Medical OR chemical castration - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,045 members26,252 posts

Medical OR chemical castration

Stevegr profile image
17 Replies

Hi All,

Ok I am 79 and still in great physical condition. PR and ADT for 2 years. To date no unusual physical side effects other than zero sex drive. It looks as thought I will be on ADT until I die. PSA increasing monthly so I will try other chemicals.

I want to remain in good shape until my number is up. My question is should I get medical castration to reduce the side effect of extended ADT injections or continue with the ADT.

Does medical have less side effects? I understand that I may also need a penal implant.

Written by
Stevegr profile image
Stevegr
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
17 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

In a retrospective study, compared with those treated with GnRH agonist (like Lupron), patients who received an orchiectomy had significantly lower risks of experiencing:

• any fractures (-23%)

• peripheral arterial disease (-35%), and

• cardiac-related complications (-26%) .

• no statistically significant difference for diabetes and cognitive disorders.

GnRH antagonists (like degarelix or relugolix) seem to be more similar to orchiectomy than to GnRH agonists in cardiovascular side effects.

jamanetwork.com/journals/ja...

However, in a randomized clinical trial, fat accumulation was higher for orchiectomy :

bjui-journals.onlinelibrary...

Chemical castration may get testosterone levels lower:

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Stevegr profile image
Stevegr in reply to Tall_Allen

I appreciate your feedback and as with life I will have to wait & see what I will eventually decide. The fact that I have had none of the side effects from ADT weigh high on my decision

addicted2cycling profile image
addicted2cycling in reply to Stevegr

April 2015 my urologist began explaining the ADT Drugs that were my option. Before he could complete HIS JOB I stopped him and said "I did not want DRUGS put in my body, I wanted the offending BOYS REMOVED." 24 hours later my Orchiectomy was completed. Almost 65 then and 73 now with not a single regret.

caveat - My treatment doctor(NOT the urologist but Dr. Gary Onik) performed his job and in 2016 prescribed (contrary to SOC GL10 treatment protocol) testosterone injections.

spencoid2 profile image
spencoid2 in reply to addicted2cycling

so nice cycling without balls no regrets here either

addicted2cycling profile image
addicted2cycling in reply to spencoid2

My longest nut-less ride was in 2016 of 307 miles in under 20 hours

spencoid2 profile image
spencoid2 in reply to addicted2cycling

how long would it have been if you were still nutted?

in reply to spencoid2

LOL!

LifeQuality profile image
LifeQuality in reply to Tall_Allen

Tall_Allen, I'm wondering what the studies you cited here convinced YOU to do. Does it come down to whether you're more worried about fractures, arterial disease, and cardiac complications vs. fat accumulation and lower testosterone levels?

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to LifeQuality

I didn't have to make that decision. Every man can only decide for himself, given what is known.

Ian99 profile image
Ian99

Re your concern about bone health, you don’t mention it but a Dexa scan is usually recommended.

Stevegr profile image
Stevegr in reply to Ian99

Yes I did all ok . Due for another this year.

FourString profile image
FourString

Had my orchiectomy immediately upon diagnosis. Only regret is that I didn’t get on Estradiol patches immediately. Talked my MO into that 5 yrs later.

bean1008 profile image
bean1008

I’ve had chronic testicular pain since my RP in 2019. I’ve been so tempted to do the orchiectomy! My MO said I could drop the current Lupron (3 years now) but would stay on Abiraterone. And that the pain I’m having is likely nerve pain which could continue even if I had surgery…kind of like phantom syndrome. So I drug my feet on doing it.

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

Try the Medical first, if that doesn't work go for the Chemical.....

At 79 years old you're asking about a penal implant? Excuse me sir, but I'll have what for you're smoking.........

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Sunday 10/29/2023 3:14 PM DST

Stevegr profile image
Stevegr in reply to j-o-h-n

No need for the blow either. I have been active sexually at least 2x a week up until I started the ADT 2 years ago. My wife is also close to my age & we live a very healthy happy life. We do not look or feel our age EVER and I believe this is due to not living in the USA for the past 35 years and never eating any fast or packaged foods. I have been very close to calling all this drug related therapy quits and letting the cards fall where they may.

j-o-h-n profile image
j-o-h-n

Well Stefanos, I think you know I'm an American Greek and understand that eating Hellenic style is good for your "temper"..... Yiasou....

I will tell you a short and a real story/ using phonetic Greek) (which may make you smile). I was born here and spoke Greek at home (and went to Greek school in NYC) so my Greek was so/so "spasmena" (Broken Greek). Well we had a relative here in the US in his early fifties (Michali) a bachelor who decided to have a "proxenia" (arranged marriage /introduction in Greek) marriage with a woman he was fixed up with who lived in Greece. So he travels back to Greece, marries the woman and brings her here to the US. So one day that newly arrived woman (without Michali) visits my Meterra to meet her for the very first time.

So as I came home from school (14/15 years old?) I walked into the Living Room where that lady who just got married and my mother were having Turkish coffee. So as my mother taught me to be a well manured Greek boy I said hello to the woman and I meant to say "pous kannie oh Michalis? (what's/how is Michalis?)" however I added one little word that changed the whole sentence/meaning of what I meant to say. Instead I said "pous "TO" kannie oh Michalis?" .

The woman stood there aghast as did my Mom. And me standing there trying to figure out what did I say that was so bad.....Anyway take care and to Ms. Stevegr "pous TO kannie oh Stefanos?

Good Luck, Good Health and Good Humor.

j-o-h-n Sunday 10/29/2023 5:43 PM DST

Stevegr profile image
Stevegr in reply to j-o-h-n

Yes, I can REALLY relate to that as I still do the same even after all these years. Nice to hear from you,

You may also like...

Orchiectomy rather than chemical castration?

to recover and take another PSA to see if these treatments were effective. If they were not, he...

Medical castration vs actual castration.

I have been reading about Lupron and other medical treatments and it raises the question of why not...

Castrate-resistant medication options?

Taxotere? I am quite nervous about the side effects and whether they will be tolerable :( thank u...

Castrate Resistant Pre-Indicator

While you were on ADT, did you notice fewer or shorter term side effects to the shots as your...

Castration Resistance

that I am castration resistant? Will my PSA suddenly start escalating rapidly? Will my PSA just...