next step more Lupron?: I just... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,037 members26,217 posts

next step more Lupron?

GJ65 profile image
GJ65
31 Replies

I just finished 38 rounds of radiation to the pelvic bed and abdominal lymph nodes. My last Lupron shot will be out of my system in December, and I am taking Xtandi. My last PSA was 0, and testosterone was 7. Side effects include extreme fatigue and sciatica pain.

I am scheduled to see my urologist again in December to receive a second Lupron injection. I would like to see if the radiation was effective and take a break from the medication. Is there any reason not to take a break and restart Lupron and Xtandi if my numbers start going back up? Suggestions ?

Written by
GJ65 profile image
GJ65
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
31 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

Yes, there is a reason and it is huge. You are trying to get a curative therapy with limited-term adjuvant hormonal therapy to assist the radiation therapy you had. The last thing you want to do is stop and restart the hormonal therapy just so you can see what happens. You wouldn't like what happens.

It would be similar to stopping and restarting antibiotics for a bacterial infection. It would guarantee failure by allowing the most resistant bacteria to survive and multiply.

Similarly, the most vulnerable cancer cells are killed off first by radiation and hormone therapy, while the most resistant cancer cells are killed off only with continuous long-term use of hormonal therapy. Stop the hormonal therapy too soon and you allow the most resistant cells to take over.

Lymph node metastases may be cured by 2-3 years of adjuvant hormonal treatment. Maybe you can get away with just 2 years because you are adding Xtandi. Abdominal lymph nodes are at the verge of escaping systemically - now is not the time to cut back on treatment.

allie2020 profile image
allie2020 in reply to Tall_Allen

What an amazingly great explanation by Tall_Allen. I am so impressed with those rare individuals who can take very complex situations and make them easily understandable. Love the analogy with antibiotics for a bacterial infection. GJ, sounds like you need to bite the bullet, stay with the Lupron and go for the cure!

in reply to allie2020

Bravo!

GJ65 profile image
GJ65 in reply to Tall_Allen

Thank you for a great explanation! You are very easy to understand. All of my questions come to me once I leave the doctor’s office.

Andy1569 profile image
Andy1569 in reply to Tall_Allen

Is every 3 mo. Lupron injection better than every 6 mo. injections. I'm due for my next (second) 6 mo. injection Nov. 1st.?

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Andy1569

Same.

Andy1569 profile image
Andy1569 in reply to Tall_Allen

I thought so.

Thank You.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Tall_Allen

"GnRH agonist depot formulations have evolved to offer treatment intervals of 1, 3, 4, and 6 months, all of which offer similarly acceptable safety and efficacy profiles."

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

sciaticaman profile image
sciaticaman in reply to Andy1569

I was diagnosed as “unfavorable intermediate risk” so my doctor put me on 6 months of Lupron depot as well as radiation. Several radiation oncologists thought I should be more correctly designated as “favorable intermediate risk” because there was no evidence of cancer outside of my prostate and my PSA and Gleason put me in the favorable category. Of course the difference between these two classifications is one gets ADT and the other does not. Despite the differences of opinions by these doctors, my oncologist recommended being very conservative with 6 months of Lupron. My side effects were pretty bad so it was good that I had the 6 month depot shot. Otherwise, I may have elected to stop the ADT midstream or try some other ADT besides Lupron. I did get sciatica, muscle and joint pain and there were days when I could hardly walk. Now since I am off the drug and am recovering slowly and most of my side effects are a distant nightmare, I can say I was glad That I took the full treatment of 6 months Lupron. So far (and I know it is early) I am still hoping for a cure. My T level is almost 500 and my muscles are coming back with a lot of help from continued weight training. My last PSA was 0.07 If it stays that low, I will credit it to electing to take ADT even though I had many days of misery on that drug. However, if my PSA goes up I am hoping by that time research efforts will come up with something better than Lupron.

Gabby643 profile image
Gabby643 in reply to Tall_Allen

thanks T _A

in reply to Tall_Allen

Bravo!

Papillon2 profile image
Papillon2 in reply to Tall_Allen

Priceless!

Huzzah1 profile image
Huzzah1

I totally agree with TA, as tough as it is, staying the course is what's important. You said you were going to to see your Uro, don't you have a medical oncologist who is driving your care? When my journey started, it was highly advised by everyone, including my Uro to have an oncologist as the main person as cancer is their specialty.

GJ65 profile image
GJ65 in reply to Huzzah1

I have a MO and he agrees with continuing Lupron.

in reply to GJ65

Stay the course! Especially , if it is working!

cesces profile image
cesces

1. You never fully kill the prostate cancers off totally.

The theoretical mathematical research tells us if you are fighting a mutating epidemic or a mutating cancer... you do best by allocating all your resources in punctuated "shock and awe" attacks. That leaves a smaller population to grow back and start mutating.

