Ice Bucket Challenge: Hi, I have been... - Atrial Fibrillati...

Atrial Fibrillation Support

32,306 members38,578 posts

Ice Bucket Challenge

janscrivens profile image
16 Replies

Hi, I have been nominated for the Ice Bucket Challenge. Does anyone know if it would be dangerous as I have now had 3 episodes of AF.?

Thanks, Jan

Written by
janscrivens profile image
janscrivens
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
16 Replies
jennydog profile image
jennydog

I wouldn't risk it - just make a donation!

Jason1971 profile image
Jason1971

I did it on Sunday, but I'm already two weeks into an episode. I think Jennydog is right, if you are unsure, then just make a donation. It's for a very worthwhile charity.

dedeottie profile image
dedeottie

I was wondering the same thing and have decided to play safe and make a donation.x

fallingtopieces profile image
fallingtopieces

I say don't do it! My big AF episode began with an icy drink which I believe is fairly common.

If you have AF right now though, plunging one's face into icy water is on the list of things to try doing to bring you back into NSR so it could be worth a try!

BobD profile image
BobDVolunteer

I think it is an irresponsible think like so many facebook challenges and only a fool, would be succkered into it.

You gotta be kidding! No way José. Unless you asked them to warm the water up first :-)

_

Yamil007 profile image
Yamil007

Do the warm bucket challenge :)

Loo53 profile image
Loo53

Personally I wouldn't want to do this as its just asking for it. Unless maybe do two ice buckets one to put you in AF and the other to put you back in NSR. :-D Sometimes we have to be selfish and do I what's best for ourselves. Make a donation.

davegm profile image
davegm

Don't feel obliged to do it just because you have been nominated. Think of yourself first.

Personally, I wouldn't do it whether I had AF or not, had an ablation or not etc. I think it is something thought up by self centered celebrities and social media etc - but then that the Victor Meldrew coming out in me!

I agree make a donation to the well worthwhile cause.

MammaCass profile image
MammaCass

No way Jose'. I've watched my son, his wife, other family members and their friends do it. The shock of the cold water was horrendous. I'm almost 3 months post ablation and I wouldn't risk it, the shock of iced water would be too much.

Jollies profile image
Jollies

I have been nominated, by my son, and am refusing to do it. Tend to think it is quite self seeking and social media driven. I have said also that I won't be doing it as it wouldn't be sensible with AF. Am making a donation to charity x

Japaholic profile image
Japaholic

I wont do it for the following reasons....

More than 3.4 million people die each year from water, sanitation, and hygiene-related causes. Nearly all deaths, 99 percent, occur in the developing world.

Lack of access to clean water and sanitation kills children at a rate equivalent of a jumbo jet crashing every four hours.

780 million people lack access to a clean water source; approximately one in nine people on the planet.

(Source - water.org)

So yeah, go dump a bucket of water over your head to raise money for a charity BUT think about the bigger picture. All that water from all those ice bucket challenges could save a lot of lives.

in reply toJapaholic

As a water industry journalist I'm applauding wildly. And I have already told my family not to nominate me!

Jay10 profile image
Jay10 in reply toJapaholic

Well said. We waste so much of our precious resources without thinking.

Pleased president Obama refused to do it...C

Dadog profile image
Dadog

Sensible and educated comments from everyone. I just don't get it. Donations to chosen charities are one thing. Idiotic, wasteful and potentially dangerous pranks are another. It brings the grumpy old man out in me!

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Ice Bucket Challenge

Hi, those of you who follow social media may have heard of the Ice Bucket Challenge. For those who...
Beanz1970 profile image

Bucket List

Bit of fun this weekend, thought I'd share the fit of giggles we've spread with you. It's now 4...
Ianp66 profile image

Drinking ice or submerged in ice

So one technique they told me is drink ice when u have symptoms of AFib or vagal maunuver
Wannna40 profile image

Dentist & Ice

Two questions please. I haven't been to the dentist since I was put on Rivaroxaban anticoagulant...
MT51 profile image

Stopped eating ice, snowballs, ice cream, etc.

I'm sorry I deleted my post by accident but I wanted to add a couple other things I left out. I...
kelviethedog profile image

Moderation team

See all
Emily-Admin profile image
Emily-AdminAdministrator
Kelley-Admin profile image
Kelley-AdminAdministrator
jess-admin profile image
jess-adminAdministrator

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.