Simon Wessely Defends PACE: A large clinical... - Ramsays Disease

Ramsays Disease

567 members470 posts

Simon Wessely Defends PACE

Theresa60 profile image
46 Replies

A large clinical trial might be said to resemble an ocean liner, which is leaving Southampton to sail to New York. It is a complicated system. There will be a captain on the bridge and a large crew. They will have filed a course some time before they set sail, but not everything can be foreseen in advance; the weather for example. Sometimes small corrections to the route will need to be made en voyage. These will be meticulously recorded, authorised by the ship’s owners, otherwise known as the Trial Steering Committee, which can overrule the captain if needed. Occasionally something happens; the vessel is seaworthy, the cabins are ready, and the band has started playing, but the ship never sets out, most often because they can’t get enough passengers on board to make the voyage worthwhile. Very occasionally there is a shipwreck, but this is very rare. Few trials suffer the fate of the Titanic, but sometimes the ship gets to the USA, but not to New York, but some other place; destination changed en route, which is considered bad form. In that case, people may debate for years afterwards what actually pushed them off course, and what that means. But most often the ship does eventually dock in New York, with satisfied passengers, and a tired but relieved crew.

nationalelfservice.net/othe...

One oresponse (below the bluster) hits the argument below the waterline.

Graham McPhee

NEW CANARD PASSENGER LINE

Southampton to New York in 5 days

Canard has announced the successful first voyage of its flagship, the Queen Mary Pace. Built in Oxford to rigorous specifications, this sleek and sophisticated liner, with the latest engines built with Graduated Energy Transmission, has taken the world by storm with the first crossing in just 5 days.

Setting out from Southampton on 18th March, 2005, amid cheers from admiring crowds in the medical enclosure, it left harbour looking every inch the awesome and standard-setting giant that it is.

With everyone settled in and enjoying the cruise, the captain called together his senior crew and decided to make some minor adjustments to the course plotted. Informing the management back at Canard, these quickly took place, and a mere 5 days later, passengers found themselves at the quayside in Dublin.

“All changes were rigorously discussed with the senior crew,” explained the captain. “It was felt important to make changes that truly reflected the potential of the new engine arrangement. Dublin is an entirely normal destiny for cruise liners.”

A number of passengers complained, but, as management at Canard explained, “There are always vexatious passengers on any cruise. All decisions were taken in their interests, and, naturally, it would be inappropriate for passengers unfamiliar with the ways of the sea to be allowed to comment on such matters. The crew had unusually tranquil seas and clement weather to contend with: it is too easy to criticize from the sidelines.” The UK government, which invested heavily in this engineering miracle, recommends that everyone should experience this very effective service.

When questioned, 22% of the passengers said that they thought Dublin was much better or even very much better than they had realized: but another analysis showed that, actually, none of them ever ended up in New York, even two years later.

Written by
Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
46 Replies
Arianne profile image
Arianne

Banner reads NO BIAS. NO MISINFORMATION. NO SPIN. JUST WHAT YOU NEED.

Then tells of bias in previous research, admits information has been withheld from freedom of information requests, spins CBT as a coping strategy when changing

"irrational illness beliefs" was a stated aim and with Graded Exercise Therapy just what you do not need.

Effort profile image
Effort in reply toArianne

For previous form meactionuk.org.uk/Prejudice... a poorly informed medical establishment continues

holding control.

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toEffort

Searching further on the information shared.

Emmaril profile image
Emmaril in reply toEffort

First appearances a reasonable person that has wanted the best and then with hindsight is twisting things as politicians do.

carch520 profile image
carch520

Talking about the Titanic is he joking ?

Len607 profile image
Len607 in reply tocarch520

Does make you wonder doesn't it Titanic hardly a byword for safety.

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply tocarch520

They have in common the deaths of a large number of people.

Jonesbones profile image
Jonesbones

For iceberg substitute disbelief of medical professionals.

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toJonesbones

Update themselves and soon this is the 21st Century.

CheshireKatz profile image
CheshireKatz

Disagree and sign the petition my.meaction.net/petitions/p...

Ian123 profile image
Ian123

Considering why the same safeguards should be in place that are used with drug therapy. bmj.com/content/350/bmj.h22...

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toIan123

"Behavioural research should not have a “get out of jail free” card when it comes to scientific rigour"

Lancet reviewers should take note of this statement as the gatekeepers of scientific rigour. The cost of the research (£5m) should also be questioned when considering allegations of defrauding the taxpayers.

Halflife profile image
Halflife

Was controversial that's changing radioboston.wbur.org/2015/1... NIH moving oversight into NINDS .

Ellen Wright Clayton at IOM

youtube.com/watch?v=K9saHKz...

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toHalflife

"It's time to stop saying that this is a just figment of people's imagination. This is a real disease, with real physical manifestations that need to be identified and cared for," Committee Chair Ellen Wright Clayton, MD, JD, professor of pediatrics and director of the Center for Biomedical Ethics and Society at Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee.

Wessely will no longer want PACE cruises going to America or beyond the British Isles as psychological theory collapses.

