Risk vs reward in clinical trials - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,371 members28,135 posts

Risk vs reward in clinical trials

Pmann profile image
16 Replies

Morning folks,

I just finished reading my clinical protocol consent paperwork and don’t get the good warm feeling that the risk is worth the reward.

This trial is through Sarah Cannon Research and involves a first in human investigational drug called TAK 280. It utilizes an approach already in clinical use to attach T cells in your body directly to the cancer cells.

Being first in human is somewhat scary when they can’t say for sure if you will receive any real benefit from the treatment.

It is also quite arduous in that it requires weekly infusions for 14 months and I am almost a three hour drive to the clinic.

I wonder if I pass on this trial if I get black balled for others.

Thoughts and advice are appreciated.

Written by
Pmann profile image
Pmann
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
Avanat profile image
Avanat

My husband was in a Phase 2 clinical trial sponsored by Dana Farber but administered at Moffitt Cancer Center. He was told if he opted out he could still participate in others down the road. It was supposed to be a 2 year trial but he was taken out of the trial by his oncologist after 8 months because of side effects. His doctor was worried about the side effects becoming permanent. I’m happy to report they weren’t and he got over the side effects which for him was stomatitis (mouth sores) and colitis. He could still participate in another trial later but right now his cancer is stable so luckily it’s not something he has to worry about right now. Good luck with whatever you decide.

Pmann profile image
Pmann in reply toAvanat

Thanks so much

Pmann profile image
Pmann

Sage words my friend

I must admit I am playing with house money

I was diagnosed with this disease in 2000

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

It is one of many BiTE (bi-specific T-cell engager) trials now going on. One end attaches to a surface protein on the cancer cell called B7-H3 and the other end attaches to a protein on T-cells.

Here's an early trial that used a different anti-B7-H3 medicine:

nature.com/articles/s41591-...

gsun profile image
gsun in reply toTall_Allen

That is for localized cancer.

Pmann profile image
Pmann

Thanks TA that is helpful

pilot52 profile image
pilot52

I am currently in a Pfizer Trial . The paper work if you are not used to long consents are daunting. Count on your doctors opinion and not the consent. They watch you very close. If you do participate go into it with gusto and confidence. The trial team is there to administer the meds and not sure if yours are oral but comply to all instructions. If I can answer more direct questions pvt. msg . me.....The consent is an open contract which you can break at anytime. Good luck, Blue Skies and Always a Tailwind , Sky King and Penny ( woof)

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

Only thing more daunting is signing a marriage certificate..........

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n

Pmann profile image
Pmann in reply toj-o-h-n

Understood, but you can leave the trial and not pay alimony

addicted2cycling profile image
addicted2cycling in reply toPmann

Opting out = no consequences for sure.

No alimony paid out if she has ALL THE MONEY. Been a happily kept man, now Eunuch for almost 51 years.

ron_bucher profile image
ron_bucher

I don't think there is such a thing as getting "blackballed" from trials.

Stevecavill profile image
Stevecavill

a phase 1 trial is usually of very little benefit to the participants. It’s looking for safety and tolerability, rather than efficacy. It’s usually offered to people who are failing standard therapies. Do you fit in that category.

I would only do a phase 1 trial as a last resort.

Pmann profile image
Pmann in reply toStevecavill

Thanks for the comments.

I have been through most all SOC therapies. I can do chemo again.

I am on waitlist for several other trials.

This is the first one that came open.

Stevecavill profile image
Stevecavill in reply toPmann

If you have been through all the other SOC options, then a phase 1 trial could be worth a try. Ideally phase 2 or 3 is better, because at this stage they don’t know what dose to use, and that’s what they test on you. But it’s probably better than nothing. And if the toxic effects are too high they will take you off the drug anyway.

Good luck.

Brysonal profile image
Brysonal

I did a phase 1 vaccine trial as both my MOs said it wouldn’t negatively impact on my cancer. It was first in human but I was number 12 so not as brave as number 1

I wanted early access to the vaccine at maximum dose which I got by being the lady of the 1a cohort.

I wouldn’t have done one of the riskier trials as currently my cancer is undetectable/ NED so I relied on my Mos input that it was a low risk type

inter100 profile image
inter100

I have done a little research about TAK 280, and bi-specific T-cell engagers.Here's what I came across

pharmaceutical-technology.c...

not sure of the accuracy of the above, I'm always suspicious when asked to buy reports

nature.com/articles/s41591-...

takedaoncology.com/science/...

the one above gives some details of other trials the company is involved in.

cancer.gov/publications/dic...

Life changing decisions are hard to make. Research as much as you can and see if that "warm feeling" emerges

Tall_Allen has provided details of similar therapies, though not exactly the same , I am sure it will give insight when including them in your research🙏

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Immunology clinical trial vs. Radiation?

Surgery in 2009, biochemical recurrence beginning 2017, and my slow-rising PSA is now up to 0.63,...
KeyboardGuy profile image

Treatment naïve and clinical trials

Treatment naïve and clinical trials.... I am asking this question for a friend. Does anyone here...
Farmhand profile image

AKT inhibitors - Clinical Trials

As included in previous update, I am now CRPC. Uro has added Cosodex (50mg per day) to my Zolodex...
Hazard profile image

Cancer-killing virus ( CF33-hNIS ) - Human trials begin ! today

So today ( 24-05-2022 ) at last , a human clinical trial of something that looks promising -...
raoulmaher profile image

Triplet Regimen vs Clinical Trial (Pluvicto)

I was recently diagnosed with advanced prostate cancer with diffuse bone metastases (March 20th). I...
Bruce98 profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.