Greetings from Cape Town......Cryotherapy.....doe... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

20,269 members37,944 posts

Greetings from Cape Town......Cryotherapy.....does it help in final stages of PMR?

berold profile image
45 Replies

Greetings from Cape Town where life is good but we are having a bit of a drought and could borrow some of your rain. I got diagnosed with PMR in October 2016...all the classic symptoms with prednisone giving "miracle" relief. Ive had a quick recovery in relative terms (having read some of your scary posts)....and came from 20mg to 10 to 7,5 to 5 to 2,5 mg prednisone in Feb, and now down to 2,5mg every 2nd day for the last few months (btw we only get 5mg tabs here....no 1mg). So no pain for a long time ....but I have two little niggle, and need advice. I have some bursitis in the hip....no pain , its just an irritation when I play squash (Im 66 and do things like that) or when I run . Also I have some tendonitis in my arm/shoulder....not the serious rotator cuff stuff that I once had.....but right arm is weaker and it affects my backhand lob. I do all the exercises and stretches but the damn thing wont go away. So this physio lady (trained in UK mind you) suggests Cryotherapy....cold nitrogen freezing the area. It cost about 22 pounds a treatment (not expensive for you,I know) and she reckons I need about 6 treatments. I had one treatment but cant say it helped. I said I would only carry on once I have consulted with PMR UK group (who know everything). Can anyone oblige.

Written by
berold profile image
berold
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
45 Replies

Hi. Beautiful photo. I am fairly new to all the pmr business and have no experience of cryotherapy. All I will say is the thought of it (and excess heat) makes my muscles hurt. I went and looked up life expectancy of siberia which is coldest place I could think of in winter, where i think it can go down to minus 70, and it's males 55 and females 69. No idea what that means lol. Obviously totally different and can see how it is used clinically for cancer treatment. Hope others have info. I would be interested to know if this therapy is beneficial in this context. Brrrrr. Good luck!!

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer

Hi berold,

Can't help with the rain - at the moment anyway, lovely and sunny! No doubt it will be along soon though.

Can't help with the cryotherapy either, nobody on here has mentioned it as far as I know. But PMRpro will probably be able to help, she's the expert regarding bursitis.

Glad to hear you're getting on so well, and that you're keeping fit, but just make sure you're not overdoing it, the muscles take a bit of a battering from the PMR and the Pred.

berold profile image
berold in reply to DorsetLady

Thanks so much for comments

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador

Is this local use of cold? As opposed to being put in a cold chamber? The cold chamber version of cryotherapy didn't work well for one lady in Germany when a rheumy rehab clinic inflicted it on her during a "Kur". She went home worse than when she'd arrived!

I have to say you sound as if you may have had a "reactive" type of PMR to have got so low so fast. Which may mean what you have now is more bursitis than PMR. Really haven't come across cryotherapy for bursitis though. Really not sure I'd be too enthusiastic - cold never does my muscles any good.

Marilyn1959 profile image
Marilyn1959 in reply to PMRpro

Hi PMRpro. Can you please explain your reference to 'reactive' PMR? Are there different types of PMR? Thanks

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Marilyn1959

There is some thought that there may be - and in the case of "reactive" illnesses they occur after having another event, it may be trauma or infection, and then last a relatively short time. There is a form of arthritis that is due to that sort of cause and it disappears after a few months never to appear again. There are certainly groups of fairly different PMR: that last 2 years or less, that last about 5 years or so and which are pretty much permanent. But no-one knows for sure.

I suppose I mean the symptoms are due to something else - rather than an immune system malfunction. PMR is just the name we give to a set of symptoms - the underlying cause varies. The others should be ruled out first and the PMR we discuss here should be a final resort diagnosis.

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to PMRpro

And not forgetting the very serious 'Man' PMR... ;-) :-D

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to markbenjamin57

It's terminal isn't it? ;-)

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to PMRpro

YOU should be so lucky...! :-) :-D

Hindags profile image
Hindags in reply to PMRpro

Is there a way to test or to know what kind of PMR one has? IL 6 levels for instance? I wonder sometimes why I haven't had much fatigue...Does the fatigue get worse as one continues reducing the Pred? I'm just starting 12.5.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Hindags

It's a very recent train of thought - and no, they haven't yet found a marker that gives any guide towards how long PMR will last. I have heard doctors claim that people with higher ESR/CRP will have longer courses - so where do I fit in with resolutely low normal levels at all times and a 13 years PMR history?

