Another experience proving we are all... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

31,322 members36,990 posts

Another experience proving we are all different

Peacefulneedshelp profile image

I had mentioned in a couple of my answers to posts in the group that I had been episode free for over a year, and suddenly I had two back to back episodes of AF. i didn’t remember doing anything different and in fact did not have any alcohol that day or for several days so not drinking anything can’t be the culprit.

I had been listening to a podcast where they kept talking about how important fish oils are in our diet and I temporarily forgot that whenever I take a fish oil supplement it doesn’t agree with me.

I have tried a newer fish oil supplement made from sea weed oil which is supposed to be better and less contaminated and yadda yadda.

I took 1 capsule which actually forgot about and it was later that day I had a AF episode and 1 the next day as well, in my sleep which finally cleared up after about 8 hours.

Two days after that after much thought I remembered I had taken the fish supplement.

I did a research and found an article at Cleveland Clinic and a study regarding oils. Three groups, fish oil, corn oil, and mineral oil. Turns out worst outcomes for these oils and fish oil did nothing for people with AF. Bottom line: people with AF stay away from fish oil.

Experiment with your diet and supplements and muscle test if you know how.

Written by
Peacefulneedshelp profile image
Peacefulneedshelp
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
21 Replies
jeanjeannie50 profile image
jeanjeannie50

I have always known not to take fish oil supplements because I have AF. Can't remember why now but then I've had AF for 19 years.

Good that you have brought this subject up to remind members.

Jean

Peacefulneedshelp profile image
Peacefulneedshelp in reply to jeanjeannie50

I have known also but we forget, thank you for validating the issue.

JudiHalf profile image
JudiHalf

I take a fish oil capsule daily it has no effect on my AF whatsoever, different things affect different people, so you have to learn your own personal triggers.

Peony4575 profile image
Peony4575 in reply to JudiHalf

Me too . Taken it for decades . What I find disagrees with my body is stopping and starting things, I always buy my supplements from the same supplier . Keep everything as level and steady as possible, not too much of anything. Don’t poke the beast with a stick

Shopgal67 profile image
Shopgal67

I’ve been taking a good quality omega 3 for years with high amounts of EPA & DHA I thought they were benifcial for heart health, fighting inflammation and brain support !!

I think I’ll ask for clarification from my nutritionist .

Peacefulneedshelp profile image
Peacefulneedshelp in reply to Shopgal67

I always say do your homework. We are all different and thinks affect us differently. the supplements I take are good quality I would have to say better than good quality. I have no problem with eating Salmon, in fact had some last night. Again it speaks to how we are all different.

Glenlyon profile image
Glenlyon

I’m the same - fish oil worked wonders for joint pain years back - I tried it a couple of times since start of heart stuff - first time I was naive - second time I simple forgot what that earlier experience had taught me ….still here & 🤞🏻I’ve learnt the lesson (glad of the reminder though)

BrotherThomas profile image
BrotherThomas

I too have taken cod liver oil capsules for many years without any effect on my AF. Just goes to show how different we all are.

bassets profile image
bassets

Thank you - something to remember.

Ppiman profile image
Ppiman

I have always understood that fish is one of the most healthy of foods, but I always shy away from artificial "nutraceuticals" since there can be no way our bodies have evolved for them to be healthy. If they work, they work as a ny other drug works, rather than as anything "natural". The worry with them is that they are generally untested and cannot be standardised since the active ingredient is often unknown.

Steve

Morges profile image
Morges

Flaxseed is rich in ALA, a type of omega-3 fatty acid that may offer numerous benefits for heart health.

Abbyroza profile image
Abbyroza

There are many scientific papers warning for the link between Omega3 supplements and Afib. Here are two of them:

ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articl...

escardio.org/The-ESC/Press-...

Peacefulneedshelp profile image
Peacefulneedshelp in reply to Abbyroza

both interesting articles. In my case I don't think my triglycerides are elevated so there is that. If they are it is only slightly.

ainslie profile image
ainslie

any chance you could post the study by Cleveland please, I thought fish oil was meant to be good for us🤔

Peacefulneedshelp profile image
Peacefulneedshelp in reply to ainslie

I found the article and test case. my.clevelandclinic.org/podc.... here you go!

ainslie profile image
ainslie in reply to Peacefulneedshelp

Thankyou 👍

Blearyeyed profile image
Blearyeyed

It's another one of those funny ones isn't it.Omega 3 supplements can increase the risk of developing or triggering aFib in many sufferers but oily fish in the diet can be beneficial. Just 1g of Omega 3 , or a supplement each day caused an increased aFib risk in tests.

Much like when talking about using Turmeric or CoQ10 on medications for blood thinning or anticlotting.

Avoid the supplements but you can choose your timing and have them in your diet.

Calypso76 profile image
Calypso76

Are you taking fish oil along with a blood thinner for your AF?

Peacefulneedshelp profile image
Peacefulneedshelp in reply to Calypso76

No I am not taking either as my AF is so sporadic that only aspirin has been recommended for now.

Calypso76 profile image
Calypso76

From what you mentioned, I'm wondering if eating fish regularly and I mean like everyday would have the same effect as using omega 3 supplements.

Peacefulneedshelp profile image
Peacefulneedshelp in reply to Calypso76

That is questionable but as I mentioned I hadn’t taken any fish oil for over a year. As I said it’s a mystery. It also could be that a fish oil supplement doesn’t really contain all the constituents that eating a piece of salmon or other oils fish would. I can eat fish with no problem but 1 fish oil capsule creates AFib in a few hours and another episode the next day. Go figure.

You may also like...

WE are all different!

this and if he was not better next day to go back and see him. Next day he was still bad so went....

Are we all shielding?

ring a week later to check that had happened, which I did. Five days later I received a letter...

An Experiment! Update

month I have only had a few minutes of palpitations every few days and no episodes of AF. Despite...

All very different.

I had a Cryoablation September 2019. 8 weeks ago tomorrow I had an RF ablation. Didn’t know I was...

Update thinners intolerance- Warfarin headed experiences please..

fruit and veg, always had salad on fridge. Non red meat 30+, diet= 1/3 chicken 1/3 fish 1/3...