To boost or not to boost, that is the question - NRAS

NRAS

36,571 members45,173 posts

To boost or not to boost, that is the question

attatel profile image
12 Replies

Hi All,

I hope you are all having a decent day.

This is a bit of a daft question, but then, when did that ever stop me?

I often see people recommending foods and supplements that boost the immune system. But don't we all take all sorts of hideous medication specifically to thwart our immune systems?

So, how does this work?

I'm a bit confused by it!

Thanks!

Terry

Written by
attatel profile image
attatel
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
12 Replies
charisma profile image
charisma

Supplements boost immune system health. We need health restored to ours!

helixhelix profile image
helixhelix

Yes, I agree. And I avoid anything that is said to stimulate the immune system like echinea. However the word “boost” does mean slightly different things in different contexts. It can mean to increase, but it can also mean merely to help improve - give you a boost = give you a helping hand. And we need our body including our immune system to work as well as it can.

The immune system isn't one thing either, it’s a huge range of processes. So while I don't want the immune system response nibbling away at my joints I do want it to function more broadly.

So for example I pay a lot of attention to eating well because I want to help my body work as well as it can, and for example not get my digestive system bogged down processing junk food that adds nothing. I personally take no supplements apart fromVit D in winter because I get everything I need in my diet, but that’s a choice we each need to make for ourselves.

attatel profile image
attatel in reply to helixhelix

Thanks! That's more or less what I was thinking. So many things that are recommended for general health benefits are also said to boost the immune system and it does make me wonder sometimes! I'm pretty sure that things like, say blackcurrants (a recipe for a syrup, that emphasised it's benefits to the immune system was what made me post this) probably help more than hinder in general.

AgedCrone profile image
AgedCrone

It doesn’t necessarily work...we don't need our immune system boosting ....we need it to be controlled.

Speak to your rheumy nurse...she will tell you if there are any supplements that may help you.

But everybody is different ...please don’t try DIY supplements...your rheumatologist will prescribe what you need...usually a healthy balanced diet!

attatel profile image
attatel in reply to AgedCrone

I agree! I was thinking of things like fruit more than supplements. I often read how beneficial certain fruits are, then they say 'great for boosting your immune system' ! Also spices like turmeric which is a proven anti-inflammatory but guess what? Great for strengthening the immune system!

It doesn't put me off things like blueberries but my heart sinks a bit whenever I read that!

AgedCrone profile image
AgedCrone in reply to attatel

I have always eaten whatever I fancy within reason....in the early days I think I had a brain freeze & tried Echinacea....after three weeks I was back walking with two sticks. When I told my rheumy he laughed & said that would teach me not to make decisions like that again.......so I haven’t!

Lizard28 profile image
Lizard28

I find this confusing as well, I keep meaning to ask my doc next time I see her. I’ve been taking B12 tablets for 3 months, my last bloods showed folic acid low. I read the leaflet that was in the box and they said Do Not take if:

You have B12 deficiency, Have Cancer, or allergic to anything in them eg lactose which I’m currently getting tested for, I’m on a no lactose diet for a month. These tablets were prescribed by my haematologist and I have all these things stated. Very confusing..

attatel profile image
attatel in reply to Lizard28

Typical! I've noticed this before e.g. patient leaflet: may interract with methotrexate, rheumatologist: it's fine

I hope you get all this stuff under control soon!

Troygirl profile image
Troygirl

John Hopkins rheumatology center says supplements and certain diets MAY have an effect on inflammation.

Now they are also saying having a few drinks can reduce inflammation. But with all the poisonous drugs they give us we are not supposed to drink one drop. Which is it?

arthritis-alternatives.com/...

attatel profile image
attatel in reply to Troygirl

I don't know, but I vote for the alcohol option! :D

attatel profile image
attatel

Just noticed that under my post there's a link to related tags "thwart". Who knew there was a whole separate category of "thwart" posts! :D

Sumdy profile image
Sumdy

I've thought that too Terry 🙂

You may also like...

Help me boost my immune system!

and I'm also on steroids, so I'm guessing my immune system isn't going to fight this cold off...

Lowered immune question!

ride it out a bit longer? Just wondered what other people's experiences are? Does stopping the meds...

Tapering prednisolone but need boost

me through a change of drugs because I was in a bit of a pickle. Started on 7 1/2 mg. got new drugs.

Questions, questions, questions

asked for ill health retirement if it is granted does anyone know what the implications are for...

Circulation-boosting machines - any thoughts?

available!!) and they do seem to help most people. But does anyone know if they're suitable for...