Study says orchiectomy has higher ris... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,045 members26,252 posts

Study says orchiectomy has higher risks for fracture than chemical castration. I wonder why.

rsgdmd profile image
7 Replies

empr.com/home/news/prostate...

Written by
rsgdmd profile image
rsgdmd
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
7 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

Association is not causation.

rsgdmd profile image
rsgdmd in reply to Tall_Allen

Agreed, but the differences were pretty significant.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to rsgdmd

It is "pretty significant" that only men get PCa but women never do. But sex doesn't cause PCa. Retrospective studies like that are useless because of unmeasured confounders.

addicted2cycling profile image
addicted2cycling in reply to rsgdmd

WAS CASTRATED 8 years ago coming up in April. Just had another DEXA and numbers ONLY SLIGHTLY WORSE than results 7 years ago 1/2016. Osteopenia in 2016 and now so not at osteoporosis yet.

Just sayin -- Remaining active with good diet helps.

April 2020 I was hit by a WILD HOG while bicycling with results from crash = 2 cracked ribs + cracked scapula + punctured lung + trauma to left shoulder at almost age = 70yrs.

July 2022 ( 16 days after my 72nd birthday) another Wild Hog T-boned me into my left leg fracturing the Tibia. VERY HARD HIT then a face plant crash onto street with only the fracture a cause for concern. Using a *not too well designed knee scooter* I managed to FALL OVER 3 times WITHOUT FURTHER INJURY other than "You DUMB ASS" yelling at myself.

p.s. - only months after last Hog Hit I had to clean -up 2 yards following Hurricane IAN with Tibia still not healed. Managed to trip on debris and fall a few times without issues. So much for the DOWN FALL results caused by castration, at least in my situation. 🤔

Vangogh1961 profile image
Vangogh1961

That's a pretty old study, but I prefer to walk to keep my bones strong and the orchiectomy to prevent heart disease.

MateoBeach profile image
MateoBeach

In two words, you are seeing “selection bias”. Those who choose orchiectomy have self selected and perceive they will never come off ADT so may reflect a more advanced disease population.

in reply to MateoBeach

Thays why I did it ! I was told shots for life . ✌️

You may also like...

Orchiectomy rather than chemical castration?

Supplementing Vitamin D has no effect on fracture risk

supplement Vitamin D in the hope of reducing fracture risk due to ADT-induced osteoporosis. It...

I Always Wondered Why My Onco Carries A Brown Paper Bag

I wonder why I have a few drops of blood after I pee.

I had high dose radiation seeds put into the prostate for a few (can't remember how long they left...

A 6 minute watch. I can back up most of what he says with multiple trials and studies and research.

Does Sugar Feed Prostate Cancer? Does Fatty/Adipose Tissue Attract Cancer? | Mark Moyad, MD, MPH -...