How can asthma breathlessness be diag... - Asthma Community ...

Asthma Community Forum

22,429 members24,828 posts

How can asthma breathlessness be diagnosed? Is there any way to get doctors to diagnose breathlessness to prove its asthma related?

My_fairy profile image
23 Replies

I need help as my daughter suffers with severe breathlessness and also had breathlessness attacks which are asthma attacks. I need advice from anyone how

to prove this to the medical team that this is asthma and very serious as you can’t take inhaler when you are having that severe breathlessness attack and could be deadly.

Written by
My_fairy profile image
My_fairy
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
23 Replies
Homely2 profile image
Homely2Administrator

It has been diagnosed that my breathlessness is asthma related four times.

1. The first time they thought it was cardiac related, so they did all the cardiac tests, and on the basis that it was not cardiac, diagnosed asthma. This still confuses me, to get an asthma diagnosis, with a letter prescribing an inhaler, from a cardiac consultant.

2. I was then referred to an asthma nurse, who then diagnosed asthma, on the basis that she could show the inhalers substantially improved my peak flow. This was during covid when my hospital lung department was all but closed.

3. The third time, was at a specialist unit, who said my feno test reading proved it was asthma.

4. The fourth time my new consultant diagnosed it, on the basis of a medical history.

So in practice each medic seems to take their own approach.

I am now diagnosed with severe asthma with poor control, without ever having what I would call a definitive test.

Personally I want them to do the spirometry pre and post taking inhalers which to me is the way to prove asthma.

I have had spirometry twice, once was clear, once was bad for lung capacity, so they are now doing more spirometry but with no indication of what precisely for.

On taking inhalers when having a severe attack, get the biggest spacer you can. I find them much better when it is nasty.

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toHomely2

Thanks for detailed reply

Bingo88 profile image
Bingo88

Good morning My_fairy. I was diagnosed as having Asthma markers from a blood test. So not sure if your Daughter has had this done and should then be on the inhaler to help her more. Hope you get things sorted out. Brian

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toBingo88

thanks Brian yes she did have bloods and I believe it shows asthma markers therefore she’s eligible for biological treatment .. do u mean IGE level I am not too gods with terminology but I think it’s these markers

Bingo88 profile image
Bingo88 in reply toMy_fairy

Not sure sorry I was just told there was signs of Asthma in the blood markers from the test. I was 65 at the time and never had Asthma problems

Gareth57 profile image
Gareth57

I was diagnosed using the ventolin reversibility test, so take a best of 3 peak flow, then take a dose of ventolin, wait 15-20 mins and redo the peak flow. Asthmatics should have a 20% (I think, it was a long time ago) improvement in the peak flow. You could check this with the asthma uk nurses.

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toGareth57

yes she’s diagnosed asthmatic after attack it’s even more than 50% reversibility

Gareth57 profile image
Gareth57 in reply toMy_fairy

I would have thought that would be quite conclusive!

Lysistrata profile image
LysistrataAdministratorCommunity Ambassador in reply toGareth57

It's 12-15% from baseline or more (different guidelines have different cutoffs though I think 12% is more often used). My_fairy it sounds like your daughter is well over this so I have no idea why they keep questioning it!

But from experience I find we have to prove we still have asthma frequently, but if one person decides one time it's something like dysfunctional breathing then it sticks forever.

Gareth57 profile image
Gareth57 in reply toLysistrata

thanks, it's about 20 years since that test so not surprised I was a bit out, plus I didn't really believe the diagnosis at the time having been asthma free for about 30 years and it feeling very different. My GP at the time referred to me as the reluctant asthmatic 😂

Lysistrata profile image
LysistrataAdministratorCommunity Ambassador in reply toGareth57

Ha I get you, I was convinced I'd grown out of mine by uni so had no inhaler. Looking back, I definitely had some episodes at uni and was lucky to get away unscathed with my complete ignorance! Then when it did come back after swine flu I kept being told it wasn't asthma (it was).

PaulRosedene profile image
PaulRosedene

I had a lung function test. This shows at what percentage of capacity the lungs are operating. If the lung function improves after taking ventolin, this is shown as evidence of asthma.