Seascape profile image
Seascape

Weasely and his close personal friends have aided in the avoidance of biomedical research for over thirty years a prosperous journey for them financially at the cost

of human pain and suffering on a biblical scale.

ringading profile image
ringading

Countess Mar relays history forward-me.org.uk/Speeches/...

nedd profile image
nedd

Surely he has shot himself in the foot when statting.

That "there were a significant number of patients who did not improve with these treatments. Some patients deteriorated, but this seems to be the nature of the illness, rather than related to a particular treatment". And must be further limping weighed down by the acknowledgement that no bed bound patients were included.

This seems to be the nature of the illness! If I didn't laugh I would howl,

I am willing not to chuck the baby out with the bath water but really!

Jonesbones profile image
Jonesbones in reply tonedd

Positive spin on null result an act of desperation

( questioning baby ever been in the bath water at any time)

nedd profile image
nedd in reply toJonesbones

Oh we of little faith.

CheshireKatz profile image
CheshireKatz

Government orders release of PACE trial data

meaction.net/2015/11/06/gov...

Jonesbones profile image
Jonesbones in reply toCheshireKatz

Upper hand vexatious vociferous minority.

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toCheshireKatz

Counting nothing until they have hatched into chickens.

Ian123 profile image
Ian123 in reply toCheshireKatz

pressure increases meaction.net/2015/11/11/jam...

Effort profile image
Effort in reply toIan123

Political pressure do the "right thing" from more respected academics.

Effort profile image
Effort

FINE is PACE's forgotten sister virology.ws/2015/11/09/tria...

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toEffort

Null results beyond spin.

Effort profile image
Effort in reply toTheresa60

Unprecedented spin failure beliefs !

Ian123 profile image
Ian123

Fighting over fatigue mosaicscience.com/chronic-f...

Phoebly profile image
Phoebly

Reaction from Northern Ireland belfasttelegraph.co.uk/life...

Ian123 profile image
Ian123

Shared from another site with permission of the poster.

healthunlocked.com/api/redi...

readerlist profile image
readerlist

"But according to the theory underlying this psychiatric research, my problem was that I was out of shape, afraid of exercise, and obsessed about my symptoms. The path to wellness was to drop the idea that I had a physical disease and steadily increase my exercise, no matter how bad it made me feel.

Patients rapidly discovered serious scientific problems with the 2011 Lancet paper. Despite these errors, the study, known as the PACE trial, went on to inform recommendations from such influential bodies as the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the Mayo Clinic, and the British National Health Service. So the new follow-up study, I feared, seemed destined for a warm and uncritical reception from the medical establishment regardless of whether its findings were legitimate"

The authors of the PACE trial were possibly aware that a warm uncritical reception had no historical context, although the firestorm from beyond the usual suspects, can scarcely have entered their worst nightmares.

Reviewed by peer groups outside of the funding establishment a harsh reality settles upon psychosocial theories demanding evidence standards equality within medical treatment, smoke and mirrors discarded.

Jonesbones profile image
Jonesbones in reply toreaderlist

Now is the winter of our discontent William Shakespeare

ringading profile image
ringading

Pychosomatic should not be the default position

newstatesman.com/culture/ob...

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toringading

Rituximab destroys more than white blood cells "psychosomatic" theories

fall with successful treatment.

ringading profile image
ringading in reply toTheresa60

Proof from Norway validated with further testing here.

CheshireKatz profile image
CheshireKatz

Open letter for CDC dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u... from patient advocates.

Babylon5 profile image
Babylon5 in reply toCheshireKatz

Class action against CDC using damaging guidelines had defence of doubt now that has vanished.

CheshireKatz profile image
CheshireKatz

James Coyne skeptical view on PACE trials

youtube.com/watch?v=KSGtZgz...

CheshireKatz profile image
CheshireKatz in reply toCheshireKatz

youtube.com/watch?v=a8IdkZM...

CheshireKatz profile image
CheshireKatz in reply toCheshireKatz

youtube.com/watch?v=JHQuRp_...

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toCheshireKatz

Bad science unquestioned by the establishment for power politics that does not bite the hand which feeds them.

Ian123 profile image
Ian123

Half of medical reporting is subject to spin

linkis.com/www.nhs.uk/news/...

Effort profile image
Effort

James Coyne public talk on PACE (some strong language)

mediafire.com/view/n5r9qdqm...

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60 in reply toEffort

Transcripts of CheshireKatz videos are hugely helpful as sound quality disturbed my fragile concentration. Thank you so much from a foggy memory.

Effort profile image
Effort in reply toTheresa60

You are most welcome from a kindred spirit.

Theresa60 profile image
Theresa60

Professor James Coyne requests data from 2012 Plos One this is the response

linkis.com/com/xdxYg

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

PACE New Analysis

A long read but cutting it short the PACE trial showed no recovery inflating the results published...
Effort profile image

PACE Review

The main findings reported in the PACE trial were that cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and...
readerlist profile image

PACE Data

An FOI (freedom of information) request for data from the PACE trial was deemed "vexatious" by QMUL...
Ian123 profile image

PACE trial commentaries

Following an exchange of correspondence with journal editor Dr David Marks, it has been agreed by...
Ian123 profile image

Analysis of the Scandalous PACE Trial

Excellent article analysing the so-called science of the PACE trial. A bit lengthy and a brain...
ukmsmi4 profile image

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.