English retailers told to halt coronavirus home... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

141,183 members166,422 posts

English retailers told to halt coronavirus home antibody test deliveries

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministrator
8 Replies

In case anyone has bought, or used, or is even just thinking about buying, a home covid-19 antibodies test, the following article might be of interest.

What is not at all clear is how this applies in Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland!

English retailers told to halt coronavirus home antibody test deliveries

Public Health England says labs must not process them until it has established their accuracy

theguardian.com/world/2020/...

Written by
helvella profile image
helvella
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
8 Replies
Marz profile image
Marz

They are using a German one in the US. Sorry no link !

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

These tests are virtually useless and may be harmful if you think you have a degree of immunity when you don't.

Blue Horizon state:

100% Sensitive at detecting IgG antibodies in people who have been ill from Covid-19 at 14 days or more after their first symptoms.

99.6% Specific. This means that there were only 0.4% of people that gave blood before SARS-CoV-2 or had a respiratory illness that was caused by another virus who tested positive for IgG antibodies (false positives)

This sounds good but we need to factor in the mathematics. Approximately 265,000 people have tested positive in the UK. Assuming a UK population of 65,000,000 a test that is 99.6% specific would give 260,000 false positives. Thus, if you test positive on one of these tests there may be a 50 / 50 chance you have had COVID-19! Fifty percent accuracy is not good enough to base decisions on. It's probable there are more than 265,000 who have been infected so my calculation probably exaggerates the problem.

I'm also suspicious of the comment about 'had a respiratory illness'. It's not clear if this 99.6% specific figure is based upon a ramdon selection of people who were tested (should be) or whether they selected people who had a respiratory illness. Selecting people who were symptomatic for COVID-19 would greatly increase the apparent accuracy of the test.

Once one looks at the figures in detail it becomes clear how difficult a task the government / NHS has in finding good tests.

Well, apparently in the Netherlands that found that stored blood from years before this virus was supposed to exist could test positive for antibodies. This suggests that a) the test cannot tell the different between antibodies for different coronaviruses (or apparently strep or hepatis) b) the alleged new virus isn't new c) the tests are not accurate. d) None of the above. But on the other hand, the tests for active infection can test positive on a goat, a piece of fruit and some motor oil and the NHS is quite happy to use those, so who knows? Perhaps home test interfere with their Stazi-style track and trace programme

Marz profile image
Marz in reply toAngel_of_the_North

Very concerning - as testing positive could mean the common cold anti-bodies. Another two weeks under house arrest whilst more plans are made to curtail our freedoms.

Of course DC has to stay - he's in the middle of some very important modelling in the dark wings - and will be organising the new order. Also the Global Vaccine Conference - GAVI - is taking place soon - virtually. - but hosted by UK.. Ferguson is Acting director of VIMC - Vaccine Impact Midelling Consortium.

If they do not have a full proof test - why is it starting today - the TAT - Track and Trace ??

Who do we trust ?

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

The NHS has resisted pressure to use antibody tests until they have found an accurate one. This has put enormous pressure on everyone involved but to their credit they have resisted. Vaccines have varying effectiveness, polio is fantastic whilst influenza vaccines save thousands of lives in spite of moderate effectiveness.

The cruical point is when infection rates are very low as in COVID-19 an antibody test needs to be 100% specific in order to avoid many false positives.

Marz profile image
Marz

Will take a look ! Didn't know you could drive 265 miles in a Discovery without a refill .. 😎😕

Marz profile image
Marz

Oh well that's sorted then !

jimh111 profile image
jimh111

If I remember that is what was reported. I guess it comes down to how many decimal places. There comes a point when the test is sufficiently accurate to be useful, my point is the over the counter tests are not.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Blue Horizon Covid -19 Antibody Test

Just wondering if anybody had tried the antibody test from Blue Horizon? Or had any they could...
Rhsana profile image

Beginners post: Thyroid antibody test results in plain English please

Hi I have been going back and forth to the GPs for quite a while as I believe I have a return of...
Shylton profile image

UK pharmacies in dark about ministers’ plan to maintain drug supplies

The headline might be a bit overdone but, as you read, it is clear that we simply do not know what...
helvella profile image
Administrator

Heads Up

Got this text message yesterday. High risk in this context not related to age - OH is older than...

Can’t lose weight: Hypothyroidism, Hashimoto’s. Extreme obesity.

Hello guys, Could someone please look at my blood test results and tell me if there’s any issue? I...

Moderation team

See all
Jaydee1507 profile image
Jaydee1507Administrator
PurpleNails profile image
PurpleNailsAdministrator
SlowDragon profile image
SlowDragonAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.