Thiamine and the placebo effect. - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,588 members27,912 posts

Thiamine and the placebo effect.

Tfrk profile image
Tfrk
22 Replies

Does anyone have any information on clinical studies on high dose thiamine hcl and the placebo effect? I am thinking seriously about starting the thiamine protocol and am just curious. Perhaps the answer is that there is no or little downside to taking thiamine - but I have no information on that either. Would appreciate replies with info on either question. Thanks.

Written by
Tfrk profile image
Tfrk
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
22 Replies
wifeofparky profile image
wifeofparky

although B vitamins are water soluble and easily excreted I also would like to see valid clinical studies as opposed to testimonials

in reply towifeofparky

You may have a very long wait for such studies at the dosing being used by Dr. Costantini. If you search the internet for thiamine toxicity, you are going to have a hard time finding much data on the subject. There are some side effects as already mentioned on this forum, but side effects reported for standard PD meds seem to be more frequent and more significant.

Art

wifeofparky profile image
wifeofparky in reply to

without double blind placebo studies we will never know what really works and at what dosage. Dr C is merely dosing at what he thinks is correct with no real validation or reporting of side effects or toxicity.

We all want that 'silver bullet' and I am skeptical

in reply towifeofparky

I understand the skepticism! Who will pay for those studies though? They will cost millions of dollars. Dr. Costantini is merely going forward based on the currently known safety of B-1. He is now treating over 3,500 patients with high dose B-1 and has been doing so for over five years with very minimal side effects in over five years of experience. Nobody is making anyone take high dose B-1 and if you want to wait for those placebo controlled double blind studies, you should, for your own peace of mind. I'm just saying it may be a very long wait! Btw, Dr. Costantini's results have been very good and quite a few HU members who have followed his protocol as he recommends in his free email consults, would agree!

Art

in reply to

What the lady is saying is how on earth one can begin to think thiamine would be any good for anything. I took a few years ago. It wasn't cheap.

in reply to

I don't know what you paid for the thiamine that you bought a few years ago, but thiamine is inexpensive as witnessed by many forum members who have purchased it this year and reported their results on this forum!

Art

in reply to

I will give another try then. It was in pure powder, no additives.

nellie58 profile image
nellie58 in reply to

I purchased a years worth of vials and it was 250euro.

nellie58 profile image
nellie58 in reply towifeofparky

If there is enough desperation and if you have come to the end of the road with conventional medication like my husband did, then B1 is a lifesaver. We were staring into a bleak future after our visit with a leading Neurologist. He had not answers at all. Just more drugs with different side effects and the promise of a downward decline. My hubby has improved since our journey started with B1 and I want so badly to go back and show that Dr but no way would we waste the money to pay for the appointment. If hubby was doing ok on regular meds we would possibly not have had this adventure. I am so grateful to this forum and all the brave people that tried this treatment and showed us the way. My wish is that every new patient is put straight onto this protocol. Imagine a world where Parkinsons is stopped in its tracks?

KLDA profile image
KLDA in reply towifeofparky

When I first purchased B-1, I purchased Nutricost B-1 with mononitrate. the added mononitrate makes it fat soluble. When I discovered this I switched to Solgar.

in reply toKLDA

Solgar monohydrate or thiamine hcl?

Better choice would be easy swallow capsules, 500mg, 300 count. You might choke on Solgar tablets.

KLDA profile image
KLDA in reply to

I agree RoyProp Solgar are large and difficult to swallow. I purchased these because someone recommended them. Are you willing to recommend a brand? I just checked on Amazon and there appears to be a plethora of choices.

KLDA profile image
KLDA in reply toKLDA

OOPS I just noticed that you said Solgar monohydrate. I'll check this brand out.

in reply toKLDA

no! Nutricost B-1 with mononitrate (should be thiamin hcl)

Vitacost vitamin B1 (as thiamin HCI) 500mg, easy swallow capsules

29$ for 300 capsules.

Vitacost.com out of stock until October;

Last time I checked, 42$ through Amazon but listing may no longer be active on Amazon.

KLDA profile image
KLDA in reply to

Thank You - I found it (vitacost.com/vitacost-vitam..., good price. I'll be ordering after their new supply comes in in October.

KERRINGTON profile image
KERRINGTON in reply to

I take 1 at a time, crunch twice, make a face, take 2 gulps of water..swallow... repeat. It's worth it.

KLDA profile image
KLDA in reply toKERRINGTON

I'll try it, can't wait :)

Kia17 profile image
Kia17

I don’t think Double blind placebo trial for Thiamin ever happens.It’s like to say If ever the production of Tobacco or liqueur stop,casinos are closed,corn farms stop producing, big pharma gets well regulated then we can be hopeful for such studies.

in reply toKia17

It looks like you can get vit B1 on the FDA approved script. Having said that wouldn't you be getting enough from food?

Lbi1608 profile image
Lbi1608

It’s always good to question. Given that there is no cure or perfect treatment plan for all the variations of PD symptoms, I seek progress not perfection. So if there is little to none side effects I give it a try. Even if it is placebo the fact that the body is showing less symptoms is enough progress. Once again it’s personal choice and quality of life that guides my choices

Best of luck

Tfrk profile image
Tfrk

Ok - thanks for all the responses. The more perspectives you get, the better informed you are. I appreciate the willingness to share information. I have consulted with my normal neurologist to get one last perspective and double check on drug interactions but I expect I am going to go ahead with Dr. Costantini’s protocol and will post the results periodically on HU. Thanks to all.

Puneetforjosh profile image
Puneetforjosh

Start thaimine for one week.then you will never stop.you are engaged in useless thinking,which is giving more pain to the patient.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Vitamin B1 : Thiamine vs. Benfotiamine

Why is it that the HDT of B1 is with Thiamine instead of Benfotiamine? Thiamine is water soluble...

Thiamine B1 and the placebo effect

First of all I do not care if B1 helps or not the mice as long as it is helping me from March 2018....
ion_ion profile image

Thiamine and magnesium

Does anyone have information on the interaction between thiamine (I am following the HDT protocol,...
tacato profile image

The murky waters of thiamine.

I see there is growing interest on high dose thiamine on this forum. Sadly, the topic is being...
sunvox profile image

Thiamine and Benfo Thiamine Advice

I have had thiamine tablets made up for me. They are thiamine hydrochloride 130mg. And I am advised...
Celtis profile image

Moderation team

See all
CPT_Aleksandra profile image
CPT_AleksandraAdministrator
CPT_Anaya profile image
CPT_AnayaAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.