Ga-68 PSMA-PET scan result vs Biopsy - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

21,007 members26,183 posts

Ga-68 PSMA-PET scan result vs Biopsy

timotur profile image
9 Replies

Just received results of a Ga-68 PSMA PET scan with a stage of T2u(RM) N1(PS) M0, translated meaning stage 2, organ confined, unifocal, right-medial with LN involvement in the presacral LN.

Contrasted with a CDUS-biopsy of T3b + ISV extracap extension, GL 7 (3+4), 55% both lobes.

With the PSMA scan, the presacral LN was barely detectable at SUVmax of 3.3, which is right at the cutoff, so it may or not be a false positive. (SUVmax, statistical uptake value-- a statistical measure to determine significance based on the number of pixels and shape of the image).

What's interesting to me is that the PSMA scan did not pick up the CDUS biopsy-indicated SV involvement, and only indicated only a unifocal tumor versus a bi-lobe tumor.

Later this week, a mpMRI will be done, maybe shed more light on this.

Written by
timotur profile image
timotur
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
9 Replies
Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen

It's not established when PSMA begins to appear in prostate cancer cells. Its use in staging is also far from established. The biopsy is more definitive than any imaging. I think you have to treat as high risk with N1. Why are you continuing to have a scan rather than treatment?

timotur profile image
timotur in reply to Tall_Allen

It's all part of staging at UCLA Brachy department. Lots of lag time getting all the prerequisite tests and appointments with Onc (Chang), MO (Scholz), MRI, and PET. Things should speed up after the mpMRI done this week.

I'm reading that PSMA scan is established and very useful tool in staging combined with mpMRI, but no comparisons I've seen with biopsy results, in other words, has anyone see a divergence in pre-tx staging between a guided-biopsy and a PSMA PET scan?

translational-medicine.biom...

researchgate.net/publicatio...

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

urotoday.com/recent-abstrac...

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to timotur

i would never characterize PSMA as "established" or "very useful" for staging of T3 cancer. Quite the opposite. Mpmri seems to be good for staging T3b but not T3a. The question is - what is the point of all these scans anyway? It sounds like you will be getting whole pelvic external beam with a brachy boost to the prostate anyway. I'm sure your doctors are grateful for increasing their billing.

timotur profile image
timotur in reply to Tall_Allen

Yes, UCLA tx plan is for BB + EBRT + 18mosHT. As you know, a T3b biopsy doesn't say anything about bone mets, which is the point of the PSMA scan. If there are bone mets in pre-tx, I assume it changes the MO's choice on HT tx plan (length, dose, drug), but not change the planned BB + EBRT. I asked Dr. Chang if there is a cutoff on number of bone mets to go/no-go with BB + EBRT, he said no. (I had read somewhere the general cutoff is three bone mets to go directly to systemic tx and forego gland tx.) I assume mpMRI will confirm the CDUS-biopsy id of the +SV, but my question is, why didn't PSMA pick up the SV GL-7 piece or the two-lobe involvement, and whether anyone has seen this before in tx-planning stage? At PSA 29, a PSMA scan should be sensitive enough to pick up everything the biopsy did if everything I read aligns correctly.

Tall_Allen profile image
Tall_Allen in reply to timotur

You are right that the cut-off is 3 bone mets. Possibly Dr Chang has not yet seen the newest STAMPEDE trial. Maybe send him this link:

thelancet.com/action/showPd...

But it's moot, since no bone mets were detected.

PSMA scans are probably very good at picking up metastases, but the point I was trying to make was that no one knows how good they are at picking up cancer in the pre-metastatic stage. It should only be used to detect distant mets (N1 or M1) but not to find cancer in and around the capsule. UCLA, NIH and a few others are trying to find out more about its ability to detect cancer in the high risk prostate.

Blackpatch profile image
Blackpatch in reply to timotur

Hello Timotur

I was pT3b with SVI on both sides and 2.5mm ECE, but the pre-surgery PSMA didn’t pick up either the ECE or SCVI - admittedly, my PSA was only around 15 cf your 29, but I guess the point is that PSMA PET isn’t all that great for fine detail close to the prostate. It may well be that the presence of so much PSMA in the prostate reduces the effective dynamic range in the proximal area, but I’m just guessing.

Stuart

timotur profile image
timotur in reply to Blackpatch

Stuart, ok, thanks for responding. I agree with your thought that the intensity of the PSMA at the gland reduces the dynamic range around the prostate. As a former comm engineer, it’s similar to the dynamic range of a receiver that is reduced in the presence of strong adjacent signals and weak signal detection is compromised. The range of PSMA expression was SUVmax of 21 at the gland, and 3.4 at the mesorectal lymph node, quite a difference.

tennis4life profile image
tennis4life

Can you tell me what hospital did your PSMA PET?

timotur profile image
timotur in reply to tennis4life

Yes, it was at UCLA, costing about $2450 out of pocket. The CT portion of the exam may be reimbursable, checking on that.

You may also like...

68 Ga-PSMA scans available in USA?

trying to determine if it possible to get a 68 Ga-PSMA-11 scan done here in the USA now outside of...

PSMA 68 Galleon Pet Ct Scan

Checking on trying to get the new 68 Galleon Pet Ct scan PSMA that is only offered at a few...

FDA approves Ga-68-PSMA PET scans only at UCSF and UCLA

candidates for salvage therapy. Since the Ga-68-PSMA PET scan for these purposes has already been...

What are the side effects of the GA 68 PSMA PET Scan

drop due to the PSMA PET scan? In general, what are the side effects of the PSMA PET scan? Thanks

UCLA is expanding access to the Ga-68-PSMA-11 PET scan

access to the PET scan until the FDA approves it, hopefully by this summer. The PET scan is...