Looking for understanding, not advice. - Above & Beyond - ...

Above & Beyond - Mental Health

5,483 members1,510 posts

Looking for understanding, not advice.

Iain2017 profile image
4 Replies

Do you ever feel that when you talk to friends all they want to do is offer advice, but in-fact what you are actually looking for is just somebody to talk to who will listen and understand? Sometimes I feel worse because I don't feel understood, and that is difficult. Sometimes I may want advice and sometimes it is unnecessary.

Written by
Iain2017 profile image
Iain2017
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
4 Replies
chloe40 profile image
chloe40Administrator

Hello there Iain2017

I do indeed know what you mean. We all need to offload sometimes to someone who empathises or just a friendly shoulder to lean on. I think that some feel that we must be wanting advise or we wouldn't be telling them. :-)

Chloe

Iain2017 profile image
Iain2017 in reply to chloe40

Yeh y think thats right, hi chloe, i think also that maybe sometimes i would hope tht people would perhaps share their insecurities as well, so tht it is a two way thing, that always makes things easier and less jarring.

Gambit62 profile image
Gambit62

nothing more irritating than being offered advice when all you wanted was to talk about something ... but just as irritating to have people refuse to give you advice when you ask for it.

At the risk of pushing stereotypes men tend to talk because they want advice and women tend to talk because they want to be listened to - a dynamic that often goes wrong ... and sometimes the gender dynamic is the other way round (was in my marriage).

Sometimes think that its not really about being understood - always felt that with depression it was more about wanting to know that I was accepted despite how I was feeling and people were trying to understand (and potentially fix) something that they just couldn't understand. The people that I found most helpful were those who actually said that they didn't understand but they would listen.

mysmugcat profile image
mysmugcat

Yes. I have been interrupted in my flow and given stupid advice by people lol.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Hi... I’m just looking for some help or some type of clarity.

Well I’m not really sure what to write or if anyone will really care but I just don’t know what’s...

Any advice for a new member please?

Hello, Just joined this forum and been reading the posts. Lots of people comment that their...

I feel like something is wrong with me but I don't know what

Hi everyone! This is my first post here and I'm a bit nervous. For the past few months I have been...

Do you really want to be "cured" or do you merely want to thrive?

Wouldn't you say those that suffer from depression are too smart for their own good? We know why we...

How do I keep my body from falling apart?

I'm only 20, yet I'm chronically ill. My health has been progressively getting worse year by year....