Am I disabled now?: What is it to be... - Cure Parkinson's

Cure Parkinson's

26,582 members27,897 posts

Am I disabled now?

drjonny profile image
5 Replies

What is it to be disabled? Where does the term "disability" come from?

People are a mixture of thrownness (Heidegger’s description of the state in which we exist), self-determination and circumstances sometimes outside of our control. Within this mix, no person alone can be described as being disabled; they are just being themselves. The term “disabled” arises only when people are compared to each other (including your past self compared to your present self).

Physical and mental disability is considered a lack of ability only because another person happens to have that ability. We live in a wonderfully complex world full of individuals with unique skills and abilities. If disability arises from an act of comparing, then everyone is potentially disabled depending on whom they are compared to. For example, the athlete Usain Bolt is disabled compared to the swimmer Michael Phelps because he physically can’t swim as well as Phelps (and Phelps is disabled when compared to Bolt).

Whether it is Parkinson’s disease, an inability to run 100 metres in under 10 seconds or millions of other reasons, everyone can be considered disabled. Therefore, the division between able and disabled people, which the word “disability” signifies, is a false division.

I was diagnosed with Parkinson's in April 2012, I was only 33 at the time. As I have battled to come to terms with my disease I have written a series of short essays exploring the impact, consequences and meaning of Parkinson's. I have recently started to post my essays on a blog at dialoguewithdisability.blogspot.co.uk (search google for "dialogue with disability parkinson's"). My intention is to allow sufferers and non-sufferers (as well as other people with disability) to better understand Parkinson's from the inside. Understanding is empowerment.

dr jonny

Written by
drjonny profile image
drjonny
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
5 Replies
Carrigan profile image
Carrigan

Very enspiring thoughts coming from you Dr Johnny sure you will be a great help to many , thanks will look up your blogg xx take care now

compucure profile image
compucure

Inspirational dr jonny - thanks for this and it was good to see the description from Heidegger!

Tony

jillannf6 profile image
jillannf6

i shall look a tyour blgo too

lol JIll

:-)

DeParkiePoet profile image
DeParkiePoet

It's not a long way from disabled to victim and from there we have nowhere to go but down, we could just give up and die. I like to think that Parky is a very strong adversary, who is willing to fight for my health. So I am too, willing to fight this bummy for months, years, lifetimes if need be.

drjonny profile image
drjonny

In my post I was trying to show that if everyone can be called disabled (depending on whom you are compared to) then the division between able and disabled people is meaningless. Disability is always a relative term. For example, we all have the "disability" of only seeing light in the visual spectrum but since we can't be compared to someone who can see more of the spectrum its not considered a disability.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Why Am I Taking Butyrate?

A lot of us take a number of supplements. This thread is to make the case for Butyric Acid -...

Does exercise help Pd ?

The benefits of exercise for reducing disability in people with Parkinson disease (PD) are...
Danny2401 profile image

Levodopa Equivalent Dose App

Many of us take a complicated mixture of different types of Parkinson's drugs, with different...
johntPM profile image

Has anyone heard about K2 a Vitamin. I hope it's true and not another Scam

Vitamin K2 Potentially Offers Hope For A New Treatment For Parkinson's Disease 14 May 2012...
Danny2401 profile image

Anyone familiar with CoQ10 treatment? This is Dr Shallenberger's daily post

When Parkinson's disease first shows up, it's very mild. But as time goes by, the symptoms can...
kaypeeoh profile image