Hormone therapy can make prostate can... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,056 members26,262 posts

Hormone therapy can make prostate cancer worse, study finds

Claud68 profile image
24 Replies

Searching another study I just found this one. Maybe it was yet discussed here, but I think it is very very interesting for those who haven't seen it.

sciencedaily.com/releases/2...

Are there new findings about the simple blood test measuring glutamine to predict when therapy resistance will occur?

Written by
Claud68 profile image
Claud68
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
24 Replies

The consequence of successfully treating cancer is that the surviving cancer cells are resistant to the treatment. So as we successfully treat the cancer, it becomes more aggressive. This has been used by some to "prove" that treatments are bad since they only make the cancer more aggressive.

The goal of treatment is to extend life, not to keep the cancer from becoming more aggressive. Metastatic cancer will eventually find a way around every treatment we throw at it, but the alternative is dying sooner.

LearnAll profile image
LearnAll in reply to

Its not necessary that we have to let cancer become aggressive. The problem is that we have beenblocking only one path of cancer growth that is androgen path. More research is needed to block all major paths of cancer progression simultaneously . Recent study about role of prolactin in cancer progression is a good step in right direction.. Sometimes I think "who wants a real cure...they just want to peddle their exremely expensive semi cures to keep their economy going by keeping the patient alive and sick and bankrupt families." First reseach should be about these multiple pathways of progression and a combination of meds to block all major pathways.

Claud68 profile image
Claud68 in reply to LearnAll

sciencedaily.com/releases/2...

For advanced PCa the patients should systematically undergo a genetic testing before they take some ADT, like abiraterone, without knowing if it will not cause more illness .

packfan profile image
packfan

I thought the interesting part was:

"One possible reason for that resistance, the study indicated, appears to be that the therapy causes some adenocarcinoma cells to become neuroendocrine cancer-type cells."

timotur profile image
timotur

This was discussed in this study showing an association between Zytiga and "treatment emergent" form of neuroendocrine small-cell PCa in about 20% of participants.

oncologypro.esmo.org/Oncolo...

“Can”? .......Anything “Can” happen. Luckily for me ,I’m one that has been given some years of life extended by adt.. it ain’t no party ... but I’m here when I don’t think I would have been without the dreaded adt..

in reply to

Right. We can't be worrying about the disease we "might" get later when we have to fight the disease we have now.

Some of these arguments remind of people who say, "Don't get radiation or chemotherapy because that causes cancer later" or "Big Pharma is just keeping us alive so they can make more money!"

in reply to

No bull ! What they did to me is not offend done. My perspective was survival by any means. I was given only 50/50 to survive first year. I ran with the ball. Thank God I’m stilling doing as well as I am . Only the one that has had the tentacles of apc choking him out , can understand ...fear of treatments NO Way fear apc eating you for lunch . It’s a tuff bastard . We must become grizzled mentally to live with this fiend .. hahaha. 😂when we were told that apc thrives on T I said chop em off.. anything to get the upper hand( albeit only temporarily) ..We are having good days as of late . No complaints for me. I hope that you’re feeling well .. 😎✌️

in reply to

Amen Whimpy

in reply to

Nobody has answers for APC . We are all fishing 🎣

Hi Claude:

Very interesting article. It did not say at what level the Glutamine reading is when it indicates the resistance is failing. Do you know?

Thanks,

TC

Claud68 profile image
Claud68 in reply to

No, I found this study incidentally, but if you know that you are Gleason 9 or 10, you can be almost sure that you could be already castration resistant several months after starting ADT.

Thus it would be interesting to start other therapies from the beginning if a blood test indicates a bad glutamine level and predicts when therapy resistance could occur with an ADT.

Maybe this test exists now?

in reply to Claud68

Thanks - I will keep track of my glutamine.

Appreciate the article.

TC

Published in 2005 by Robert Amato and Haby Henery, two Metastatic Prostate Cancer Researchers. Their working Hypothesis:

“Recently, chemotherapy is being reported to show a survival advantage. The stage is set for chemotherapy to be given earlier in men with prostate cancer. As a working hypothesis, transformation from an androgen-dependent to an androgen-independent phenotype is mediated by the expansion of an androgen-independent clone already present at the time of androgen deprivation. If this model is correct, then it would be desirable to bring treatment to bear on the androgen-independent component when the corresponding tumor burden is minimal. We view the androgen-independent component as analogous to “microscopic residual” or micro-metastatic disease for which adjuvant chemotherapy has shown to be effective in other contexts.”

As a result, Chemotherapy and ADT are usually given at the same time.

Research continues; sometimes in different directions.

GD

Sandy752 profile image
Sandy752

With Gleason of 7 (4-3) and 10 of 12 samples cancerous, I had 40 doses of external-beam radiation which failed to cure me. I went on ADT (Lupron). Have been on it and nothing else for six years. Latest PSA reading was .22.

Hirsch profile image
Hirsch in reply to Sandy752

Radiation not always effective

in reply to Hirsch

But six years is something beyond the bad stats .

Hirsch profile image
Hirsch in reply to

Probably the lupron

in reply to Hirsch

Agreed !

Geoff22 profile image
Geoff22 in reply to Sandy752

Do you find that side effects from ADT build over time

in reply to Geoff22

I suffered initially from adt but as time goes on I’m adjusting to the new diminished me .. I’m happy to be alive. Take care

Sandy752 profile image
Sandy752 in reply to Geoff22

The fatigue has gotten worse overtime but I find that walking a lot and maintaining my weight helps. Hot flashes are not as intense or as long was they were about 5 years ago.

Geoff22 profile image
Geoff22 in reply to Sandy752

Did you get any "holidays" during the 6 years

Sandy752 profile image
Sandy752 in reply to Geoff22

No. Radiation oncologist never suggested it. I chose not to raise the issue because I'm so pleased the Lupron has continued to work.

You may also like...

Prostate cancer has returned, considering experimental therapy (if I can get it).

ten quarters. Sept. 2018, PSA reached 1.43, was placed on Lupron in Oct. 2018, will have 40...

Prostate Cancer Therapy:

Prostate Cancer Therapy: I'm new and recently diagnosed with prostate cancer. Urologist only wants...

New study validates intermittent hormone therapy

video titled 'New study validates intermittent hormone therapy'. So, just search 'PCRI' in YouTube

Depression from 2nd-generation hormone therapy is worse

I found a JAMA paper on the NIH website titled: Association of Second-generation Antiandrogens...

Combination therapy in metastatic hormone-sensitive prostate cancer: is three a crowd?

quite new, have you seen this already This is for Hormone sensitive men....