Gut health vs. brain health - conflicting... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,583 members27,897 posts

Gut health vs. brain health - conflicting guidance

7 Replies

Many doctors, like Perlmutter for example advise very little to no grains so one can reach a state of ketosis which is best for the brain.

But then I read other doctors (Like Dr. B, gut MD) and he recommends feeding the colon gut bugs prebiotic fibrous foods to keep the gut bugs happy.

For the seemingly rare people who go to great lengths to implement a diet for optimum gut and brain health, how do you navigate the balance between gut health and brain health optimization?

(And respectfully, I appreciate Dr. Mischley immensely as she is a much needed ally but her understanding of this is very limited)

7 Replies
bookish profile image
bookish

Interesting points and of course I don't have an answer. I am grain free as I can't tolerate them, which seemed to improve brain function and gut absorption and I eat a good clean diet with as diverse a range of veg and fruit as possible. The interaction of the vagus nerve for gut-brain, brain-gut communication seems so important, so I do exercises to help that. I am part way through Datis Kharrazian's epic tome 'Why Isn't My Brain Working?' - wish I'd had it years ago and would recommend to anyone interested. (He talks of ketosis and the importance of fasting - although this has become more strongly indicated more recently, so not so much in the book, more on his website, lectures etc - but only once blood sugar imbalances have been resolved.) Best wishes

in reply tobookish

Thank you for the book recommendation. I have just ordered it. When you said that you "do exercise to help with that" how does that relate to the vagus nerve? Can you please elaborate? I really appreciate your help.

bookish profile image
bookish in reply to

Hi, my pleasure and I hope you find it as interesting as I do.

Re. the vagus - I have had an ebook of Datis Kharrazian's called 'The Autoimmune Diet - The gut-brain repair guide' for a couple of years now in which he basically recommends the following (the ebook vagus section is much as you'll find it in his brain book, although the latter has more detail)

(1) gargle every sip of a large glass of water as long and hard as you can, trying to make your eyes water, and do it several times a day if possible, for several weeks. I do at least one glass daily.

(2) sing loudly - I try to vary pitch, sing very softly then really loud, mix it up a bit. Some frequencies give me different sensations, so I sing a good variety, annoyingly often because I've always loved singing! I also hum (easier to do less obviously) and whistle.

(3) He suggests a box of tongue blades to stimulate gag reflex - lay on back of tongue and push down (don't jab back of throat). I use the handle of a wooden spoon, a few times a day as convenient.

Gag reflexes are like doing push-ups for the vagus, while gargling and singing are like doing sprints, according to DK. They need to be challenging to make muscles contract and stimulate GI tract.

He also suggests coffee enemas (particularly for those with lack of bowel motility too) which will activate the vagus, but I haven't tried that (yet!).

These can all also support/improve liver function and ability to 'detox' waste products.

Cheers

laglag profile image
laglag in reply to

Go to YouTube and search for Vegus nerve exercises. I haven't tried them but strongly thinking about it.

gaga1958 profile image
gaga1958

There’s more than 1 Dr Matthew Phillips. Look for the one from New Zealand. Google with Dr Perlmutter. Interesting info on fasting and Parkinson’s.

in reply togaga1958

Thank you! Thank you for taking the time to clarify. Much appreciated!

Jandeb profile image
Jandeb

veggies contain much more fiber than grains both per calorie and per gram. And veggies contain substantially more protective compounds

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

The Gut-Brain Connection: How it Works and The Role of Nutrition; Explained in layman's language as per Healthline

"This article explores the gut-brain axis and foods that are beneficial to its health." "Your gut...
MBAnderson profile image

How the Keto Diet Impacts Gut Health And The Microbiome

Now, we started out talking about the keto diet and went down a little bit of a gut health rabbit...
Kia17 profile image

How does what's in your gut affect your brain?

LOVE YOUR GUTS. 90% of your serotonin is made in your guts and you have hundreds of trillions of...
Farooqji profile image

Berberine for leaky gut and Parkinson's ?

Several months ago I was diagnosed with atrial fibrillation and have been looking for alternative...
faridaro profile image

Are you taking these antioxident vitamins to cure your gut?

As you know, the consensus from docs is that our PD started in our gut (and some say our nose, as...