advice re reducing pred while on TCZ: Hi, a quick... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

20,312 members38,049 posts

advice re reducing pred while on TCZ

Sophiestree profile image
81 Replies

Hi, a quick question as I know you will have the answer. I finally received a copy of the letter the consultant sent to my gp after my phone appt on 18th Feb. She told me over the phone to reduce the pred by 1mg every two weeks, but on the letter it says 3/4 weeks after I am on 10mg. This is my last week on 10mg so 9mg will start next Monday. Any suggestions as to how long I should do each reduction bearing in mind I am also on TCZ. Had 2 months so far on TCZ if that makes any difference. My symptoms are OK-ish, mild head pressure, 10% of what it was, and occasional neck issues, but all doable. The only thing, as I have already written about, is my right buttock and right leg, which is still pretty dire, but I am doing exercises and it has improved a teeny bit after 2 weeks, but I still can't walk down the road. But this maybe something totally different.. I am also sleeping, which I haven't done for months!

Can't even do a simple question short can I! Thanks in advance.....

Written by
Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
81 Replies
alvertta profile image
alvertta

My rheumy is taking 14 weeks to take me from 14 to 8. Similar to the HU go slow formula. I am on toxy as well. Once a week.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to alvertta

interesting, so are you reducing by 1 mg every two weeks?

alvertta profile image
alvertta in reply to Sophiestree

There is a guide on this site for a slow taper. It’s not exactly 1 per week.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to alvertta

Yes, thank you

alvertta profile image
alvertta in reply to Sophiestree

Good luck. It’s a lot of “try and see how it feels.”

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to alvertta

Yes, the thing I have totally seen from reading everything on here. It's all about you and not about what a book might say!

Rugger profile image
Rugger

I'm also on TCZ and my Rheumatologist advised 1mg every 28 days, from 10mg downwards, so similar to yours. When I got down to 3, 2 and 1mg I noticed symptoms returning, so I'm back on 5mg and she has suggested I stay on that dose until I stop TCZ when my 'ration' runs out. Then we'll see where we go from there!

Good Luck!

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Rugger

Do you have GCA? Interested re your symptoms returning. I have LVV/GCA but not PMR

Rugger profile image
Rugger in reply to Sophiestree

I also have GCA-LVV and noticed my legs were complaining, as they did before the LVV was diagnosed. My Rheumatologist feels it could have been the claudication returning, but it might have been due to PMR, which I've had since 2016. (GCA-LVV since 2019). Whatever the cause, she suggested an increase in the pred dose.

By the way, CRP reading will be rock bottom, as the TCZ blocks our inflammatory response - no need to have it checked at all!

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Rugger

I hope my consultant seriously knows that, as I have said before, I have very little faith in her, but hopefully she will know, I don't want to think she is that rubbish 😆

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Sophiestree

ard.bmj.com/content/75/Supp...

academic.oup.com/rheumap/ar...

have references about the unreliability of using CRP in tocilizumab therapy

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

Going to swot up on that for the next phone call. She hasn't even asked for regular blood tests, particularly for liver, which is something that they say needs monitoring, plus the fact I have had liver issues the whole time throughout. Exhausting to keep up with it all, but you're bu*%$!ed if you don't.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Sophiestree

Have you seen the stuff about monitoring from the manufacturer? I did post it a few weeks ago

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

I have the leaflet that came in the box. I am going to have a thorough read through that as well. May even just ask the GP to organise the blood tests, but know they will say that the consultant has to suggest it first.... urgh

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Sophiestree

actemrahcp.com/ra/dosing-an...

I'd be upset if my GP wouldn't agree to do basic labs for me if the specialist was so lax. They aren't specialist tests - just LFTs and FBC

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

yes, I agree, I will drop them a note about it and see what their reaction is.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

the bmj link didn't work... the other one has though so will read that one. thanks

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Sophiestree

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

google that - gives you the article, It's about CRP not rising in severe bacterial infection when the patient is on TCZ - but the principle is the same. CRP isn't relevant ...

