Boris Johnson’s ‘moonshot’ mass testi... - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

56,325 members66,956 posts

Boris Johnson’s ‘moonshot’ mass testing plan is not the way out of the coronavirus pandemic

2greys profile image
11 Replies

UK Prime Minister Boris Johnson has announced an ambitious “moonshot” plan to roll out mass population testing for COVID-19. Johnson said that, under the plan, the UK would process millions of tests a day, allowing those who test negative to resume their normal lives. The programme will cost around £100 billion, equivalent to two-thirds of the annual budget of the National Health Service.

Will it work? Unfortunately, mass population testing is a flawed idea in search of science to back it up. It is unlikely to be the solution that sees us out of this pandemic.

theconversation.com/boris-j...

Written by
2greys profile image
2greys
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
Superzob profile image
Superzob

Excellent, thought-provoking article

soul-123 profile image
soul-123

Scary stuff have really bad feelings about what will happen next !

O2Trees profile image
O2Trees

Think I smell Dominic Cummings at work here?

SquirrelsHolt profile image
SquirrelsHolt in reply toO2Trees

🐷 A pig of a politician and as sly as a 🦊 fox, as prickly as a 🦔 hedgehog and as creepy as a 🐜 soldier ant, as thick skinned as a 🐮 Rhino or an 🐘 elephant!!!(couldn't find a Cheetar or a Leopard sadly). I think you get my drift. Mr. Cummings is one of my top 100 blaggers so no real surprises for my outburst! Apologies to you O2Trees. Hope you are keeping yourself sway from any virus hot spots and are doing well? 🐿🌈

O2Trees profile image
O2Trees in reply toSquirrelsHolt

Im good Squirrel, hope you are too. You realise we arent allowed by the powers that be to be 'political' ?! But no apologies needed for me, Im sure you know i agree with every word. x

SquirrelsHolt profile image
SquirrelsHolt in reply toO2Trees

Oooops!! A bit of a "faux par" by me. Sorry everybody and sorry to HU. I'm guilty of typing before thinking !🐿🌈x

O2Trees profile image
O2Trees in reply toSquirrelsHolt

I think they dont respond as much to individual comments, more to actual posts. Im sure you're ok and very many will agree with you! I liked it anyway x

Badbessie profile image
Badbessie

The main problems are both money and the test. 1% of tests give a false positive. That means 60,000 people a week are going to need to be isolated plus their contacts. It would be reasonable to think that they have been in contact with 5 people so that is 300,000 people a week in isolation. So it takes 3 to 5 days to become infected so even if the people are tested on Monday and you on Wednesday the Monday people would still need to isolate because they could be still infected as the virus could still be there even if they were negetive. So I tested negative on Tuesday my daughter tested positive at the same time due to a false positive. Do I isolate? Because I could still be positive but not in amount in the blood to show up on the test. Of course then there are the people you continue the shed dead cells after having the virus who can remain positive due to that. Any bets it would be mass confusion?

we need less in the way of hyperbole.

Mavary profile image
Mavary

My thoughts are if you’ve only just been in contact with someone and you are going to get the virus it probably won’t show up in a test. Meaning you are out and about still spreading the virus.

Lfcpremier profile image
Lfcpremier

It is indisputable that to beat the virus we need to have a viable Test, track & trace.

We were promised a 'world beating one' but instead it is a shambles so therefore we must conclude we will not get the better of covid.

Sad to say any talk of a moonshine test is utter nonsense, a distraction from the current debacle.

Although the virus is on the rise again all over Europe if we look at Germany we see a system in place that has a good degree of control. Rates there are rising far more slowly. 😧

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Government’s plan recklessly exposes millions in the UK to infection when they could be vaccinated

In allowing mass infection, Boris Johnson’s government is pursuing a strategy that will lead to...
2greys profile image

Experts slam UK over 'murderous' end to Covid curbs.

The UK government's plan to scrap day-to-day pandemic restrictions in England next week has no...
2greys profile image

Operation Moonshot proposals are scientifically unsound, experts argue.

The idea of Moonshot is to frequently use new point-of-care tests across the whole population to...
2greys profile image

PM: Cafes, pubs and bars to close.

Mr Johnson says the government is strengening the measures announced earlier this week. "We are...
2greys profile image

Less than half UK population to receive vaccine, says task force head.

Less than half the UK population can expect to be vaccinated against coronavirus, the head of...
2greys profile image

Moderation team

See all
AsthmaandLung profile image
AsthmaandLungAdministrator
moderator_AandLUK profile image
moderator_AandLUKAdministrator
Claire_ALUK profile image
Claire_ALUKAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.