Good news for red wine drinkers! - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,304 members38,577 posts

Good news for red wine drinkers!

MarkS profile image
17 Replies

It appears as though moderate red wine drinking actually protects against AF:

medscape.com/viewarticle/95...

In this UK study of 400,000 adults, consumption of 1 to 7 glasses of red wine a week reduced the incidence of AF by 6%. White wine also had a similar though lower effect and beer and cider increased risk at any level. Interestingly, the risk of AF never increased at any level of red wine drinking compared with non-drinkers.

Written by
MarkS profile image
MarkS
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
17 Replies

G'day Mark

That's what I ( and the wine industry) like to see ..... nice positive news .... in moderation. Always brings back memories of 'Lil 'ole wine drinker me ... Dean Martin. Although I believe he did give the booze quite a caning along with other members of the 'Rat Pack'.

😂😂😂

I always knew I was doing something right with my diet.

John

😇😇

MarkS profile image
MarkS in reply to

Nothing beats a good Ossie Shiraz for me! 😋

fairgo45 profile image
fairgo45 in reply toMarkS

Ossie Shiraz ? It's better across the Tasmin and I should know I live there

Desanthony profile image
Desanthony

I knew there was a reason I favoured red wine. Though I do know someone whose AF is triggered by wine but not beer - maybe it's to do with something else in the wine. Thankfully I know my AF isn't triggered by wine and I barely drink a full glass a day and it is usually red wine. Good to hear I must be doing something right.

Singwell profile image
Singwell

Hmm. After my near miss with Pimm's yesterday I won't be trying this out just yet! 😉. But I shall read it as I'd been thinking IF I drink again it would be local artisan cider...

HelenClare profile image
HelenClare

Really good article. Thank you for bringing to our attention. A good start to Monday morning!

Singwell profile image
Singwell

OK I'm going to be the party pooper here. Admittedly the link is only a summary, not the paper itself. But the conclusion isn't quite as you implied:". A large cohort study saw a familiar J-shaped curve detailing risk for new atrial fibrillation (AF) in which the risk rose steadily with greater number of drinks per week, except at the lowest levels of alcohol intake.

There, the curve turned the other way. Light drinkers overall showed no higher AF risk than nondrinkers, and the risk was lowest at any degree of alcohol intake up to 56 g per week." I really don't think we can conclude from this that if you already have AF it's safe to drink red wine. Obviously I'd need to read the full study to say more - in particular how they assessed 'risk of AF' and how that was compared in those with AF - if it all. And I accept my that it's a very individual thing: some can drink, some cannot. Far be it from me to kill a simple pleasure. But the paper isn't a green light for all of us to our red bottles...😔. Only you lucky few. Have one for me please - a well aged rioja!

Morzine profile image
Morzine

Guess it is a mixed bag of views though with this as clearly some folk are badly affected by any alcohol. I can have two reds if I am out but I’m wary of full bodied high percent ones. I drink a lot of water too..... God I’d love a full bodied Rjoja!.....those days are gone......

Auriculaire profile image
Auriculaire in reply toMorzine

I have found that more and more French wines have higher alcohol content than they used to. It is rare to look at the label and find less than 12.5 % these days and often they are 13.5%. Maybe this is to do with hotter summers. Except this one! 😭

Morzine profile image
Morzine in reply toAuriculaire

Yes you’re dead right, 13, 13.5 and 14......it’s hard to find a twelve or twelve point five.....we must look funny in our Carrefour turning the bottles around looking at labels, think yes it’s the hot summers.......this summer aaaargh......

Auriculaire profile image
Auriculaire in reply toMorzine

I'm blaming next door. They come down from Paris in summer and this year they bought a swimming pool. I was chatting to Helena this morning and she said she was so fed up with the heat the last two years she had to have water - she is Brazilian and is out in her tiny bikini most of the day when it's sunny. The kids have ventured in so far a couple of times . It is gradually coming hotter but quite humid cos of all the rain we have had.

Mugsy15 profile image
Mugsy15

Sorry but this is misleading at best - the risk of 'new' AF may not be affected by drinking red wine, but this forum is populated largely by those who already have the condition, and for them the risk of triggering AF by drinking red wine is very real. Many suspect that the presence of sulphates is the culprit, but in the book 'How I Cured My Afib', one of the listed triggers is Tyramine - which is present in red wine.

Personally I can say red wine very definitely IS a trigger, and it is not the alcohol content as beer is not a trigger in my case - so for me and many others this article is potentially dangerous.

in reply toMugsy15

Right, so that gives that article a real caning and pounding to bits, objective and subjective comments et al ..... so now who is gonna do one on tea, coffee, decaffeinated tea, decaffeinated coffee, soft drinks .... and don't forget to be subjective 😂😂😂 ..... it is what it is for all of us .....horses for courses ... we are all affected by different things, food, drinks, fruit, sugar, salt - even medications.Why not just accept the article as a general interest item. On a world wide basis it will have relevance to many people.

Mugsy15 profile image
Mugsy15 in reply to

Because it is posted on a forum for sufferers of Atrial Fibrillation, many of whom would suffer an attack as a result of drinking red wine in the belief that this article gives them a green light to do so. That's why.

CDreamer profile image
CDreamer

And yet:-

medscape.org/viewarticle/95...

How selective we can be when it suits our tastes and opinion. Just saying.

Champagne or a really good Sparkling white wine is the only wine I can tolerate these days - better get your wallets out if you are having me around! It’s the tannin in red wine which upsets me, black tea is the same. But I’m all for having a bit of what you fancy and makes you feel good.

Morzine profile image
Morzine in reply toCDreamer

Ha ha yes seems to me it’s a funny affair eh!

beach_bum profile image
beach_bum

I really wonder sometimes....there must be SO much grant money out there these days. Just who conjures up these studies? Cash strapped biomed PhD candidates is my guess. Next up? "The effects of cranberries on teens with Epstein Barr" 😋

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Red Wine

After being diagnosed with AF 3 years ago I soon gave up caffeine in tea and coffee as well as...
geacie1274 profile image

AF with Red wine

I have AF, this used to be controlled with Flecanide 200mg per day but this month I have had 4...
Zacky19 profile image

No wine for women

Hello. This is Dr JoAnn Manson, professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School and Brigham and...
Ianc2 profile image

Can i have a glass of wine for the x factor final??

Hi. I haven't drank alcohol in several months now. The typical triggers of AF (caffeine, alcohol...
Vony profile image

Alcohol and Afib

I have recently been diagnosed with PAF, and am wondering what is a reasonable level of alcohol to...

Moderation team

See all
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.