Scientists say mystery of how red wine headache... - Thyroid UK

Thyroid UK

137,824 members161,644 posts

Scientists say mystery of how red wine headaches occur may be solved

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK
11 Replies

Thought this could be relevant on at least two grounds:

First, so many members say they have issues tolerating alcoholic drinks, especially red wine. And it is specifically in this respect that I am posting. Not ordinary excessive drinking.

Second, there are numerous posts here which advocate taking quercetin!

This search of the forum will only find some posts:

healthunlocked.com/thyroidu...

Scientists say mystery of how red wine headaches occur may be solved

Researchers home in on phenolic flavonoids as culprit for headaches that come on soon after a glass or two

The researchers, including Prof Andrew Waterhouse, an expert in viticulture at the University of California, Davis, ran lab tests on more than a dozen compounds in red wine. One stood out. A flavanol called quercetin, found almost exclusively in red wine, is processed in the body into various substances. One of these, quercetin glucuronide, turned out to be particularly effective at blocking the enzyme that converts acetaldehyde into acetate.

theguardian.com/science/202...

I’m not coming down on either side - but it is an interesting question.

This search finds 94 papers which mention quercetin and hypothyroid. Having a good browse and tell us what you think. :-)

europepmc.org/search?query=...

Cheers

Written by
helvella profile image
helvella
Administrator
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
11 Replies
helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK

For those who can access BBC Sounds podcasts, this program discusses the red wine headache issue.

Cyber attacks, red wine headaches and Parkinson’s disease

5 Live Science Podcast

26 November 2023

Dr Chris Smith and the Naked Scientist team present the latest science news, analysis and breakthroughs,

In this week's episode... a damning indictment of our politician’s grasp of science emerges from the COVID enquiry. We’ll ask who is behind the high-profile cyber attacks on the British Library and how researchers got to the bottom of why some of us get red wine headaches. Plus we find out what it’s like to live with Parkinson’s disease and what is science revealing about why it happens and what we can do to make life more bearable.

bbc.co.uk/programmes/p0gvqkgw

CapnM profile image
CapnM

I read this and am someone who can not process alcohol since about the time of developing Hashi. My first reaction was well its only covering red wine so cant apply to me then I thought well it mainly red wine I used to drink but my hazy memory thinks I have suffered with beer and odd gin and tonic too in past. Part of me wanted to experiment but the last time I drank was a cheeky sip of my mothers wine glass. I woke up to running up and down the garden with head exploding, in a mess and dry retching and was sick for next 2 days. Then I remember I quite like not drinking any more.

I haven't had red wine for many years (it causes rhuematism in my hands) and so, recent years' reactions to 1 glass of white wine with a meal has been parallel to the decline in my thyroid function.

By the way, I understood quercetin (from a number of websites) as being contained in many sources:

"Quercetin is a plant flavonol from the flavonoid group of polyphenols. It is found in many fruits, vegetables, leaves, seeds, and grains; capers, red onions, and kale are common foods containing appreciable amounts of it.[2][3] It has a bitter flavor and is used as an ingredient in dietary supplements, beverages, and foods."

Whereas, Prof Andrew Waterhouse et al are quoted as stating" "A flavanol called quercetin, found almost exclusively in red wine...".

Am I missing something?

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to

I think the Professor meant that within wine it is almost exclusively found in red wines! Even then, I think he meant us to interpret that as being found in substantial quantities - low levels are found across many wines.

But it really needed that to be stated clearly.

Yes - it is common.

in reply to helvella

Right you are, helvella. :)

Brightness14 profile image
Brightness14

Interesting, I drink red wine a small glass once or twice a week. I have never had a headache in my life from anything I am one of those lucky people.

My daughter, however, gets a headache from one glass of red wine. She hasn't a thyroid problem and I am without one.

The headache nerve was missed when I was forming in the womb, for which I am so grateful.

I usually but the cheap red as I live in France.

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to Brightness14

Somewhere it did say cheap stuff has less quercetin than good stuff! :-)

Brightness14 profile image
Brightness14

Of course, I never thought of that. I will stick with the cheap one then.

foxglove profile image
foxglove

Not just red wine and a different prob. Does alcohol i general cause stomach bleed? Thank you

helvella profile image
helvellaAdministratorThyroid UK in reply to foxglove

I don't know. I doubt a modest quantity of wine, beer or similar would do so. But spirits might be different.

foxglove profile image
foxglove in reply to helvella

Thanks for reply - probably ok in moderation (as usual)

You may also like...

[Off-topic] Coffee or tea? The answer might be in your genes

genes Choice of drink linked to how we perceive bitterness of substances, researchers say......

New heart treatment is biggest breakthrough since statins, scientists say

biggest breakthrough since statins, scientists say US researchers find heart attack...

A New Search Engine for Scholarly Works

Just a quick post to point out a new search facility - which might be very useful. Browsing the...

Scientists hail earwax test for checking stress hormone levels

Scientists hail earwax test for checking stress hormone levels Researchers say...

Butter nonsense: the rise of the cholesterol deniers

thread will end up just being a re-hash of previous posts. Butter nonsense: the rise of...