Better than a DEXA?: I am in my 2-year... - Osteoporosis Support

Osteoporosis Support

4,731 members897 posts

Better than a DEXA?

Foodie2shoes profile image
10 Replies

I am in my 2-year period of grace given by my MD before taking something for my osteopenia which was increasing. I've been doing what I can- exercise, weights, yoga, Calcium-D3-K2 supplements and doing the OsetoStrong program. I have increased my strength 175% since starting OsteoStrong, so I'm hoping that will translate to some bone strength as well. My question is about the DEXA scan that I will have in November. Is there a better scan, or a different type of scan, that I can request for better or more accurate information? It may actually be better to stick with the same DEXA to be able to compare apples to apples, but I just wanted to know if there is something more accurate available.

Thanks

Written by
Foodie2shoes profile image
Foodie2shoes
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
10 Replies
Met00 profile image
Met00

I'm wondering why they're considering medication for osteopenia? Have you had a fragility fracture? The decision about medication should be based on fracture risk, which takes into account a whole variety of risk factors.

Foodie2shoes profile image
Foodie2shoes in reply toMet00

No fractures or issues at all. My mother had severe osteoporosis and my osteopenia scores were increasing. The report said,"medication advised" so I guess that's why my OB/GYN wanted me to start taking it. But, when I talked later to my internist, she said she would not have prescribed it due to my low fracture risk. So, I've just made some lifestyle adjustments and looking forward to seeing the results.

Met00 profile image
Met00 in reply toFoodie2shoes

Although having a family member with osteoporosis may raise your own fracture risk, it doesn't follow that you'll also end up with severe osteoporosis. It depends whether you've inherited the underlying cause(s) of your mother's osteoporosis, or lifestyle factors (eg smoking, poor diet, lack of exercise) if they contributed to your mother's bone loss.

Foodie2shoes profile image
Foodie2shoes in reply toMet00

My mother lived to be 101, so she had a lot of great genetics, but lost about 4" in height due to the osteoporosis. She took oral bisphosphonates for years and did not have fractures. I have seemed to follow in much of her good health in that I am small boned, have low blood pressure and am very healthy. She never had HRT and was not a smoker, but very sedentary. I did have HRT (no longer) am active and as noted employing other lifestyle "hacks". Hopefully, my scan will be good. My original question was actually inquiring about other types of scans.

Met00 profile image
Met00 in reply toFoodie2shoes

The other scan I know about is a REMS scan, which gives the same t-scores as a DEXA scan, but uses ultrasound rather than x-ray and is more fully automated than DEXA so less open to error.

Oscarbuddy profile image
Oscarbuddy

I recommend getting a DEXA scan with a TBS (trabecular bone score). The TBS measures the strength of the microarchitecture of the trabecular bone (inside bone). It sounds like you are adopting good health habits for your bones. I would get more information before taking medications. Best wishes in your care.

Foodie2shoes profile image
Foodie2shoes in reply toOscarbuddy

Thank you!

yogalibrarian profile image
yogalibrarian

Comparing apples to apples is important. Even comparing DXA scans on machines from 2 different manufacturers requires some calibration and calculations. You can't really compare a DXA with another type of scan. And DXA is still the gold standard for diagnosing osteoporosis. If it is available in your area, your healthcare provider might suggest adding the trabecular bone score (TBS) to your DXA. But the equipment is not as widely available.

Foodie2shoes profile image
Foodie2shoes in reply toyogalibrarian

Yes. I have heard that having the same type of test is a good idea for accurate comparison. I will ask if they can add the TBS to the DEXA. Thank you!

dw98611 profile image
dw98611

What were the results of your scan? I'd like to l'd like to know if Osteostrong worked.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Experience with Echolight versus DEXA

Last year I had an Echolight scan and the results were better than my DEXA. Unfortunately the...
Pugger profile image

An alternative to the DEXA test, the Echolight REMS test

This week I got a relatively new bone health test called the Echolight REMS scan. It is found to...

DEXA Results

Hello, I know this question has been addressed in various ways before, but it would still help me...
Karana81 profile image

Getting the doc to order a DEXA

I went to the doctor for a yearly physical which was so frustrating. The muse asked me a bunch of...

Cat scan vs DEXA scan

I had a CT scan in December for another issue not having anything to do with my bones and after I...
Kitchenbuddy profile image

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.