opinions needed: Weird question: My knee... - Stand Up 2 OA

Stand Up 2 OA

316 posts

opinions needed

11 Replies

Weird question: My knee replacement is on hold as my hubby needs an unexpected surgery and he will be my caregiver. So, I have too much time to think about the surgery I dont want to have, lol. My knee is in better shape now than it was a yr ago as Ive worked hard riding my exercise bike etc. My pain some days is non existent, other days it reminds me it's there. Surgeon says my valgus( knocked ) knee is bone on bone, valgus is causing my femur to twist causing my hip to turn in, etc etc. I dont doubt that as I can tell my valgus is worse. I guess my two questions are 1. Why are my symptoms better when xrays show worse 2. If I back out of the surgery, will I be doing damage to myself due to valgus?

I am going to get a second opinion next week but wondering if anyone else has had similar situation?

Addendum 3/5: saw ortho doc for second opinion.

I love it when docs tell me what I want to hear!!! He said cancel surgery, you only want knee replacement when you have exhausted everyother option. Continue on with your wt loss, exercise, strengthen your core. Only consider surgery when the pain is bad and daily, you will know. He said it might b 6 mo, 2 yr, 5 yr, never. I was sooo happy when I left and more motivated to be more aggressive with diet/ exercise.

Read more about...

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

11 Replies
suryakaizen profile image
suryakaizen

Good for you Hoski. You seem to have come upon a good, good doctor. Knee replacement lasts only about 20 years, I was told, so I too haven't gone for it, and will do so only if I'm absolutely unable to get about. I have found from experience that reducing mental stress too reduces pain from arthritis. So you might want to take up meditation or tai chi or vipassana rather than aggressive exercise which could aggravate your condition.

in reply tosuryakaizen

thankyou so much! I agree, I believe God intervened in my situation and I am thankful!

wrightfan profile image
wrightfan in reply to

Very good! Best of luck to your husband.

in reply towrightfan

thankyou so much! He too escaped the bullet. He had a mass removed from his neck that was benign but the type of tumor that likes to become malignant over time! He is recovering well. I made an appt with a trainer this week to get started on a core building ex program I can do at home. Im afraid he might make me break a sweat!!!

willisteele profile image
willisteeleAmbassador

Sounds like the doc is in your corner! Best of Luck on the journy and stay motivated!

in reply towillisteele

Thanks! I could have kissed that doc! I told him I appreciated his honesty as here in the USA, surgeons dont make $$ by not advising surgery. I feel confident that my motivation with be fueled by avoiding or at least prolonging a surgery👍🏻

bethedifference profile image
bethedifference

Well done with all the hard work keeping your physical activity levels up! One important thing I learned from my Start Moving team is that you can reduce pain and stiffness by building strength and flexibility in the muscles and tendons around your knee. That is one reason why we emphasize physical activity, stretching and balancing in the new Healthy Activity Score. The other effect to reduce chronic pain may be that the physical activity is reducing inflammation around the joint. So pleased to hear of your progress and best wishes with all that is going on with you :-)

in reply tobethedifference

Thankyou so much!

OrthoRN87 profile image
OrthoRN87Ambassador

One thing is motion is lotion for your joint-the bike has played a role in how you feel...better muscle tone supporting your knee, lubrication, increase movement of joint, & endurance

Marbarpink profile image
Marbarpink

I have arthritis and my knee is particularly painful and I have been told I will need a knee replacement eventually. At the moment I am undergoing PRP injections (platelet rich plasma) which are helping with the pain your own platelets help to rebuild worn cartilage as long as you still have some cartilage left. (Plenty of info on the internet) May be an option?

Marbarpink profile image
Marbarpink

I also do regular aqua fit and swimming which helps as you can exercise but the water helps to support your joints so doesn't aggravate the arthritis

The ability to reply to this post has been turned off.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Knee and back pain suffer!

I am 57 years old ,and I am over weight .My knees hurt everyday, I had total knee replacement on...
Fayehall profile image

Alternatives to knee surgery

Hi, I just joined-already belong to 3 communities which I have gotten much help...

Limp after knee replacement?

I had a rt knee replacement( tkr) 3 mo ago. Sadly I had to have it redone 6 weeks later as the...

Knee replacement

Is knee replacement horrible? I have found my knee doesn’t hurt in warm weather. But it does in...
fleener profile image

Pain gone

This is a mystery, Ive had progressive osteoarthritis in my rt knee for years. This winter it has...

Moderation team

alnapier profile image
alnapierAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.