Good news or bad news ?: I have had... - British Heart Fou...

British Heart Foundation

51,553 members32,505 posts

Good news or bad news ?

Mgs333 profile image
12 Replies

I have had nightime ectopic heart beats for over 5 years now and have had a real torrid time... I only seem to get them when I am in bed and trying to go to sleep...during the day I get nothing.

To be fair to my consultant(s) they have given me every test and investigation possible including many ecg's, halter monitors, angiograms and calcium scoring, but still nothing changes......however just this week I saw my fourth consultant who is from a private hospital but contracted to the NHS who has told me that they have come to the end of the line with investigations and basically they can do no more...he has concluded that my heart is in good strong condition with no problems and that my recent echo scan was better than average.....so my heart is fine!

But, he went on to say that the ectopics/palpitations seem to be a sympton rather than the cause and the problem may well be something else that will need investigating by another department.

Hey ho....all good fun !!

Written by
Mgs333 profile image
Mgs333
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
12 Replies
theonethatgotaway1 profile image
theonethatgotaway1

Well that sounds like good news regarding your heart. It may well be the mind itself triggering them when it's quiet on a night. I know myself that I can trigger them by focusing on my pulse and when I'm worrying about my heart as I have heart failure.

soppysokes profile image
soppysokes

Thyroid issue definitely can cause ectopic beats has it been fully checked

Qualipop profile image
Qualipop

It took over a year to find my palpitations and decide they were harmless. Yours could be caused by something like thyroid.

Samazeuilh2 profile image
Samazeuilh2

Last week I had a phone consultation with a cardiologist who advised having an MRI and a Holter test for 24 hours as I complained of frequent ectopics. If the frequency is over 10-15% then they might do an ablation as very frequent ectopics can lead to heart failure. The cause of my ectopics could be scarring of the heart caused by a bypass procedure 9 months ago, or idiopathic. I have noticed that if I lie on my left side I get ectopics but on turning to my right side they stop. Sometimes I get them following exercise. I don’t think their frequency is 10-15%, more like 5% but I cannot be sure.

You could request an MRI, although they might not go along with this. Sometimes magnesium taurate or citrate is recommended and might improve things. I’d be interested to know how many ectopics you get per minute on average. Also, do you get them during the daytime too?

Blackwolf_7619 profile image
Blackwolf_7619 in reply to Samazeuilh2

I have ventricular bigeminy. It is very severe. I have it in in episodes. For example, my last episode lasted for 8 weeks. I also have the all day every day. My cardiologist said it will start to weeken the heart after around 6 months without a break.

MikeThePike profile image
MikeThePike in reply to Blackwolf_7619

Then perhaps you should consider having an ablation. Why wait until your heart is irreparably damaged? I would ask to see an electrophysiologist and find out which part of your heart the ectopic beats are coming from and how many you are having everyday. The location and frequency largely determines the potential success of an ablation.

Mgs333 profile image
Mgs333 in reply to MikeThePike

Thanks...Yep I thought that that would be an option but my cardiologist is insisting that my heart is fine and that the ectopic beats are a symptom and not a the cause...I had a full echo cardiogram about a month ago that showed that my heart is working perfectly with no issues.....so the mystery continues....

Blackwolf_7619 profile image
Blackwolf_7619 in reply to MikeThePike

I have actually asked for ablation, but the liklihood of anything being granted by a cardiologist who, despite all the evidence proving it, won't admit to there being a problem. He just passes everything off. I wonder if I would have the same doctor issues if I were male. Just a thought.

MikeThePike profile image
MikeThePike in reply to Blackwolf_7619

I think perhaps you need to shout a bit louder and get a second opinion.

Blackwolf_7619 profile image
Blackwolf_7619 in reply to MikeThePike

I have thought about a second opinion, but on reality, they all just agree with each other anyway. I am considering a different trust though.

Engineer46 profile image
Engineer46

The best advice is to lie on your right side rather than your left when going to sleep.

Best wishes,

Paul

MikeThePike profile image
MikeThePike

If these ectopic beats are seriously affecting you're happiness or quality of life then perhaps you should consider having an ablation.

You may also like...

Update on the bad news

with my heart etc so once again I will put my faith in the NHS . Her parting words were have a...

Bad news

news that I have bowel cancer. It was picked up through the routine testing another thing I have to...

new meds. Are they good news?

say what they are like? I don’t have horrendous symptoms of heart failure , I’m just tired. He said

Statins - More Good News

infection can cross to the heart particularly where valve surgery is involved. So it seems even a...

Good news and good news