Dr Scholz: Hi, My husband is currently... - Advanced Prostate...

Advanced Prostate Cancer

22,286 members27,986 posts

Dr Scholz

Blair77 profile image
12 Replies

Hi,

My husband is currently treated at UCSF, but we recently had a skye appointment with Dr. Scholz in Marina Del Ray. He suggested some different therapies and kind of treatment then has currently been suggested. Any ideas how to research which plan is better?

Written by
Blair77 profile image
Blair77
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
12 Replies
PaulC2 profile image
PaulC2

I would read all recent medical journal articles on each of the therapies suggested. (Dr. Scholz can probably provide you with some of them, particularly the ones he considers most salient.)

For those that have completed clinical trials, look at the corresponding page on clinicaltrials.gov — especially the third tab, labeled "Study Results".

Or you could mention what the therapies are in a forum like this one and ask people to help you with the research.

Neathuh1 profile image
Neathuh1

I'm pretty certain that if you consult 10 different doctors you'll get 10 different treatment recommendations and everyone has merit. Such is the state of prostate cancer today. There is no clear consensus . Go with the Doctor you have the most confidence in while keeping an eye on everything you read here or on other sites and always ask questions of your provider. Keep them on their toes. God bless.

pjoshea13 profile image
pjoshea13 in reply toNeathuh1

I'm afraid that "Invasion of the Prostate Snatchers" by Ralph H. Blum and Dr. Mark Scholz, & his blog comments, has colored my view on Scholz. His view on urologists is that it is an historical anomaly that they treat PCa - akin to barbers still pulling teeth.

Well, he's perhaps brave to say what many oncologists probably think, but I get the impression that he has never recommends surgery. Maybe I'm wrong about that; maybe he's not as closed-minded as he appears.

-Patrick

Neal-Snyder profile image
Neal-Snyder in reply topjoshea13

I had my surgery 14 years ago, so that part isn't an issue for me now. I wanted to consult with a highly respected West Coast prostate cancer expert, especially 1 who is willing to think outside the box, to add to what my Kaiser med onc says (& to my past consults with a UCSF uro onc).

Mark Scholz repeatedly came up as the doctor to see, & I have an appointment with him for April 11. If & only if we finish with my stuff & my time isn't gone (highly unlikely, I'd guess), I'll ask if he ever recommends surgery. I am curious.

Neal

efsculpt profile image
efsculpt

What recommendations? And where on the PCa "journey" is your husband at? I see Dr Turner ( Dr. Schultz's partner) end of April.

in reply toefsculpt

I'll second that notion. What stage, what gleason score? Makes a big difference if it is contained within the prostate or not.

Blair77 profile image
Blair77 in reply to

Stage is iv with bone mets, Gleason 9 age is 47. I think the prostate should be removed to try and debulk. Dr. Scholz disagreed with the idea of removing the prostate.

podsart profile image
podsart

May I ask re Skype appt: 1 what documents or forms u sent him ( fax or email)? 2 how much time were you allotted for call 3 what the cost was and any insurance taken 4 how long had

Dan59 profile image
Dan59

I for 1 would like to know what Dr Scholtz suggest. At my case having done every standard of care therapy, and on chemo now, I think Dr Scholtz knows a lot about current options in clinical trials and also it is perhaps my assumption he would be willing to think out of the box, and knows of other things to do. I am far to late for Surgery.

thanks

Dan

in reply toDan59

You know what ticks me off Dan, today they don't think twice about removing a guys prostate with lymph node involvement. They'll just take the nodes with it. And their cancer free. I say that and I don't want any backtalk from ItsB, if you get my drift. In hindsight I would have had the surgery, too many troubling side effects from ADT.

Dan59 profile image
Dan59

I wanted the surgery, if nothing else to de bulk the primary tumor where the most oldest most mutated cancer is, what is wrong with killing 3 million cancer cells in one surgery? Unfortunately I could not find anyone to do it 11 years ago. What are the bad side effects you have from adt?

in reply toDan59

It would be nice if insurance / Medicare covered HIFU. It would allow 'debulking' with much reduced risk of incontinence and impotence that often goes with surgical removal.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Experience with Dr. Mark Scholz?

I am actively looking for a replacement Med Onc since Dr. Charles "Snuffy" Myers is retiring....
vandy69 profile image

Dr Scholz' Opinion on Brachytherapy

I haven't received this treatment myself but it could be a future option for me. Dr Scholz says...

Dr. Emmanuel Antonarakis

Hi--I understand for the helpful posts that I received in search of an alternative to Dr. Snuffy...
4luvofrob profile image

Any ideas on how to find local oncologist to implement Dr Scholz' treatment plan?

I am one of Dr Snuffy Meyer's former patients (as many of you know, he's now retired) and am now a...
NCrocker profile image

Dr Charles Drake

I would like to get a second opinion from a medical oncologist in New York city. Currently seeing...

Moderation team

Bethishere profile image
BethishereAdministrator
Number6 profile image
Number6Administrator
Darryl profile image
DarrylPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.