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

thanks, that worked 👍

pata63 profile image
pata63 in reply to PMRpro

Just to add a little to this from my own medical history. I am on 5 mg of Prednisone for PMR. My CRP was 23 when I was diagnosed (1-Apr-19) then dropped back to 1 until I was hospitalized with acute bacterial prostatitis and sepsis (23-Feb-20). I was kept in for a few days on IV antibiotics. My CRP? Went to 5.8 which barely moves the needle into the "there is a bacterial infection" zone. After further treatment (a month on two different oral antibiotics) my CRP is back to 1 again, where it stays to this day. The small CRP test response to a big infection could be both the 5 mg of Prednisone and also my own personal biology. I've never been on any other drugs like TCZ for the PMR as Prednisone seems to do the trick.

weatherman69 profile image
weatherman69 in reply to Rugger

trust me, even on Actemra, your CRP can go up with a bad flare. My husband has experience this. His labs are checked every 2 weeks here

weatherman69 profile image
weatherman69 in reply to weatherman69

He gets CBCdiff, Comprehensive Metabolic Profile, Lipids, ESR and CRP every 2 weeks

piglette profile image
piglette

If you are on 10mg I would make it 1mg reduction every four weeks not two. You then have time to ensure the reduction is OK and the PMR is still under control and does not give it so much of a chance to raise its ugly head. Being a tender flower, I reduce 0.5mg a month, as I find that works for me.

jinasc profile image
jinasc in reply to piglette

Just to make is clear Sophiestree has GCA.

Unless you have GCA. TCZ is not available for PMR in the UK. It is also not given automatically for GCA.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to piglette

tender flower 😂 I so feel like that these days and I although thought I was quite robust. I don't have PMR, it actually sounds utterly dreadful when I read some of the symptoms you all suffer from.

piglette profile image
piglette in reply to Sophiestree

Sorry I should have said GCA.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to piglette

no problem at all, just wanted to mention it as it may be different, which I am unsure of to be honest.

jinasc profile image
jinasc

The second option is just like the DSNS plan using the 4 weeks. Best best as the Tortoise won the race.

Plan in Pinned Posts.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to jinasc

yes, interesting. thank you

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

The faster taper might be OK with the TCZ - only you can tell that! To some extent it will depend on how long you have been on pred and how rusty your adrenal function is. Only lower pred will wake that up and it takes time, the TCZ has no effect there at all except allowing the lower pred.

Remember TCZ doesn't get half of patients to zero, just to a lower dose, so you MIGHT get a return of symptoms and that ESR and CRP are meaningless when you are on TCZ because of the way it works.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

Trying to tell my consultant that she needs to ignore my blood results for ESR/CRP is a challenge! She seems to go by that every time, but to be fair also listens to the fact I do have slight symptoms still. Maybe I could split the difference and do 3 weeks per 1mg reduction.. Is there something I need to look out for, to understand the difference, in terms of adrenal function having been on pred since last Oct starting on 40mg. I am not expecting TCZ to be the miracle, but am enjoying the lesser side effects from the higher doses of pred. They are much more manageable since I got to about 15/12.5mg whereas before they were all consuming against anything else.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Sophiestree

Honestly not sure - see what happens.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

yes, very true!

Devoid profile image
Devoid in reply to PMRpro

Hi I am aware that crp is not reflective of condition when on TCZ but do you know if it literally zeros it or can you still expect some reading?? Hopefully you will know what I’m asking even if there isn’t an answer 😊

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Devoid

I am not sure actually, as i forgot to ask her what the numbers were last time we spoke, I slipped up there, as I like to keep a record, but I do know that ESR/CRP were within normal readings, just not sure what. I will ask when we next speak.

Devoid profile image
Devoid in reply to Sophiestree

Hi I was wondering if pmrpro had any idea, my consultant still requests it when I have my bloods done but has never explained the benefits of the test when TCZ negates it . Why I was interested is mine has never been zero

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Devoid

It shouldn't be zero I don't think but I suppose it could be as it stops the production of the protein. But it is possible that the lab assay won't show zero, just report as less than whatever the top of their normal range is.

Devoid profile image
Devoid in reply to PMRpro

Thanks it seems mad to me that they request a test that is of no benefit and even worrying when they say that the results are reassuring

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Devoid

the reassuring remark is the bit that worries me with my consultant!

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Devoid

It definitely concerns me that they haven't read the documentation - it states very clearly thst ESR/CRP don't monitor disease activity in TCZ patients.

Chrisellie profile image
Chrisellie in reply to Devoid

Hi Devoid my CRP was usually 0.4 during treatment but did vary a tiny bit now and again.

Blackcatlover profile image
Blackcatlover in reply to Devoid

I am on TCZ and down to 4.5mg of Prednisone. My doctor still does CRP and ESR every other month. My CRP has remained at .5 and my ESR is 2.

