Why does it matter if you take too much B... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

25,510 members26,824 posts

Why does it matter if you take too much B1 if excessive B1 is excreted anyway?

narcisa956 profile image
16 Replies

Hi everyone!

I have been on B1 injections for 3 months now (100 mg weekly). I have no idea if this dose is suitable for me. But one question is haunting me - why is it so important to find just the right dose? Why not take a very high dose and let the excess be excreted anyway? I hope this is not a stupid question :(

Best wishes! Mojca

Written by
narcisa956 profile image
narcisa956
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
16 Replies
pdpatient profile image
pdpatient

You are correct. Don't see any harm in an overdose:

ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/T...

livestrong.com/article/3672...

michaeljfox.org/news/thiami...

chartist profile image
chartist

narcisa956,

What forum members have reported who are using or testing HDT/B-1 and so has Dr. Costantini, is that a dose that is too high will very frequently cause a worsening of existing PD symptoms and in some cases, new symptoms may appear that have not previously been experienced. Overall, PD symptoms seem to worsen at too high of a dose.

Art

WinnieThePoo profile image
WinnieThePoo in reply to chartist

Thank you. But that doesn't really answer the question. If excess b1 is excreted, how can you overdose?

chartist profile image
chartist in reply to WinnieThePoo

Intake rate is greater than the use and excretion rate.

Art

WinnieThePoo profile image
WinnieThePoo in reply to chartist

Thank you. That works. It is therefore important to clarify that, within a reasonable safety band , excess B1 is excreted, but above a certain level it can cause adverse events

rescuema profile image
rescuema

Have you checked your serum magnesium status? If you're not noticing much difference, in the least be sure that you're not deficient in Mg since it is a required co-factor. Magnesium L-Threonate is a good form to try to cross the BBB.

The reason why the correct amount (of anything) is important involves the understanding of methylation metabolism, but incorrect balance because of malnutrition (or SNPs/epigenetics/toxins) can lead to high level of homocysteine (b6, b9 and b12 involved, an inflammatory biomarker) and among other things affect glycine (inhibitory neurotransmitter & a buffer of excess methyl groups, used by SAM->SAH). If you end up exhausting nutrients and the available methyl groups (CH3 - needed for the synthesis of creatine, phosphatidylcholine, etc) that starts/stops any gene/enzymatic reactions, it causes backups/jams in the cycle and you could also end up wasting glycine (esp if deficient in b2, choline or due to excess b3/b9 metabolism), and dysregulation of dopamine (COMT methylation), histamine (need methyl donor SAM and NAD+ to be metabolized), etc. B1 is used as an important cofactor (a spark) of most enzymatic reactions in the Krebs cycle for ATP required for methylation involving all Bs and other nutrients/minerals (including the important magnesium, zinc, copper, etc).

The result of imbalance of various reactions in the simplest relevant explanation will involve a no reaction or possible increased inflammation (back/joint/muscle pain), decreased detox, and worsening of PD symptom, but not permanent if because of short run B1 overdose. This is the reason why it's also important to identify/address any nutritional gap.

Dap1948 profile image
Dap1948 in reply to rescuema

Wow! Now we know! Or we do if we could understand it! Thanks. I'll reread and eventually I'll work it out what you're saying!

Juliegrace profile image
Juliegrace

Too high of a dose made me jittery, kept me awake and made my dyskinesia worse. Some members have reported high blood pressure from too high of a dose and some others have also reported feeling jittery. It may not be "harmful" but it may make you feel bad.

narcisa956 profile image
narcisa956 in reply to Juliegrace

Thanks, Juliegrace !

rescuema profile image
rescuema in reply to Juliegrace

Excess histamine in result of induced undermethylation (not enough methyl donors left after ramped up B1 metabolism and nutrient shortage) can affect the circadian rhythms (sleep/wake cycle) and cause insomnia, jitter, rash, allaergies, GERD, etc. Low glycine (because this transsulfuration synthesis through cysteine takes a backseat to SAM availability and dependent on adequate methylation) also affects sleep, inflammation, and detoxification (glycine is needed for glutathione). Blood pressure regulation can get compromised if left deficient in CH3 and magnesium that controls potassium (or deficient in K). If dopamine reuptake activity (esp if left excess of b3 that inhibits sirtuin thus increases DAT transport) dominates the amount available (compounded by deficient CH3 for dopamine synthesis from tyrosine), you’re left with lesser of the NT and feel worse.

Gioc profile image
Gioc

Hi Narcisa

Thiamine has been known and used for more than a hundred years to solve "beri beri", and also in emergency rooms to solve alcohol problems. Its pharmacokinetics and its effects have been widely studied. Here's a study of how b1 behaves in blood. You will also find interesting the amount of studies in references especially point 31 , 32 if I am not mistaken.

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

narcisa956 profile image
narcisa956 in reply to Gioc

Thank you so much !

rescuema profile image
rescuema in reply to narcisa956

It’s also important to keep in mind that some people have compromised active transport activity of thiamine especially if they’ve been deficient for a while. That is why a high dose therapy is needed for the passive transport so that absorption could occur, and if the transketolase enzyme activity slowly gets restored for the active transport(for some this doesn’t happen), you can reduce the amount of the dosage eventually. I assume this is why Dr. C started his patients at as high as 2-4g oral dosage to begin with, monitor symptoms, and adjust per individual. You can also opt for TTFD since it does not depend on the transport enzymes to cross the BBB.

Oceanflow profile image
Oceanflow in reply to rescuema

I’m missing the obvious probably, but what is TTFD?

rescuema profile image
rescuema in reply to Oceanflow

Thiamine tetrahydrofurfuryl disulfide. You can purchase the product called Allithiamine or Lipothiamine (seems with less filler and enteric coated).

hormonesmatter.com/ttfd-thi...

MarionP profile image
MarionP

Answer: you can have side effects or potential toxic interactions or mutatiins that affect your processing to the bad. Also see Sharon's recent comment that's worth researching.

Also per rescuema comment a couple days ago now looking into TTFD.

You may also like...

Does B1 make you tired?

Didn’t find any direct answer to my question. But in one answer it said that the dose may be too...

Does anyone take B1 and Mannitol?

got that general impression.) My question- Does anyone take both and have their dosage of one...

How much B1 as TTFD does this contain? Can Anybody Read Japanese?

*** I ended up with High Blood Pressure taking TTFD. I no longer take TTFD. Based on my experience,...

Can Too Much B1 HCL (Thiamine HCL) Cause Hypertension or Other Side Effects?

I realize that many people have benefited from B1 HCL, but I've read on some sites that there is...

My New Deck (or why I was too busy to do much research this summer)

new stairs/deck, and people wanted to see it. I have included a picture and here is the video tour:...