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toPaulRosedene

yes it improves all the time

Mandevilla profile image
Mandevilla

What are they diagnosing her with at the moment? Have they suggested any alternatives?

Unfortunately, you do often have to keep pushing for a diagnosis - I was brushed off as suffering from 'Covid related anxiety' for two years before someone finally thought to check the difference in my peak flow before and after Ventolin! Keep going back until you get some answers. You might also find it helpful to call the Asthma Uk helpline for advice - they were great at giving me helpful phrases and questions to use in my discussions with my GP surgery - sometimes, it's not so much what you say as how you say it that gets results!

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toMandevilla

thanks for your reply it is definitely helpful.. I will do

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toMandevilla

they keep going back to dysfunctional breathing to prove their diagnosis when all of her symptoms are asthma related

runcyclexcski profile image
runcyclexcski in reply toMy_fairy

Can you ask for a referral to another consultant? They can differ even within the same hospital (my experience). Or, you can see a private consultant with a double affiliation who then can help you get back in onto the NHS.

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toruncyclexcski

yes this is what happened they differed within the same hospital .. I wasn’t happy with diagnosis as difficult asthma so we saw another consultant when biologic helped her. He said severe asthma in his letter but as soon as biologic failed he is trying to change it to asthma and dysfunctional breathing as there’s been a lot of negligence in her case from secondary and due to their errors tertiary didn’t make right decisions aswell when she was assessed ….her case has been messed up and now they want to prove themselves right by writing misleading letters and hiding important information on letters i.e. lung function/feno.

They are trying to force us to accept the diagnosis ..now the issue is he’s top most consultant here working for NHS and privately I believe noone will challenge him or even take on her case due to complex nature but he’s not saying the truth anymore… her condition is very bad she’s taking daily reliever symbicort and still has bronchospasm frequently and they have offered another biologic but we don’t know if it will work or again be a secondary failure like before then what options we are left with… it’s a very tough situation and I know they are being dishonest knowingly as I pointed out their mistake of giving her steroid injection when she’s therapy severe resistant asthma… they keep going back to dysfunctional breathing when it was first diagnosed in a life threatening asthma attack

Patk1 profile image
Patk1 in reply toMy_fairy

Have they offered help for dysfunctional breathing? There are trained respiratory/ speech + language therapists who may help yr daughter x

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toPatk1

yes she doesn’t require these and she’s perfectly fine doesn’t have any of these issues but misleading her case … she only requires inhaler because of recurrent symptoms and they know it … but her case has been neglected due to misdiagnosis and complexity

runcyclexcski profile image
runcyclexcski

Variability of the spirometry test from day to day (while off steroids) and the improvement of the test in response to ventolin did it for me. I understand that taking the inhaler can cause airway constriction, but in the hospital they can manage that. They can also test for elevated IgE and elevated eosinophiles.Improvement of symptoms in response to oral steroids. There are also the metacholine test and the exercise challenge.

My_fairy profile image
My_fairy in reply toruncyclexcski

thanks.. never had metacholine but exercise challenge was done

runcyclexcski profile image
runcyclexcski in reply toMy_fairy

They say metacholine can be quite uncomfortable.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Mannitol challenge

Hi, hope you are all well. 😊 Bit of a long story sorry…. I’ve recently seen a new consultant,...
Celie1 profile image

can steroid's...damage you bladder sensation?

Hi my names katie, i am a severe asthmatic, i have a number of allergys and have taken 6 asthma...

Does Your asthma every get you down and depressed?

Hiya everyone..x Was just wandering if anyone else feels down and depressed about there asthma!...

Swollen throat

Hi all. As always, looking for a bit of advice please. I suffer with Severe Allergic Asthma which...
MrsCMK profile image

Return of symptoms on reduction of Pred

Hi I have had a week in hospital and two weeks back home now. Before hospital I had been on 40mg...
Debd profile image

Moderation team

See all
Homely2 profile image
Homely2Administrator
Lysistrata profile image
LysistrataAdministrator
ALUK_Nurses profile image
ALUK_NursesAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.