Helipad profile image
Helipad

I am on TCZ as well and the Prof has me reducing 2.5mg every 2 weeks but on alternate days if that makes sense, for example the last 2 weeks I did 10 and 7.5mg and for the next 2 weeks I’m taking 7.5mg, then it will be 7.5 and 5mg for 2 weeks. My jaw and tongue are starting to hurt a bit more as I’m having to lower the dose though. I have GCA LVV and Fibromyalgia.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Helipad

Interesting, that is a much bigger drop isn't it.

Helipad profile image
Helipad

It certainly is much bigger and seems to go against all the guidelines but when I said before that some of my GCA symptoms were returning/feeling worse and another rheumatology doctor told me to increase my Pred the Prof got really mad and said not to ring again or increase my Pred as he would take me off TCZ. It’s all very confusing.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Helipad

By the Prof you mean Dasgupta? Several people have noted that sort of reaction from him. Sorry - he is a leading light in the GCA world and without him the charity would possibly not exist but he still needs to listen when patients report problems.

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to PMRpro

It came as quite a shock as previously I had only spoken with him at the end of my appointments with his research fellowes and he had always seemed so lovely and approachable, so when I turned up for my last appointment and saw it was going to be with the Prof I was initially really pleased and then it all went to pot and I came away quite upset and feeling quite alone, luckily I have a really good GP so have decided that I will speak to her and she has agreed to liaise with Rheumatology if needed. I will still attend my 3 monthly appointments as I am part of the research study. It’s such a shame because as you say this forum would not exist if it were not for him and he is the one that recommended it join it. It is an amazing forum.

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to Helipad

I don't know your whole story, but is it possible you've been told not to deviate from the prescribed pred dosage because you're part of a study? If that is the case you should be informed, and also given guidance what to do if your symptoms continue to worsen. Not threatened.

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to HeronNS

It could be but if so they have never told me that and yes I agree. There are many different ways for someone to ask/tell you something. I rang to speak to one of the rheumatology nurses about 2 months ago as wanted just to clarify some procedures with regards to antibiotics and TCZ and even she told me not to ring again 😱

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Helipad

The department that keeps on giving!

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to Sophiestree

Aren’t they just,

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to Helipad

And no suggestion as to whom you should speak regarding questions? Really not acceptable. 😨

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to HeronNS

No it’s not and left me feeling very disillusioned

HeronNS profile image
HeronNS in reply to Helipad

🤗

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Helipad

Wow, people seem to like to hold things against people don't they.Threatening to take you off TCZ is pretty poor. Like a child throwing their toys out of the pram. Was the other rheumatology doctor in the same hospital? Is this Prof Dasgupta?

I think Kendrew had experiences with him in the past.

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to Sophiestree

Yes the other doctor is in the same hospital and yes it was Professor Dasgupta, I had to ask him to stop in the end as I was so close to tears and it did make me feel that I had nowhere to turn for advice but I have since spoken to my GP, who is amazing and she has said she will liaise with Rheumatology if need be. Yes Kendrew has had experience with him before.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Helipad

Interesting that you had to tell him to stop. I would like to think that he thought about that and has taken it onboard. I have far too many experiences of medics who have grown into monsters over the years.. a great shame and I am really sorry you experienced that. He needs reminding why he is there and who he is working for.

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to Sophiestree

I’d like to think so too but I won’t be holding my breath on that one. I know what you mean about medics becoming monsters and have had a few run ins since my accident 3 1/2 years ago, but at least I have an excellent GP who always talks everything over with me giving me options and ways forward and she is definitely not adverse to looking things up to try and help.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Helipad

Sadly, no, you are probably right. What a shame. So pleased you have an understand GP though, gold dust, keep hold of them!

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to Sophiestree

She is amazing and if it wasn’t for her I would have probably lost my sight, but she took me seriously and really listened to what I was saying.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Helipad

a keeper! I have one who I really like, but I don't always get her unless I write to her specifically. She rang me every day when my husband went into hospital, I think she felt guilty, but why I have no idea, as she certainly didn't need to feel like that. He was stubborn, and no one could tell him what to do regardless. But it was great she did that. I did buy her a gift at the end to say thank you as I wanted to acknowledge she went above and beyond for me, and often suggested things for me to relay to the hospital. The outcome was never going to be anything different though, as by that time he was beyond saving.

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to Sophiestree

She sounds really lovely and caring and good she was supporting you through such a difficult time

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Helipad

She is nice, but I don't always get her!!!

