Dr should listen !: This could well apply to... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

140,396 members165,168 posts

Dr should listen !

meme profile image
meme
24 Replies

This could well apply to Thyroid patients.

Written by
meme profile image
meme
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
24 Replies
Buddy195 profile image
Buddy195Administrator

bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-c...

This is expanded on the BBC website.

Let’s hope more medical practitioners take notice of the research 🤞

Forestgarden profile image
Forestgarden

Sounds depressingly familiar

Stills profile image
Stills

😖

Charlie-Farley profile image
Charlie-Farley

there are articles in the Independent and Telegraph also. Plenty of exposure - perhaps we should make scraps book of all the articles to show in appointments when the gaslighting starts! 🤣

grumpyold profile image
grumpyold in reply to Charlie-Farley

They'd just dismiss our scrapbooks the same as they dismiss all other evidence/research/articles we provide. 😭😩

Charlie-Farley profile image
Charlie-Farley in reply to grumpyold

I think if you soften them up with their own guidelines first it makes it easier. 😉

JCMartin profile image
JCMartin

I know that feeling. Its like medical gas lighting.

buddy99 profile image
buddy99

But we don't have a medical background and are laypersons. How could we ever know that something is off with our body or how we really feel? Non, no, no! You have to have a medical degree to know this. A layperson is the most unreliable witness of issues concerning their body. Only a doctor can tell you how you feel. Most likely it's all made up anyway. So just be a good patient and leave the doctor alone with your unfounded claptrap. And if the doctor says something it is the absolute truth that should never, ever be challenged because they are the DOCTOR and you are obviously not. That's all there is to it. NOT!

Stills profile image
Stills in reply to buddy99

Recently I had to attend ER on advice of 111 as GP refused to follow their advice and give me an appointment for ECG. While there I informed drs of my chronic AI condition which they looked up on the internet! So if drs get knowledge that way, So can we and apply it to appointments whether they like it or not.

Sparklingsunshine profile image
Sparklingsunshine in reply to Stills

My husband, who as a man might be expected to get better treatment, still remembers when he saw a locum doctor at our surgery who listened to what he had to say, used Dr Google, printed off the fact sheet from one of the medical sites and handed it to my husband.

That was it, no advice, no examination, no prescription, nothing. As my he pointed out to me later we could have done that, no need to waste time and energy going to see a doctor. My husband has a very jaundiced opinion of medics lol.

Stills profile image
Stills in reply to Sparklingsunshine

As long as he himself is not jaundiced 😉

DandyButch profile image
DandyButch

Wow! It has taken research to show this?Just ask some of us on here.

Zephyrbear profile image
Zephyrbear

Do you think they ever consider perhaps that looking something up after you’ve mentioned it in a consultation might be of use to them? Y’know… like proper researchers might? Further their own knowledge… expand their horizons… be of some real benefit to the next patient… instead of relying on something they remember of an hour’s lecture tucked within 5 years of university study?

No, me neither!

Stills profile image
Stills in reply to Zephyrbear

Their minds are already too full of their own importance I fear

Stills profile image
Stills in reply to Zephyrbear

I remember being taught that Germany was divide into East and West when I was at school ….. now I know differently.

buddy99 profile image
buddy99 in reply to Zephyrbear

They practice evidence based medicine (as I was assured several times). Problem is....many don't have all the evidence and some have different evidence from others. The nature of science and research also is that yesterday's evidence can be today's garbage. We can never assume that we know everything, but most doctors seem to believe they do. They don't have to look it up!

serenfach profile image
serenfach

After a bit of a "discussion" with an "Endo" over the phone, just to get a T3 blood test, he sent me a paper saying T3 was not important, with the phrase "“having thyroid function tested is a marker of increased psychological morbidity”, I returned fire sending him 10 papers showing the importance of T3, thanks to this site.

I have not heard back.

Sparklingsunshine profile image
Sparklingsunshine in reply to serenfach

Is it papers at dawn now? A duel to the academic death 😆

serenfach profile image
serenfach in reply to Sparklingsunshine

Those paper cuts sting like fury, almost as much as a woman scorned.

Sparklingsunshine profile image
Sparklingsunshine in reply to serenfach

Especially if you dab them lemon juice, ahhhhhh the burn 😀

PRJ20 profile image
PRJ20 in reply to serenfach

Ooh serenfach, please could I have a list of the 10 papers you sent that "Endo", as I could really do with sending those after a similar "conversation" I had over the the importance of T3 with the *[Principal] Pharmacist* at my GP surgery a couple of weeks ago, when he was most dismissive and arrogant about anything I could say about my own AITD and history, etc., and including when I mentioned TUK and all the research papers, professionals, Endo's, etc., and knowledge they have on the subject. I even promised I'd send him some of the research papers I alluded to after he arrogantly dismissed those with: "Anyone can write a research paper..." 😮...but, 10 would be amazing to send to shut him up!! 🤐😎

(*he's actually the son of the Principal GP who retired last year at 70; it's since become very obvious he'd lined-up his son to take-over the practice, whilst probably still pulling the strings/having some control in the background; and, like father/like son, was just as arrogant and dismissive, though his father did 'mellow' slightly with age*)

arTistapple profile image
arTistapple

I think it’s one of the best ‘stitched up’ professions. They make the rules which protect themselves. They sit in their seats, in front of their computers, doing what a number of forumites have mentioned, being paid salaries which take them into the top 4% of the country. I really find it hard to feel for them, even if the government are acting like a load of ….s.

serenfach profile image
serenfach

I sometimes wonder whether there is a directive from on high telling doctors not to treat thyroid problems, let them die. Just like a certain directive that allowed a certain virus into nursing homes. Think of the pension money that they saved!

JCMartin profile image
JCMartin

My docfer said i had Sick Sinus Syndrome - but never did anything about it. 3 Cardiologists in hospital said i didnt and a docter couldnt diagnose this anyway. From that diagnosis he has not listened to my symptoms or anything i have said. The diagnosis took him 10 minutes. I tgink they cant admit whem they are wrong and certainly do not listen to their patients. Gut feeling is never wrong in my experience and i habe compalimed about my neck since June. I was told it was water retention or "not that swollen".

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Dr appointment and making them listen

I'm going to book a dr appointment today for next week, how do I make my dr listen? I don't want to...

Gps WONT listen

I had to see my Gp the other day as my sick cert ran out . However I had previously been to see my...

Why don’t doctors listen😢

So after calling today,after being told on Monday that a request for a copy of my blood results...

Another they dont listen ...

Well after 9 weeks on 100mcg levo back in Aug, my TSH finally came down to 4.27 (0.27-4.2). I...

DOCTORS LISTEN YET DON'T HEAR

16 years HASHIMOTOS HYPO/HYPER 3 DIFFERENT THYROID MEDICINE'S & ONLY STABLE FOR A COUPLE MONTHS AT...