Below about 8mg the fatigue may appear as a reflection of adrenal function not keeping up with topping up the lowering pred dose. Some very lucky people don't have fatigue at all.

berold profile image
berold in reply to PMRpro

Thanks PMRpro....comments much appreciated

PMRandRA profile image
PMRandRA in reply to Hindags

I also don't have much fatigue. I get tired yes, and my muscles tend to "clog up" and be very painful after too much work , but fatigue is gladly not on my list of horrors and this despite getting up for the loo up to 10 times a night!

SnazzyD profile image
SnazzyD

Ho ho, in my part of the UK we're crying out for rain. My South African plants are quite happy, but the English cottage garden plants are on their last legs!

I think I'd want at least some sort of explanation of what they think is supposedly going on physiologically with the cryo.

PMRandRA profile image
PMRandRA

ROFL! And what rain would that be? lol! We are in drought circumstances too and your photo certainly says that Kaapstaad is in better nick than we are. Take a peek at Wimbledon! 🤣😂 (watch it rain now!)

Unfortunately, I know nothing about Cryogenics as treatment for the alive, so am actually writing to say hi to the beautiful Cape! ☺️

Good luck in your quest and take care!

😄

karools16 profile image
karools16

Haai berold. Greetings from a S.An from PE, living in UK. Haven't a clue about cryotherapy...at first thought crying was going to be the latest 'fad'. What a thought!

Rabbit1951 profile image
Rabbit1951

Wonderful photo, I live in beautiful Maroochydore, Qld. Like you I started on 10mg Prednisone and now down to 2 mg a day. I am dancing 3 days a week and riding my bicycle most days.

I am happy just trying to gradually reduce and hope to stop treatment in a few months. I follow Kate Gilbert's advice in her book. I am now gluten free and try to eat healthy. Good luck with your treatment.

berold profile image
berold in reply to Rabbit1951

Thanks for comment...I did the same as you in following kate gilberts book.....and exercise. I think once you are down to 2mg (or every other day) then you dont have to worry about cortisone side effects too much.

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57

Greetings from the UK berold, lovely picture of SA.

Interesting to read your post, especially about playing squash. I used to really enjoy playing it regularly into my mid 50's, (I'm 60 now). But squash is notoriously tough on the joints and muscles due to its fast pace -as I well-know! Maybe your niggles are just a combination of that + some residual PMR inflammation + getting older? (sorry!). Either way, doing any sport like this well into your 60's is pretty good going by any standards!

As for your relatively fast pred reduction (well done!) due to having a possible 'reactive' form of PMR, it does appear that there are different 'strains' (?) in terms of severity / duration etc, and also that it can affect men and women differently. I'm certain that my PMR was caused by an auto-immune over-reaction to a bout of bacterial pneumonia, and I think there's a clinical research study from the Netherlands (?) with some evidence that viral and bacterial infections can trigger PMR.

As for cryotherapy (as opposed to crying therapy!), I seem to remember that, for some minor sports injuries (e.g. muscle sprains etc), a localised cold compress is often recommended to reduce inflammation / swelling / pain in the blood vessels surrounding the injured bit. It sounds like cryotherapy works on the same principle? Mmm, but maybe a bag of frozen peas might do the same job cheaper (and you can eat them afterwards)?!

That said, I see that the PMR 'Aunties' are already on the case and they are the people who know best. Just don't get on the wrong side of them.... ;-) :-D

Hope this helps, enjoy the sunshine there.

MB :-)

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to markbenjamin57

See you, MB - stop insinuating nasty things about us. Or we will turn nasty - but only to you ;-) ;-) ;-)

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to PMRpro

Ohhhhh,, :-(. It's back behind the sofa for me then (again..)? :-/ ;-)

PMRandRA profile image
PMRandRA in reply to PMRpro

Don't believe a word of it MB!

