Garmin regrets, I've had a few ...: Am so cross... - Couch to 5K

Couch to 5K

133,904 members โ€ข 159,326 posts

Garmin regrets, I've had a few ...

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate
โ€ข38 Replies

Am so cross with myself for not buying a Garmin Forerunner 35 in the Amazon Prime sale as it was seriously reduced.

I waivered because I thought, being on Wk9, I'm not a proper runner yet, I haven't caught the bug (only ran outside twice so far and whilst I think I enjoyed it, it was bl**dy tough, I need to find less hilly routes, and some where I won't get mowed down on country lanes) and is it good for a middle aged person's knees, should I be doing weights instead and the heat etc etc. So lots of excuses and negativity still bubbling about.

However, am putting a different spin on it today and wishing I'd bought one as I think it would have actually motivated me and made me feel more like a proper runner. Who knows.

May just have to bite the bullet and pay full price and that's the cost of my negativity and procrastination ๐Ÿ™„

Written by
Designbod profile image
Designbod
Graduate
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
38 Replies
โ€ข
Realfoodieclub profile image
RealfoodieclubGraduate

Oh can I just chirp in a say donโ€™t forget garmin records elevation as well as distance. I love seeing the elevation of my runs on my stats. Hehe but them I am total stats girl. Black Friday will be coming in a few months if you wanted to get it on a discount, Amazon tend to put a garmin in that.

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to Realfoodieclub

Thanks. Yes, the elevations around here would be mega! I last ran with Runkeeper last time and that recorded the elevations and they were pretty impressive. I already wear a Fitbit 24/7 and usually run with a Polar and strap as well plus my phone with Runkeeper (bit like a Christmas treee!) so I thought, do I need it, but am thinking that none of those do what I want that well.

Hmmm not sure I can wait till November. Wonder if anyone else does a Garmin sale in the meantime. Off to research!

Realfoodieclub profile image
RealfoodieclubGraduate in reply to Designbod

Keep an eye out in here as well someone usually posts when they see a garmin bargin ๐Ÿ˜€.

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to Realfoodieclub

Great tip, thanks ๐Ÿ‘

Me too Designbod. Saw Jays post but haven't had my FB Blaze that long and couldn't justify it. I'd also just come around from anaesthetic so didn't want to make a rash decision. I should've, at least I'd have had an excuse... ๐Ÿคฃ

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to

Ooh, hope all is well after your anaesthetic, yes definitely not wise to make impulse purchases when semi conscious!

It's a tricky one when you have a device already. My Fitbit 2 is a good activity tracker but doesn't specifically track running data and has no gps. Is the Blaze more running-specific?

I have the Polar as well so would look like a Xmas tree wearing them all ๐Ÿ˜†

in reply to Designbod

Lol at the Xmas tree! The Blaze uses phone GPS but I usually toggle that off in favour of Strava. Using both usually causes them both to crash.

It does have an improved exercise tracker from my old Charge 2, but speaking to others I can tell it's still way short of a proper running watch. Fastest pace and built-in GPS.

I'm finding it hard to justify, but am annoyed I upgraded Strava and paid the annual 45 quid which could've give towards the new tracker. Thought the paid version would be better tbh. Still, I'm finding out more each day so maybe not a bad decision after all.

I'll be watching out for a bargain too though so let's each shout to the other of we did anything!? ๐Ÿ˜‚

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to

Absolutely. Might be time for us Fitbitters to upgrade!

Curlygurly2 profile image
Curlygurly2Graduate

Oh what a shame, I've got a FR 35 and I LOVE it! May I ask how much "seriously reduced" was?

I expect you'll get another chance....

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to Curlygurly2

Think it was by about ยฃ35/40. So pleased to hear you love yours. How do you find the accuracy of the HR would you say? I wear a Fitbit 2 on my wrist 24/7 and I know that's not as accurate as my Polar watch with heart strap (plus I have a very weak pulse so my Fitbit sometimes loses it totally).

Curlygurly2 profile image
Curlygurly2Graduate in reply to Designbod

I paid about ยฃ120 for mine, much cheaper than from Garmin - as is always the case as far as I can tell. I don't really know about the heart rate monitor, it's consistent at least, I think it's accurate....

sallenson profile image
sallensonGraduate

Keep your eyes open. You'll see another bargain soon enough. One thing to be aware of is that the wrist HRM function doesn't work properly. The internet is awash with people having issues with getting an accurate Heart Rate count (apparently the device can lock on to your cadence instead). So may be worth doing a bit of homework before shelling out the dough....

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to sallenson

Thanks Sallenson, yes, I'd read about that. I had thought I'd read it can be connected to a chest strap too for added accuracy.

sallenson profile image
sallensonGraduate in reply to Designbod

Another 50 quid tho.... :-(

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to sallenson

Ouch! Was wondering if my Polar strap might work with it. Probably not!

