A book you should read by Dr Alyson J. McGregor.... - PMRGCAuk

PMRGCAuk

20,273 members37,962 posts

A book you should read by Dr Alyson J. McGregor. Sex Matters: "How male-centric medicine endangers women's health and what we can do".

jinasc profile image
13 Replies

I groaned and thought another feminist issue, will it never go away. Since I was 18, I have been arguing for equal rights in one way and another.

I then thought about PMR & GCA and it came into my head, that with most men PMR goes into remission within 2 to 3 years and that was the figure used in the old guidelines, the same goes, as I found out, for most auto-immune illnesses.

As the book had been recommended to me, I thought, OK I have not anything better to do at present, the weather was not good and no going out or decent enough weather to garden.

After 5 years of GCA about 6 months later I had a heart issue. I did not realise what is was, it started as indigestion etc and I was looking for arm ache (there was none). To cut a long story short, I ended up in hospital and it eventually turned out to be arrythmia on top of A/F.

The Cardio Guy, who is a lovely person and I still see him every 3 months (except this time it was just by telephone) that I must understand that women presented differently from men when experiencing a heart attack. He told me what to look out for and I have never forgotten what he told me.

I wish every woman would take the time to read this book and then pass it on to a medical man.

Things really need to change, not for me, I am into overtime - but for those women who will follow along.

Written by
jinasc profile image
jinasc
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
13 Replies
Longtimer profile image
Longtimer

Sounds good, but I fear some medical men are to arrogant to read it!....Thank you...

Charlie1boy profile image
Charlie1boy

Hi.

Yes, my wife is still in the process of reading this book, and has sent a copy of it to our grandson who is doing a PhD in bio medicine in Switzerland as she felt he needed to know!

She (my wife) had been "going on" about this issue for some years, and thinks it ought to be mandatory reading for all medical students.

This also comes up as an issue in Bill Bryson's book The Body.

Best wishes

Paddy

tangocharlie profile image
tangocharlie

I'm reading a similar tome by Maya Dusenbury called Doing harm - why women get over-looked and mistreated in medicine. The recent news about women having to fight for years to be taken seriously about concerns of things like the mesh implants, endometriosis etc makes me realise the struggle is so much harder for women still. It's probably why no research has gone into PMR and GCA because it's just aches and pains elderly women have to put up with. Even the guideines seem to be written about some mythical creature who gets over PMR in 18 months not the people on these forums! I just read an article from 2014 about how women are deemed 'steroid resistant' because their PMR didn't go away in 18 months, whereas the men's all did. I'll dig it out because for the life of me I couldn't understand how they came to the conclusions they did, that it was the TCZ that made a difference, it was so obvious there was a difference in response between the men and women.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to tangocharlie

Standard pharmaceutical procedure - if they did just women's responses separately they would often lose half their target population. Statins being a case in point ...

tangocharlie profile image
tangocharlie in reply to PMRpro

That's what my book says, women are too complicated to experiment on with all the variable hormones etc so they just used to do the trials on men and assume the same meds will also work on women! Now they include women in trials but then ignore their results because they don't fit with what they want the conclusion to be.

PMRpro profile image
PMRproAmbassador in reply to tangocharlie

Exactly! Same with age as well - loads of things work differently in the older patient - and that means over 50!!!!

jinasc profile image
jinasc in reply to tangocharlie

When Roche were looking to commence trials on TCZ, (big pharma have to involve patients with the relevant illness before they can even start a trial.

I had provided 10 of the patients from all over the UK and knew 2 others and soon got to know 1 in the bar. Turned out he loved brandy and I had ordered one and did not have my purse, just going to put it on my room number when he paid.

Roche paid for everything else, including insurance from door to door, 4 star hotel and first class travel.

Roche were unlucky enough to contact me....................I had a ball and it ended up 50/50 and I did feel a little sorry for the experts.

The Freeman in the North East was one of the 14 hospitals (mind they were not all in theUK) chosen to participate in the trial and guess what, one of the women members, fitted the criteria to take part in the trial. I was always worried that 14 were not enough, but the regs says that was OK.

I would always advise people to think seriously about taking part in a trial.

Top medical access 24 hours a day every day, including Bank Holidays. When a trial ends still priority access for quite a while.

Grammy80 profile image
Grammy80

Thanks so much for sharing that!!💖

SheffieldJane profile image
SheffieldJane

I couldn’t agree more. The vaginal mesh stories are horrific. These women were just dismissed.

tangocharlie profile image
tangocharlie

And it's people like you who stood up and did something for injustice in healthcare that has improved things for others. You inspire me, thank you x

Judyliz profile image
Judyliz

jinasc, I love it, "I am in overtime".

I'm going to pinch that little saying.

nuigini profile image
nuigini

I finally had a look at this and read the introduction to the book. It's on order. Even though it's available on Kindle I decided it warranted having a hard copy. Looking forward to reading it.

jinasc profile image
jinasc in reply to nuigini

I have just lent mine out - complete with a note on the flyleaf...............I want it back please.

You may also like...

Should you be headache free on Pred? And, do you tell work colleagues whats the matter?

Hello GCA pals, Me again. Can I ask if its normal to still have headaches when on Pred? I am...

Update from 5 months ago and new question

rheumatologist. She said she had met loads of women who thought they had PMR and wanted to be on...

'Invisible Women: Data Bias in a World Designed for Men' - Impacts on Our Health and Well-being

BIG issue which I mentioned five months ago in a post I wrote here called: 'Women and Heart...

What my rheumy said yesterday - you may not like this!

diagnosed with PMR and GCA last September. I am pleased to have printed out and presented him with...

GCA some interesting info in large Swedish study

relation to GCA in this fairly recent big Swedish study synopsis including: 'Men with GCA had a...