of people testing positive for antibodies has fallen by 26% between June and September.

They say immunity appears to be fading and there is a risk of catching the virus multiple times."

They add that T-cells may also play a role, but warn that antibodies "tend to be highly predictive of who is protected."

bbc.co.uk/news/health-54696873

MarkS profile image
MarkS in reply toBelle11

That's true, antibodies do decline. However on the BBC World at One, they had a top immunologist on (Prof Peter Openshaw) who said that the key measure is of antibody levels in the nose and throat. The standard tests only measure antibody levels in blood plasma, as a proxy, as it's much easier. The nose and throat levels could be substantially different.

He also said that many scientists consider the T cell response to be arguably more important, and the T cell memory lasts a lot longer than antibodies.

So I come back to the point that the chance of one of the tests being a false positive is far greater than the chance of someone catching Covid twice. Having said that, it can't be ruled out, simply because we don't know enough about the immunology of Covid yet.

Belle11 profile image
Belle11 in reply toMarkS

Indeed, we don't know enough - it's wait and see.

wilsond profile image
wilsond in reply toMarkS

Thank you Mark

momist profile image
momist

Also in the news today, but not mentioned by the BBC: the number of deaths in the UK from Covid19 have doubled each fortnight for the last six weeks. That would predict well over a thousand deaths per week in two weeks time . . .

Be careful, people.

Madscientist16 profile image
Madscientist16

More and more people in the US are getting Covid twice. Not testing for it twice, getting it twice. Studies are showing that antibodies may only protect you for 3 or 4 months maximum and you can indeed get Covid again. Covid is a coronavirus which is the same family as the common cold viruses. Many people can get several colds in a season, same principle; coronavirus antibodies may only protect from re-infection for a short time. That is why vaccine studies are using a 2 injection therapy protocol about a month apart, with a potential booster shot 6 months later.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

a quick hello

I gave you all a break for a few weeks. It’s been a little bit crazy at my house. We have adopted...
DawnTX profile image

A positive note

I just thought I'd relate my husband's experience and improvement, for what it's worth, and in the...
Davesgirl profile image

Keep a note

I was doing some tidying up on the computer this morning - deleting old files and putting things in...
Mrspat profile image

A quick question about an ablation

I am due to have an ablation on Thursday morning. I understand that I will be kept in overnight....
Mo-ararat profile image

On a lighter note...

Had a scan yesterday and then saw the consultant. He confirmed that I have AF & Flutter and the...
heekle profile image

Moderation team

See all
KirstyC-Admin profile image
KirstyC-AdminAdministrator
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.