Local Anestheia vs Total Sedation for... - Prostate Cancer N...

Prostate Cancer Network

5,231 members3,293 posts

Local Anestheia vs Total Sedation for Marker and Spacer Gel insertion

mijona profile image
12 Replies

72 yo Gleason 7 Localized Prostate Cancer - Just starting the process. Was interested to know if anyone has had the Markers and Spacer Gel inserted just with local anesthesia, outpatient procedure and recommended ? Thanks for your help.

Written by
mijona profile image
mijona
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
12 Replies
ToolBeltZia profile image
ToolBeltZia

I had a general. More comfortable for me....and makes it easier for the Dr to be precise. See if they do SpaceOAR or Barrigel. I had Barrigel, as it does not polymerize like SpaceOAR does, it does not have a (very) limited working time like SpaceOAR.

mijona profile image
mijona in reply toToolBeltZia

Great. Thanks for the info.

Also I see that you went with the High Dose RT as opposed to the Low Dose RT. What made you choose one over the other ?

ToolBeltZia profile image
ToolBeltZia in reply tomijona

Studies have shown that PC may be more sensitive to fewer higher dose treatments rather than more lower dose treatments. At worse SBRT (ulta-hypofractionation) has been show to be "non-inferior" to normal or hypo-fractionation. The GI and GU side effects do not show much difference, and the rate of bio-chemical recurrence and metastatic recurrence is the same as more traditional fractionation and as surgery. SBRT was also able to apply a focal boost to the dominant lesion as traditional RT can. Studies show this boost to the tumor increases the "cure" rate. All these points along with getting it done in 5 sessions over two weeks rather than 30-50 sessions over 6-10 weeks led me to go with SBRT. I ran my treatment plan past a friend who is a gastroenterologist and his son, an oncologist, and they both agreed it was "state of the art".

If you have any additional questions please do not hesitate to ask.

MarkS profile image
MarkS

Hi, I'm due to get the Barrigel spacer inserted at the beginning of Feb. That will be under local which is a lot easier, one hour in and out. It is apparently no more uncomfortable than a biopsy and that was easy enough. You can drive straightaway and you don't get the long term effects on the brain of a general.

Photographerhere profile image
Photographerhere

i had spaceOAR inserted with local anesthesia. Once they got going it was less than 4 minutes, wasn’t fun for sure It not awfully painful. It was more embarrassing than painful. Five nurses and a doc with your knees up to your chest

mijona profile image
mijona

Your comments and experiences greatly appreciated. Was told any movement during the procedure could cause complications, so wondering if local anesthesia was enough to keep still.

ToolBeltZia profile image
ToolBeltZia in reply tomijona

This is the main concern. Watch a video showing how it is done, the tolerance between your prostate and rectum is about two needle widths..... probably don't want to twitch at the wrong time. General was the way to go.

turkeyjoe1 profile image
turkeyjoe1

I got knocked out completely, best thing I ever did.

GregHay profile image
GregHay

I had spaceOAR and markers in one session with a local. I found it more painful than the biopsy but tolerable.

mijona profile image
mijona

Great info/comments. Thanks for the replies.

Atdabeach profile image
Atdabeach

I had fiducial markers placed with local anesthesia. Uncomfortable for sure -- a couple of injections to numb the skin (no big deal), then a deep needle to numb the prostate (this was the worst part, but I'd say no more painful than a biopsy). Once fully numb, I didn't even feel the marker placements.

mijona profile image
mijona

Hi Atdabeach. Great. Thanks.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Oar Gel and gold placements for beginners on this journey

I am a beginner on this PC journey but feel fortunate that I caught my cancer before it had spread...
Eadgbe profile image

"Pros and Cons of Various Forms of Radiation Therapy vs Radical Prostatectomy for Men in Their 50s"

I have been diagnosed with intermediate non-favorable risk prostate cancer. Currently, we are...
Seat15c profile image

ADT medication types and timing before Radiotherapy

I wonder what the experience and clinical view is about when to start radiotherapy for advance but...
SimMartin profile image

Incontinence Frustration

I'd like feedback from the group on incontinence and how they are dealing with it. It seems like...
Tom19 profile image

Acworth Georgia Man 2nd Opinion Results

I went yesterday for a 2nd opinion and the Dr said it is 50% chance. I am considered a very young...
GarrickR profile image

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.