I have been referred to Birmingham bu... - Acoustic Neuroma ...

Acoustic Neuroma Support

2,742 members927 posts

I have been referred to Birmingham but want Bristol. Can you recommend a consultant in Bristol?

Scottie1954 profile image
15 Replies

I have just discovered I have AN and have yet to see a specialist. Is there anyone you recommend? I live in Cheltenham so would prefer to go to Bristol rather then Birmingham. Does anyone have experience of either?

Written by
Scottie1954 profile image
Scottie1954
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
15 Replies
mrwhite profile image
mrwhite

I've been treated at Birmingham for the past 5 years, most recently with Cyberknife.

Bristol has a good team but Birmingham has in my opinion an even better one, with more treatment options available and latest technology. No harm in having a second referal to Bristol after and see which you prefer but go with best option not location

Junedoreen profile image
Junedoreen in reply tomrwhite

mrwhite I have just been recommended for Cyberknife. I had surgery last August for a large AN but need further treatment to finish it off! Can you tell me anything about your Cyberknife? I will be having it at the QE. Thank you in advance - terrified all over again!

mrwhite profile image
mrwhite in reply toJunedoreen

Hi are you a memeberbof the bana forum ? Last year I wrote a lengthy blog with photos and a small video clip there bana-uk.com/ . if not check out this website for the Harley st clinic which gives a pretty good overview too. thecyberknifecentre.com/en-...

While it is understandable to be anxious, believe me it is nothing compared to what you have already been though with surgery. It is not without its own risks but again those of surgery are higher.

BANA is having its AGM at the end of June at the QE and the lead Cyberknife team are giving a talk and tour of the facilities so if you were to join you could attend and have a really good look around and get access to mulriple consultants q &as at once. If you need any more details, let me know and i can try reposting the blog details here if you camt access them on the bana forum.

Good luck

Junedoreen profile image
Junedoreen in reply tomrwhite

Many thanks. I am a BANA member and have been trawling the website but can't locate your blob, which I would love to read. Do you remember where on the site it is? I have been helping to organise the BANA AGM so am looking forward to the tour of the Cyberknife Unit, the Consultant said that users can tour at any time if they need to so, if I decide to go ahead, which I'm sure I will (do we really have a choice?) then I may go before as I want to get this done and start recovering as soon as I can. Do you know if those who have had surgery recover any differently to those who just have Cyberknife? e.g. my inner ear has gone so is there more room for swelling of the brain? thanks

mrwhite profile image
mrwhite in reply toJunedoreen

bana-uk.com/index.php?optio...

You should be able to direct link here

I also had a tour around so its worth while if you want to do it before then. I'm now sure how sensitive your head is but you may find the mask making a little uncomfortable but its quick and not painfull.

Recovery of Cyberknife is generally quicker, less severe and fewer complications than surgery but of course it all depends on location of it and personal health/ circumstances

Junedoreen profile image
Junedoreen in reply tomrwhite

Many, many thanks for this- what a fabulous job you have done in helping us all to make sense of it. How are you now?

The only AN consultant I know of at Frenchay Hospital in Bristol is Richard Nelson - he has a good reputation and is a very nice man although I don't have any experience of him as a Consultant - just met him when he gave a talk to the South West BANA group.

keithzx12r profile image
keithzx12r

I live in Cornwall. At the time of my surgery 26 years ago there was no surgeon in Cornwall to perform the work so I travelled to Oxford for the procedure. I was quite poorly after the op and was in Oxford for three weeks. This made it difficult for my wife, business and family. I would stick at it and try for Bristol. My post op problems would probably have not been so bad with up to date procedures. There was no gamma knife at the time either. Best wishes for a good outcome, Keith

Scottie1954 profile image
Scottie1954 in reply tokeithzx12r

Thank you. Last week I had my first appointment with the consultant in Birmingham and am now happy to continue going there.

Yorkshire-Yellow profile image
Yorkshire-Yellow

@Scottie1954. Sorry to hear you've had to join the club!

I live near Stroud and work in Cheltenham. I was referred to both Bristol (by the ENT consultant I saw at Emersons green NHS centre) and to the Birmingham (by my GP, who'd had past dealings with them).

Bristol totally messed up my initial appointments (they sent me to the wrong hospital on the wrong day and at the wrong clinic time...!!!), so I removed myself from that list and continued with Birmingham.

I initially saw Mr Walsh on the NHS in Birmingham who I found to be a top, top guy. Very easy to deal with, patient and understanding. As I;m lucky enough to have private medical cover through work with covered AN's, I went private with him at The Priory Hospital in Edgbaston and had my AN removed there in December 2012.

I've seen both him and the other surgeon involved in my treatment there several times since for standard check ups an the like, and have no complaints whatsoever.

Whilst The Priory is not directly accessible by train, the Queen Elizabeth Hospital in Birmingham is, which I have found to be very helpful for the times I've been there, particularly before my AN was removed and in the latter stages it made sudden head movements sometimes uncomfortable.

It's of course up to you, but I'd see if you can see a couple of people. After all, this is a big thing for you and you'll doubtless feel more comfortable on your 'journey' dealing with a team of people you develop a good relationship.

Scottie1954 profile image
Scottie1954 in reply toYorkshire-Yellow

I had my first appointment at Mr Monksfield's clinic on Wednesday. I was greatly impressed with both the hospital and staff. I am going back there to have another MRI with a view to having cyber knife treatment if necessary. (They had not received my initial MRI scan.) Thank u for taking the time to respond.

Linzipops profile image
Linzipops

Hi, if you choose Bristol be prepared for a long wait! I was referred last January (2013) for my AN regrowth (I had my previous surgery at Frenchay 10 years ago but with a different surgeon) and I have yet to see Mr Nelson. Im hoping he is worth the wait........

Linzi

Scottie1954 profile image
Scottie1954 in reply toLinzipops

Sorry to hear about the wait. I decided to go to Birmingham after all and had my first appointment last week. Let's hope they are as efficient with the next appointment:)

Linzipops profile image
Linzipops in reply toScottie1954

Glad to hear you've had your initial appointment! That was certainly quick.......I'm still waiting!!!! I think I may have to set up camp outside the hospital ;)

bypass profile image
bypass

Rick Nelson is excellent. His department is moving from Frenchay to Southmead in May so you may have to wait a while though. Could be worth a short wait as ANs do not usually need urgent treatment

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Just been told…I have a Brain Tumour

So Im 56 and last week I was told by my Oncologist that after an 8mth horrific battle with T4...
EllieMay7 profile image

I had a AN removal (85%) In may 2013 been referred for gamma knife. After op got hydrocephalus (fitted variable lumbar shunt) have physio

My balance is still quite poor. Feel disorientated/drunk! (After a year) this feeling is worse when...
Elkcub001 profile image

Has anyone been treated by Mr Nelson at Frenchay, Bristol? If so how long have you had to wait for an appointment from initial referral?

I had surgery 10 years ago at Frenchay by Professor Coakham! In January last year an MRI revealed...
Linzipops profile image

I have got Tinatus in my ear no other symptoms but the AccustiTumour has grown in last 2 years advised Radiation worried about side effects

The Tumour grown very little went for mask at QE Birmingham yesterday Friday 13th June 2014 I...
Waiting profile image

Moderation team

See all
Zhaleh_TBTC profile image
Zhaleh_TBTCAdministrator
Maddie_TBTC profile image
Maddie_TBTCAdministrator
Beth_TBTC profile image
Beth_TBTCPartner

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.