Fish consumption and PCa Mortality. A... - Fight Prostate Ca...

Fight Prostate Cancer

2,910 members1,175 posts

Fish consumption and PCa Mortality. A meta-analysis.

pca2004 profile image
16 Replies

New study below. [1]

"In total, 25 prospective cohort studies, recruiting 1,216,474 men, were included in the systematic review, and 22 studies were included in the meta-analysis. During the follow-up periods, ranging from 6 to 33 years, a total of 44,722 cases of prostate cancer were recorded."

" ... the summary RR {relative risk} was 0.55 ... for prostate cancer mortality and 0.84 ... for prostate cancer progression, indicating an inverse association between fish intake and prostate cancer mortality."

"Also, in the dose-response analyzes, each 20 gram/day increase in total fish intake was associated with a 12% lower risk of prostate cancer mortality.

"Our findings support the protective association between total fish intake and the risk of prostate cancer mortality."

***

The meta-analysis is about fish intake rather than pescetarianism (no meat - sometimes described as "vegetarian + fish"), which may be an excellent strategy for PCa survival. I'll go out on a limb & predict that a Mediterranean pescetarian diet (40% fat) would be the best bet for cardiovascular & PCa survival. imo

-Patrick

[1] pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/375...

Written by
pca2004 profile image
pca2004
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
16 Replies
Magnus1964 profile image
Magnus1964

As a pecatarian I welcome this report.

Magnus

Peppertree602 profile image
Peppertree602

Perfect!!! My kind of diet

MateoBeach profile image
MateoBeach

So about 175 grams fish per day may take PC cancer mortality to zero. Go fish! 😆 (joking)

pca2004 profile image
pca2004 in reply toMateoBeach

Hi Paul,

I always wonder how many increases the data supports before that risk reduction rule breaks down. At least three, I suppose. (Similarly, when a constant benefit has been observed "per standard deviation".)

20 grams of fish is only 0.7 ounces.

But we should not exceed the protein needs of our bodies. In fact, limiting intake of pre-formed protein may lower IGF-I levels.

-Patrick

Nusch profile image
Nusch in reply topca2004

I’m vegan since 6 years and just recently added fish to replace my too many supplements by good fish. I agree with IGF-1 and would avoid all dairy and of course other meet.

treedown profile image
treedown

Having just finished some delicious wild Alaskan Sockeye this is a welcomed read. Guess I'll get more next weekend.

Cooolone profile image
Cooolone

Well, if I recall correctly, the Eskimo's were very healthy, until a variety of diseases appeared and with investigation found it was the industrial rainwater bringing Mercury poisoning via their heavy fish diet to be a major contributing factor.

Okinawan's who enjoy the highest population density of centurians, also have a high ration fish diet, including vegetables...

Good stuff, thanks for posting!

pca2004 profile image
pca2004 in reply toCooolone

The advice generally given is to eat fish that are low down in the food chain. But I can't eat sardines every day.

The following link has a table of 66 fish, showing median/mean mercury levels:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mercu...

One can also search for PCB data.

-Patrick

cigafred profile image
cigafred

I too am betting on a pescatorian diet with Mediterranean characteristics.

Kuanyin profile image
Kuanyin

Hi Patrick,

A few comments re fish. The other night on the PBS nightly news, there was a segment that covered the latest developments on that gift that keeps on giving, the radioactive water from the Japanese nuclear reactors at Fukushima. The Japanese are preparing to increase the water dumped from the holding tanks built to contain the contaminated water—it seems that the Japanese have run out of land to build additional tanks. I suspect that we on the West coast have had our diets enhanced with these radioactive wastes in addition to the so-called “forever chemicals,” PFAS found in our drinking water. I used to rage against fish farming because of the many reports on the disgusting way the fish are raised, a la Costco chickens. However, for these past few years I won't eat wild fish, except possibly, those caught around Norway or maybe Portugal (I love their sardines). Although we are told how great “wild caught” Alaskan salmon is, I am very suspicious about the safety of these animals. Supposedly, the fish farmers have cleaned up their act. If this is true, at least there is a possibility of some kind of quality control vs the fish coming across the Pacific to us from Fukushima.

Magnus1964 profile image
Magnus1964

Another 50 years and whole planet will be uninhabitable. It will only take another 100,000 years before we can start over.

Sunlight12 profile image
Sunlight12 in reply toMagnus1964

I can't help but think that if we made the problem, we should be able to undo the problem; it's just a matter of figuring out *how*. ...And of getting those who have the resources to focus on the *how*! (instead of just dumping waste water and shrugging🙄)

-Sun

Nusch profile image
Nusch in reply toMagnus1964

One of my sons is just finishing his PhD in technical physics and he’s much more optimistic than you and me. He feeds me with links about innovations and I start trusting him that we‘ll manage the turn around.

Sunlight12 profile image
Sunlight12 in reply toNusch

Oh how cool, Nusch!! Is there anywhere you or he recommends to read about some of them? I like to read positive things; it helps balance out the negativity!

-Sun

Nusch profile image
Nusch in reply toSunlight12

‘We’re changing the clouds.’ An unintended test of geoengineering is fueling record ocean warmth | Science | AAAS

Read this e.g.

cujoe profile image
cujoe

Hi, Patrick,

In the spirit our resident HU humorist, j-o-h-n, I can only add that:

"This topic seems more than a bit fishy to me . . . and maybe, even somewhat radioactive."

Fall approaches and you are in very good location to appreciate it. Stay S&W while you do.

Ciao, Kaptin K9

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Beta Blockers.

Interesting piece in the August Life Extension magazine. Beta blockers inhibit progression in...
pca2004 profile image

More Evidence Linking ADT for PCa to Adverse Neurocognitive Effects -Meta-analysis shows increased risk of dementia, Parkinson's, depression

As if we needed more reasons to dislike or avoid ADT, here is additional evidence of negative...
cujoe profile image

Efficacy and safety of BAT in CRPC following Abi or Enza resistance: A systematic review

New meta-analysis below [1] [2]. Hard to believe that there are enough BAT studies to perform this...
pjoshea13 profile image

Low Testosterone Linked With Mortality Risk in Aging Men - by Jeff Minerd , Contributing Writer, MedPage Today May 13, 2024

No way to know if this is applicable to those on ADT, but it would seem to be relevant for...
cujoe profile image

Cheese

New umbrella study of cheese & health outcomes [1].   The authors are Chinese – with the exception...
pca2004 profile image