Oncologist Report -- Strange? - The Roy Castle Lu...

The Roy Castle Lung Cancer Foundation

5,952 members3,549 posts

Oncologist Report -- Strange?

Beatless profile image
7 Replies

Finished 3 courses of Chemo, GemCarbo, & had scan last week.

Oncologist phoned today, said result "Better than he had expected".

I said "Has the tumor shrunk", he said "it's hard to measure because it's now not a solid lump, it's a shadow"

Should I be pleased?

What does he mean, "Just a shadow"?

Written by
Beatless profile image
Beatless
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
7 Replies

I have no idea but if I were to place a bet I would say it sounds positive! Strange he/she didn’t explain more … have you tried calling your nurse? She/he will be able to help and get more answers for you!

Beatless profile image
Beatless in reply toCockailschemocancer

No, not called the nurse. Thanks for your reply.

Other members:- Any more information?

Bow-19 profile image
Bow-19

Could you ask for a copy of the scan report? Then ask them to explain it again in clearer terms x

Bow-19 profile image
Bow-19

If you have a copy of the report then you can compare it with your next scan too. You could also ask for a copy of your first scan report to compare

RoyCastleHelpline profile image
RoyCastleHelplinePartnerAsk the NurseRoy Castle

Dear Beatless

It is encouraging that the oncologist said it ' was better than expected' and understandable how you have been left perhaps feeling a little confused.

With solid tumours usually the margins can be well defined and easy to measure, with a shadow you can imagine that it is more difficult to see therefore difficult to measure and define.

You need more clarification what this means and you can either contact your lung cancer nurse, oncologist or GP to discuss.

If you would like to discuss anything you can either email us at lungcancerhelp@roycastle.org or call our free phone nurse led helpline number on 0800 358 7200

Kind regards

The Roy Castle Support Team

Beatless profile image
Beatless in reply toRoyCastleHelpline

Thanks all, have arranged to discuss with Nurse on Friday

JanetteR57 profile image
JanetteR57

I guess it does sound confusing - the oncologist is clearly reading from the report that would have been done and verified by experienced radiologists/imaging - covid 19 revealed what short supply there is nationally of those able to interpret thoracic scans well as this speciality has mostly been developed for lung cancer/respiratory diseases. I'm never sure that getting copies of clinical scans/letters helps as they're written in medical terminology designed to help healthcare professionals who study for years to gain their experience but I know when I asked one patient who said he always asked for his how he can understand them, he revealed he was a doctor himself! So if it helps for comfort, then by all means ask but if you might not know what you're looking at - I certainly had never seen a CT for example before I was shown my own and didn't even know which way was up! The oncologist has tried to put it into plain language and clearly failed but I certainly would be pleased if it was my scan but I'd always encourage that if you don't understand something you're told to query it with the team themselves who will have your results there and can also learn to improve their communication skills for next time or with other patients... good luck.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

1sr Appointment with Oncologist

Good evening everyone. Good news - the cancer has not spread beyond my lungs! He thinks...
Aamar profile image

Ct chest scan

Is it normal to have to wait 4 months for ct scan. Had chest infection in May..xray showed white...
Hollyhops profile image

Adenocarcinoma Left lung

Morning everyone. I am now 18 months post left lower lobe removed. I have two suspicious nodules...

So scared after CT scan showed shadow on lung

Hello. I was referred for a chest CT scan by my endocrinologist (I have Graves Disease) following...
Trumps profile image

My Mums got lung cancer

Just been diagnosed with lung cancer, she's 80 yrs old generally in good health. She's sees an...
claregreg profile image

Moderation team

See all

Top community tags

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.