Surery for bronchiectasis: Hi folks. I... - Lung Conditions C...

Lung Conditions Community Forum

56,244 members66,867 posts

Surery for bronchiectasis

falconcottage1 profile image
6 Replies

Hi folks. I have bronchiectasis which is stil mild but am always looking for research. Every time I look at surgical interventions I hear positive result. It used to be that lobectomies were only for people with unilateral bronchiectasis. I get the Bronchiectasis weekly news nad this week the operation for those with bilateral bronchiectasis was discussed as beneficial for some, I don't really know how this wil work I think it must depend on the amount of lung affected. Anyway have a lok and see what u think.

healthunlocked.com/api/redi...

Written by
falconcottage1 profile image
falconcottage1
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
6 Replies
falconcottage1 profile image
falconcottage1

Sorry about spelling I'm blaming the computer

cofdrop-UK profile image
cofdrop-UK

bronchiectasisnewstoday.com...

cx

cofdrop-UK profile image
cofdrop-UK

Actually it used to be, especiallhy in the 60s, not unusual for people with diffuse bronchiectasis to undergo a lobectomy, as I and others on here can testify from experience. It hasn't been the norm for many years and I too was surprised when I received the Bronchiectasis News this week falconcottage. Of course a lobectomy was a much bigger deal in those days, being open surgery and long periods spent in hospital both before and after surgery. Much better nowadays with keyhole surgery. Thing is we really can't say if we would have been better, worse or pretty much the same if we had not had surgery.

cx

What's your FEV/FVC? If it's still mild I certainly wouldn't be going down the surgical route as it seems a bit extreme

Billiejean_2 profile image
Billiejean_2

Interesting post FC.

About 20 years ago I was turned down for surgery as the Bronchiectasis was too diffuse. My left lung had always been the worst one and Is now completely covered by fibrosis. I can't hello wondering if a left lobectomy performed at that point would have made a difference to the level of infections and hospital stays, that have characterised these years for me.

rduffy profile image
rduffy

I've always been curious about this too. My grandmother had bronchiectasis and she had both lower lobes removed back in 1956. She lived to be 87 and died of liver cancer so I guess you'd call that a positive outcome. I remember she had a phlegmy cough her entire life, even after the surgery. But I don't remember her getting sick all the time, like a lot of bronchiectasis patients do.

I was diagnosed with it in 1972, when I was 17. (Keeping it in the family, I guess.) I remember at that time the surgeon who did my bronchoscopy suggested surgical resection as an option, but my parents turned it down. At the time they told me it was because the doctors couldn't guarantee it wouldn't just come back. I've been getting by just fine all my life up until the last couple of years. Now my lung function is down to the point where they're talking transplant in the next couple of years. I don't think a lobectomy back in the 70's would have really helped all that much. But then I was lucky, like my grandmother I never got sick all the time. Just had to cough up a lot of phlegm. As health problems go, that was pretty easy to live with. If I had been getting constant pneumonias, maybe it would have made sense to remove the affected parts of my lungs.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

For folks with Bronchiectasis - EMBARC

https://www.bronchiectasis.eu/registry If you have non cf bronchiectasis and are interested in...
cofdrop-UK profile image

Bronchiectasis

Hi does anyone out there know a good Bronchiectasis Consultant in Northern Ireland? The...
maisie15 profile image

Bronchiectasis Diagnosis?

I have just posted this to asthma UK so apologies for anyone reading it twice! Hi everyone! I hope...
BP135 profile image

Bronchiectasis

Hi, I'm fairly new to Bronchiectasis(Bilateral)and would be grateful for any tips to help manage...
Aitchic1 profile image

Bronchiectasis

Hi everyone, I've just been reading through posts and replies about bronchiectasis. I was diagnosed...
Ca3489 profile image

Moderation team

See all
moderator_AandLUK profile image
moderator_AandLUKAdministrator
AsthmaandLung profile image
AsthmaandLungAdministrator
Claire_ALUK profile image
Claire_ALUKAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.