The clinical trials research backs this up. Sequential escalation of treatments is now out of date and earlier use of multiple concurrent treatments are what the centers of excellence are doing.

You won a battle. To win the war you need to kill as many of those deadender prostate cancer cells. It makes them takes longer to come back and develop mutation workarounds to your treatment.

2. When you do lupron shots, 1 month shots are better 3 month shots, and 3 month shots are better 6 month shots.

Don't let the doc talk you into 6 month shots.

3. My doc only kept me going for an additional 18 months. In retrospect I think 3 years would have been better.

But I would specifically as Tall_Allen how long you should keep it up.

And I think it would even make sense to add something to the cocktail.

lokibear0803 profile image
lokibear0803 in reply to cesces

Why would 1-month shots be better than 3-month? Thanks!

Andy1569 profile image
Andy1569 in reply to cesces

Your statement is not accurate.

"2. When you do lupron shots, 1 month shots are better 3 month shots, and 3 month shots are better 6 month shots."

cesces profile image
cesces in reply to Andy1569

It has something to do about maintaining better control over maintenance of blood levels of the active ingredient.

Its easier to do with short periods of time, than for long periods of time.

cesces profile image
cesces in reply to Andy1569

it's something I learned about in these forums.

It stands to reason that one should be better than the other. I can imagine mechanisms going either way.

If I am wrong, would you be kind enough to do a stand alone posting, citing some evidence in support of it, one way or another.

Thanks

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to cesces

Sorry to interrupt- I usually don't, but I had to correct all this misinformation that you are stating as fact rather than your personal (ill-informed) opinions. 1 and 2 have no basis in fact. 1. Many are cured by exactly the kind of treatment the OP is getting. 2. This is just incorrect.

cesces profile image
cesces in reply to Tall_Allen

TA

I will stand corrected.

But if possible, I sure would value seeing hard data on this subject: Difference in the Performance Envelopes of 1 Month, 3 Month and 6 Month Lupron Shots.

My recollection of my original source, was someone on this forum said he had an informal discussion with an employee of the manufacturer of Lupron. That employee said that the short term shots were better able to maintain stable serum levels.

There must exist serum level performance envelopes comparing the serum level performance before and after the end date of 1 month, 3 month, and 6 month shots.

Pretty much all prostate cancer patients end up taking Lupron (or equivalent shots).

So I think this is an important subject to most of us.

Have you ever seen or heard of hard data on this subject that is publicly available?

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to cesces

Lots of misinformation from hearsay. They wouldn't offer it if it weren't equivalent. Here's some hard core data:

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

Shorehousejam profile image
Shorehousejam in reply to Tall_Allen

My apologies for cutting in here to asked Tall_Allen a question, my husband suffers from sever plaque psoriasis, dx 07/01/2022…he just started Firmagon 07/06/2022 and Zytiga with Prednisone 07/20/2022

He was offered Lupron last appointment 9/13/2022

Lupron in studies, is shown to cause sever plague psoriasis flares and studies have shown this issue, plus there are other issues with the use of Lupron.

His glucose levels were high especially during and after the 10 days after his first chemotherapy docetaxel infusion, and had an epic head to toe, severe psoriasis plaque flare

We assume from the docetaxel chemotherapy

His MO was surprised

His mother is a diabetic

He has brca that blm bloom

Metformin has been shown to be used and prescribed with prostate cancer and also new studies have shown to treat sever psoriasis

Do you have any knowledge on this?

FYI

He was on Tremfya for three years, which is trials caused prostate and breast cancer, he is Not on any pills or injections for psoriasis because they are immune suppressants…

He was on Stelera before that for years

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Shorehousejam

Sorry, I don't know much about psoriasis. I suggest you talk to a rheumatologist.

Shorehousejam profile image
Shorehousejam in reply to Tall_Allen

I was referring to Metformin being prescribed for prostate cancer

Shorehousejam profile image
Shorehousejam in reply to Shorehousejam

I started a new thread on this

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to Shorehousejam

So far, the best evidence is that it does nothing for prostate cancer.

timotur profile image
timotur in reply to cesces

Ceces, I looked into the difference between monthly and 3/6-month shots, and there is data that shows the serum level of Lupron is much higher initially and at 4 weeks with the longer term shots. So if you are looking for lower SE's monthly shots may be better., eg the monthly shot has less than half the serum level at 4 hours and 4 weeks as shown below, but there aren't any RCT's that would support one dose is superior ovr another.