Ripcurlrana71 profile image
Ripcurlrana71

I love my 35 and I donโ€™t think it was that heavily reduced on prime day? ๐Ÿค”

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to Ripcurlrana71

I think it was reduced by about ยฃ35/40 I may just suck it up and buy it anyway. Good to know you love yours ๐Ÿ˜€Presumably you need your smartphone on you still if you want to play music?

Ripcurlrana71 profile image
Ripcurlrana71 in reply to Designbod

Yes have Spotify on iphone. Also like to have phone anyway as I run alone and early!

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to Ripcurlrana71

Yes, I'd always want my phone too, even though it's the size of a small book!

Ripcurlrana71 profile image
Ripcurlrana71 in reply to Designbod

๐Ÿ˜‚๐Ÿ˜‚

CJDavies profile image
CJDaviesGraduate

Try camel camel.com. It will give you amazon price history and if you register set up price alerts. Not sure if it includes prime discounts mind

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to CJDavies

Thanks, great tip ๐Ÿ‘

Agelesslass profile image
Agelesslass

Sorry to tell you but this is where I bought mine, priced them beforehand and there was quite a bit of difference in the price. Love mine, only had it a few days but it is very motivating, bite the bullet as you said, youโ€™ll find itโ€™s worth it.

BlondeAmbition72 profile image
BlondeAmbition72Graduate

I bought one yesterday from Amazon!! Couldnโ€™t wait so I paid ยฃ130 - it arrives today Iโ€™m like a child waiting for Christmas lol!!

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to BlondeAmbition72

I may have to do the same, although Jay66UK 's comment below is making me dither over the 235, although twice the price but looks excellent ...๐Ÿค”

BlondeAmbition72 profile image
BlondeAmbition72Graduate in reply to Designbod

I couldnโ€™t stretch to the 235 โ˜น๏ธ. Just had notification that the one I ordered has been delivered. I canโ€™t wait to get home and have a play with it ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ˜Š. I ran yesterday evening so Iโ€™ll have to wait until Saturday to wear it for my first run ๐Ÿ‘

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to BlondeAmbition72

I think you'll love it! From what I've read, it's very motivational and addictive - you'll become a stat-junkie ๐Ÿ˜†๐Ÿƒ

I think there's a Garmin Connected board on here too. A whole new world!

Looking forward to joining you before too long. ๐Ÿ˜Š

BlondeAmbition72 profile image
BlondeAmbition72Graduate in reply to Designbod

Iโ€™m already a stat junkie! I have a spreadsheet that I use to record my runs (probably shouldnโ€™t admit to that?! ๐Ÿ˜ฑ). Currently have a Fitbit but that will soon be redundant!! ๐Ÿ˜Š๐Ÿ˜Š

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to BlondeAmbition72

I'm the same, love a stat! I'd also be putting my Fitbit out to stud ๐Ÿ˜†

BlondeAmbition72 profile image
BlondeAmbition72Graduate in reply to Designbod

๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ˜Š

Jay66UK profile image
Jay66UKGraduate

I went for the 235, in part because I believe it has a newer version of the heart rate monitor which is said to be more reliable.

There is an industry standard for chest straps and if your polar one conforms the Garmin will connect to it.

Iโ€™m going to write a brief thing about my new watch inc a comparative review of the 235 and the old version of the Apple Watch over the weekend.

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to Jay66UK

Hi Jay, that's interesting as I was toying between the two.

Do you wear a strap or find the wrist HRM adequate? Presumably there's less of the 'locking with cadence' issue?

I'm sure you'll cover it all in your review and will look forward to reading it ๐Ÿ˜Š๐Ÿ‘

Jay66UK profile image
Jay66UKGraduate in reply to Designbod

No strap. I donโ€™t know what โ€œlocking with cadenceโ€ is ๐Ÿ˜ณ

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to Jay66UK

Apparently an issue with the FR 35 is that the HR monitor would sometimes lock on to whatever your running cadence was (how many steps you take in a min).

mensrunninguk.co.uk/trainin...

Jay66UK profile image
Jay66UKGraduate in reply to Designbod

Having seen my cadence trace (a wriggly worm) and my heart rate trace (a good representation of the Himalayas), safe to say that hasnโ€™t been my experience!

Designbod profile image
DesignbodGraduate in reply to Jay66UK

๐Ÿ˜†๐Ÿ˜†๐Ÿ˜†

Rumour profile image
RumourGraduate

We both have the FR35. Not had any problems with the heart rate monitor. Seems to be accurate enough. I have heart problems and decided to ask about accuracy when I went to the hospital last week. The cardiologist said that short of a hospital grade heart monitor, these are as good as anything. I believe that too many people expect too much from technology.

If I had to recommend the FR35 I would have no hesitation. It does everything a runner wants unless you are going to try a triathlon. The step count is accurate and the Garmin app for the phone gives a wealth of information. Go on, get one. You won't regret it. Buy the toughened glass screen protectors too, very cheap and work well.

BlondeAmbition72 profile image
BlondeAmbition72Graduate in reply to Rumour

Good to hear ๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ‘๐Ÿ˜Š

Not what you're looking for?