Our PMRpro doesn't know how to be nasty beyond baring her pearly whites now and again! 😂🌹

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to PMRandRA

I know, PMRandRA, just PMRpro and me winding each other up (as usual - it gets quite competitive sometimes!) ;-) :-D

PMRandRA profile image
PMRandRA in reply to markbenjamin57

And it is fun to read MB! Nothing like a nice bit of banter to raise the tone! 😲😂😜

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to PMRandRA

Thanks PMRandRA. But I don't know about raising the tone - LOWERING it, more like!? ;-) :-D

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to markbenjamin57

MB hits the nail on the head again... ;-)

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to PMRpro

Bless... :-) All I can say is: YOU LOT started it! ;-) :-D

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply to markbenjamin57

Good job I didn't read this yesterday after my very trying day - took 12 hrs to get from sunny Dorset to even sunnier Spain via the vagaries of flybe!

In a better mood today so will let you off reprimand !

BTW don't recommend you eat the defrosted frozen peas - typical man!

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to DorsetLady

Ohhh DL, that's crazy (12 hours etc...). So what am I supposed to do with the peas? Eat them frozen (or maybe load my pea shooter with them)? :-D

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply to markbenjamin57

As usual you've gone off on a tangent- you mentioned about using frozen peas to reduce inflammation- so once they'e defrosted you shouldn't use them for eating. Supposed to be cooked from frozen, not when they're a mush!

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to DorsetLady

Never did quite get why it makes a difference - they have to get to thawed while cooking. Nor the stuff about not refreezing things - being as they do it in factories...

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to PMRpro

PMRpro and DL

Clearly, this is very serious and controversial topic on which many of Us Lot have strong and diametrically opposing views.

I fear that it will inevitably develop into a long-running saga of Acrimony and bitter Conflict - but hopefully, ultimately, Reconciliation.

The title: War and Peas..?

:-D :-D :-D

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply to markbenjamin57

Stop it! I'm on me hollerdays!

Much more important fish to fry!

DorsetLady profile image
DorsetLadyPMRGCAuk volunteer in reply to PMRpro

'Elf & safety as usual!

Hindags profile image
Hindags in reply to DorsetLady

Pea soup?

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to Hindags

I wondered about mushy peas - but they require that tablet thing don't they?

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to PMRpro

This is all getting VERY silly now - I like it! :-)

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to Hindags

:-D

Marie1479 profile image
Marie1479

Greetings from NY! What is a niggle?

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to Marie1479

Hi Marie

'Niggle' (noun or verb): a trivial annoyance or criticism, e.g. I have a niggle (n.) in my back / stop niggling! (v.)

MB ;-)

Marie1479 profile image
Marie1479 in reply to markbenjamin57

Love it!

markbenjamin57 profile image
markbenjamin57 in reply to Marie1479

Apparently of Scandinavian origins, 'nigla' - to be ineffectual. We use it a lot in British English.

e.g. Stop niggling / I have a niggling doubt / problem with my car etc.

:-)

berold profile image
berold in reply to markbenjamin57

Thanks for the comments Mark

Rugger profile image
Rugger

I have bursitis and read very recently - I forget if it was on this forum (pred head?) that if you freeze water in a yoghurt pot and then apply that to the joint, presumably taken out of the pot and wrapped in a cloth to prevent 'freezer burn' - that might help. Cheaper than 132 pounds and you get to take the yoghurt with your pred! It said it was better than a bag of peas - not sure why. I've not tried it yet as I'm still plucking up the courage, as I'm a bit nesh. "Nesh" = English dialect adjective meaning unusually susceptible to cold weather. Obviously you wouldn't know about that at the moment!

Hindags profile image
Hindags

Niggling and Nash : two words of the day. I was Nesh the first sixty years of my life. But, postmenapausal, (PM vs PMR) I became the opposite of Nesh. Heat became my nemeses instead of cold.

The My husband who was always a cold lover has become Nesh . I find many couple friends have followed the same pattern.

Do you have a word for the opposite of Nesh?

You may also like...

Does pain from PMR move round the body

works it indicates the PMR must be the problem. Is it common for the location of PMR pain to...

Does exercise help or hinder PMR aches?

I have had PMR for at least 2 years and successfully did a slow taper from 15mg to 0. I took no...

Other Symptoms when Reducing Prednisone

typical PMR symptoms? Or can PMR include some of these symptoms too? Is it unusual that I'm not...

It's me again...finally.

withdrawal symptoms. I have been off the prednisone now for 10 weeks. I have arm and buttocks...

Newly diagnosed with PMR

I have just been diagnosed with PMR after a good number of months of increasing pain and discomfort.