The use of milk thistle as an alternat... - British Liver Trust

British Liver Trust

38,206 members18,736 posts

The use of milk thistle as an alternative medicine to heal the liver when I've been diagnosed with fatty liver and mild cirrhosis.

Marcala profile image
7 Replies

I agreed with Pateo that as patients we need to be proactive in researching other venues to help us with our ailments. I have had unforgiving experiences with doctors. Once I went to an ER with severe pain on my abdominal area that wouldn't lessen with any posture. The ER doctor readily assumed that it was consequence of an STD and send me home with antibiotics. Knowing my husband I doubted it and thanks God that I had an appointment scheduled for the next day. My husband had been with me and decided to wait for my appointment. It happened that a cyst that I had on one of my ovaries had burst and necrosis had setup on the additional areas. I was operated immediately with success thanks to the fact that I didn't blindly attend to this doctor's advice. Another experience was that I had developed frequent urination of up to 12 times a day. I went and consulted with an Urologist ( who know more about males' system than females) fearing bladder cancer? He didn't found anything like it but failed to look for the cause and it was up to me to seek the answer and find that I developed diabetes type II and there are other experiences that if it wasn't for me to search for answers, I would be in another situation health wise.

Written by
Marcala profile image
Marcala
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
7 Replies
LAJ123 profile image
LAJ123

Hello,

Sorry you have little faith in the medical world.

I can understand that you want to manage your illness in your own way, but there are dangers involved in seeking alternatives to mainstream medicine.

The prescriptions that we are given by our doctors have to meet standards of safety and effectiveness that many 'alternative' remedies don't have to aspire to.

The British Liver Trust have stated on their website:

"Milk-thistle (also known as Silybum marianum) is an over-the-counter supplement, which some people believe can be beneficial to people with liver disease. Some laboratory studies have shown the herbs active components (silymarin) have a positive effect on liver cells38. However, milk-thistle is not licensed as a medicine and so studies into its effectiveness in the body have been limited, with conflicting results. There is not currently enough evidence to prove or disprove any beneficial effects on the liver. Milk-thistle may lower blood sugar levels and people with diabetes or hypoglycaemia (low blood sugar) should use caution40,41. If you are thinking of using milk-thistle, it is a good idea to discuss this with your doctor."

With this in mind, I would be very cautious about treating your own illness and seek advice from your own GP who may know more about you and your situation than anybody in the emergency department of a hospital.

Take care and let us know how you get on.

Jim

britishlivertrust.org.uk/li...

in reply toLAJ123

I have Nash liver disease and was told by Professor O'Grady at Kings never to take milk thistle .He said they have people on their books that have liver damage because of this herb.

in reply to

That's strange because when I had cirrhosis, one of the consultants at King's said milk thistle is safe. There's no evidence it's going to help but it won't harm you either. These were her words.

I have been taking Milk Thistle but I found it very harsh indeed after a few weeks. Dropped to half dose and then half of that but still scouring me out.

I will try it again once I have finished my Hepatitis treatment But I’ll not recommend it till I see if it still has the same effect

AyrshireK profile image
AyrshireK in reply to

As werzal above says, consultants don't recommend the use of milk thistle at all as in some cases it can actually prove damaging to the liver. It can certainly alter LFT results leading to issues with conventional medical care, diagnosis etc.

LAJ123 profile image
LAJ123

Further to all of the above.

Because of the lack of regulation of the alternative health market, how do you even know it is milk thistle you are taking ? It could be anything and there are a lot of fakes out there. They even manage to produce pretty real looking prescription medications for sale on the internet.

Jim

moonbeam4 profile image
moonbeam4

ive been living with hep c for about 20 years i dont drink at all now and ive been on milk thistle for about four years and my consultant agrees that it has helped to keep my blood results low i only take one a day but it it definitely helping x

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

following a scan was diagnosed with fatty liver disease, with cysts on liver and kidney, been lifelong T Total, but am grossly overweight.

a complete shock to me, was having episodes of really severe chest pain so went to Drs. thinking it...
katyjane75 profile image

Help!

Me again with yet another question. My husband was being referred by a gastro consultant to see...
Bs1524 profile image

Diagnosed with Cirrhosis of the Liver

I was diagnosed yesterday with Cirrhosis of the Liver, this came as shock to me. What can I expect...
Mick1414 profile image

52 years old, diagnosed with cirrhosis of the liver following an internal haemorrhage and transfusion.

Hi all, I am 52 married 2 children and would describe myself as a 20-25 units a week drinker. Due...

Lesion of the liver!!! I’m worried about this has anyone had lesion of the liver ?

Hello Everyone. I’m new to all of this so please bare with me. I went to the ER because I was...
SBell7 profile image

Moderation team

See all

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.