__________________

Absorption

LUPRON DEPOT 7.5 mg for 1-Month Administration

Following a single injection of LUPRON DEPOT 7.5 mg for 1-month administration to patients, mean plasma measured concentrations were 20 ng/mL at 4 hours and 0.36 ng/mL at 4 weeks. However, intact leuprolide and an inactive major metabolite could not be distinguished by the assay which was employed in the study.

LUPRON DEPOT 22.5 mg for 3-Month Administration

Following a single injection of LUPRON DEPOT 22.5 mg for 3-month administration in patients, mean peak plasma concentrations were 48.9 ng/mL at 4 hours and then declined to 0.67 ng/mL at 12 weeks. Leuprolide appeared to be released at a constant rate following the onset of steady-state concentrations during the third week after dosing, providing steady plasma concentrations through the 12-week dosing interval. However, intact leuprolide and an inactive major metabolite could not be distinguished by the assay which was employed in the study. The initial burst, followed by a decline to a steady-state concentration, was similar to the release pattern seen with the monthly formulation.

LUPRON DEPOT 30 mg for 4-Month Administration

Following a single injection of LUPRON DEPOT 30 mg for 4-month administration in sixteen orchiectomized prostate cancer patients, mean plasma concentrations were 59.3 ng/mL at 4 hours and then declined to 0.30 ng/mL at 16 weeks. Mean plasma concentrations from weeks 3.5 to 16 was 0.44 ± 0.20 ng/mL (range: 0.20-1.06). Leuprolide appeared to be released at a constant rate following the onset of steady-state concentrations during the fourth week after dosing, providing steady plasma concentrations throughout the 16-week dosing interval. However, intact leuprolide and an inactive major metabolite could not be distinguished by the assay which was employed in the study. The initial burst, followed by a decline to a steady-state concentration, was similar to the release pattern seen with the other depot formulations.

LUPRON DEPOT 45 mg for 6-Month Administration

Following a single injection of LUPRON DEPOT 45 mg for 6-month administration in 26 prostate cancer patients, mean peak plasma concentration of 6.7 ng/mL was observed at 2 hours and then declined to 0.07 ng/mL at 24 weeks. Leuprolide appeared to be released continuously following the onset of steady-state concentrations during the third week after dosing providing steady plasma concentrations through the 24-week dosing interval. The initial burst, followed by a decline to a steady-state concentration, was similar to the release pattern seen with the other depot formulations. In this study, mean plasma concentration-time profiles were similar after the first and second dose

Wdoug profile image
Wdoug

As my personal experience shows, TA is so correct. I was inconvenienced by 3 1/2 years of Lupron, and now almost 7 years out from diagnosis with T 300-350 and PSA at .03. Don't know what would've happened if I'd bounced around in ADT -- but only can say I'm happy where I am -- albeit 7 years older. Stick it out!

I’d say yes! There is a reason not to bow out early of Lupron or adt . It could extend your life? You are so young . I was 53 and did 8 weeks imrt with Lupron and another adt test drug . Test failed and was terminated .I kept on it until a few months ago . I went clear with no Psa and 3T right after imrt . At two years I chopped the boys and dropped the lupron. I just stopped taking the test drug 4 months ago . My point is that I was told “shots for life .”! But never ever did any mo tell me to stop adt .. .. I got sarcopenia and osteopenia no strength endurance or stamina . But , I don’t have have pc chomping me down presently like I did over 7 yrs ago …. “ Cancer free “ is an oxymoron after a #4 pc dx.. nuttin free about it . Read Magnus 64 here , over two decades fighting it! We pay the piper if we survive this at all . This shadow can lurk within us for years.. not a pleasant thought . Some men think they’re going to recapture the old me ,you know? Get the t back and feel good again . The best that we can hope for is to stay under the radar for as long as possible . I reckon it to being in the eye of this storm .. Good luck young man . I’m now 61 myself . Being so young you could see a cure.. ? Hang in there .

You may also like...

Failing Lupron? What's next?

when my dad was diagnosed his PSA was 257 with only a single lymph node outside the prostate...

Help on next step - Chemo or Xtandi?

size and number of the subcentimeter left paraaortic, bilateral iliac chain and pelvic lymph nodes...

Lupron lifespan and just a little more!

2 weeks since my last. I am also taking abiraterone concurrently. I am also seeing a really good...

Confused on next step

found a very few ext. lymph node hot spots. Each time did a 3-month Lupron shot + Casodex + SBRT...

What’s Next After Lupron and Aberaterone?

after Dx along with a bunch of lymph nodes. Basically, I have been on Lupron and Aberaterone for...