Helipad profile image
Helipad in reply to Sophiestree

Luckily I can always get an appointment with her, sometimes it does mean staying up till midnight, which is when they put some appointments on line for that day, but it is so worth it and she is always happy to book me a face to face appointment when needed.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Helipad

OK, I definitely can't say that.... but I can get to speak to someone on the same day if urgent or two days if not so that's something I suppose. If I write to her personally, then she calls me when she can. That's brilliant you can get an appt and face to face, the last one of those I had was last August pre-diagnosis. That's with the GP, not hospital obviously. I have requested my own locker there!!!

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Sophiestree

The trouble is you are so taken aback when they turn nasty - and when I spoke back sharply to one I had a nurse approaching me with raised hands (I gather it is supposed to calm the patient but it causes flashbacks for me), I was hysterical after that. Not helped by OH sitting there with his mouth shut! But it had been HER omission and ignorance of how HER system worked that led to me not being able to drive for months - and she tried to push the blame on ME not having got my results from an EEG! I should have raised a complaint but OH sometimes worked with her - which made it all the more surprising. I refused to see her again.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

Oh, I so know that situation, with family members being in contact with them. No wonder I don't trust any medics. Blame game is often due to the person's error and responsibility, rarely the other person they are aiming it at, but a very poor weak way of behaving. Own your errors and I will have a lot more respect for you. And holding your hand up to someone's face is aggressive, if that is what you meant. Either way, it is patronising at its best.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Sophiestree

No, it was raised hands as in hallelujah! for some reason - which I now realise is totally not advised! All I'd done before that was speak loudly asking how she thought I could have got the results and that I had come expecting to be told I could be mobile again. She had told me I had to surrender my licence - no I didn't as it turned out, DVLA said so - and that was why OH was there, I couldn't manage public transport and it wasn't the hospital 150 yards from my house! I suppose she realised she was at fault and wasn't going to admit it. No attempt at deescalation - "You will not be seen for the rest of the appointment" , i.e "we'll throw you out"

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

Urgh, even worse. that would have sent me over the edge.We could all write a book on these things couldn't we.

Sometimes their arrogance is breathtaking...

But fighting is also utterly exhausting.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to PMRpro

that's also why you need to go with someone, and most definitely, in my experience, NOT your OH. He was utterly useless at defending me in situations like that, so I always took my sister!

Sefu profile image
Sefu in reply to Helipad

Wow that sounds so arrogant and rude. Any specialist is in a service industry and supposed to be there for patients.

Darcy2000 profile image
Darcy2000

I am on Actemra and 10 mg of Prednisone. My rheumatologist whom I really like and respect takes the the very slow reduction plan. I reduce 1 mg every 6 weeks .. he is a firm believer that slow but steady wins the race ... we’ ll see

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Darcy2000

I like him, where are you based!!!

Darcy2000 profile image
Darcy2000 in reply to Sophiestree

Ottawa Canada

Darcy2000 profile image
Darcy2000 in reply to Sophiestree

Canada

Chrisellie profile image
Chrisellie

Hi Sophiestree. My journey including my reduction programme on Tocilizumab and Prednisolone is attached to my profile.hope you walking improves soon. Take care

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Chrisellie

Hi, thanks for that. So reading that, am I right in thinking you are not on any medication now?

Chrisellie profile image
Chrisellie in reply to Sophiestree

Yes that’s right. I am well now. Fingers crossed😃

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to Chrisellie

Brilliant

musicality profile image
musicality

Every 1 has their own agenda 4 reducing Pred, but most people (including me) say the DSNS say, e.g. 1/2 mg per month method works better than per week.

Sophiestree profile image
Sophiestree in reply to musicality

yes, thank you for that.

You may also like...

Not allowed back on pred with TCZ

patches I was given are making any difference. However, I then got this letter from the consultant...

Reducing Pred Advice please

given 15mg Pred. I have now tapered down to 4mg with GP's advice ( I have been on 4mg for 3...

Monitoring needs re Actemra TCZ

reference to at least monthly blood tests, but can't find my own notes. What should we request in...

Reducing TCZ?

the weekly TCZ to every 10 days, then 2 weekly etc? Does anyone have advice on how to reduce TCZ?...

I have a cold. Increase preds, pause TCZ?

slowly tapering preds, currently on 6mg, and weekly TCZ. I started a cold last Monday (8 days ago)