statins V rapeseed oil : Rapeseed oil... - Cholesterol Support

Cholesterol Support

9,661 members2,643 posts

statins V rapeseed oil

bobski1 profile image
5 Replies

Rapeseed oil better for heart than statins ? Hope so going by a study in Toronto Canada.

express.co.uk/news/health/4...

Written by
bobski1 profile image
bobski1
To view profiles and participate in discussions please or .
Read more about...
5 Replies
Penel profile image
Penel

Good idea to research around the subject, especially check who is funding research etc.

Rapeseed may contain too much polyunsaturated fat to be healthy in the long term.

authoritynutrition.com/cano...

patch14 profile image
patch14

Rape is a member of the brassica family, such as cabbage and cauliflowers. It is a healthy plant but it is the method of extraction and manufacturing processes that have me concerned. We have a local farmer here in Bedfordshire who makes his own rapeseed oil. He calls it "cold pressing" and although a bit more expensive than the supermarket brands is much more natural. Rapeseed oil is a very healthy oil as is olive oil - but like everything else is only healthy as long as it is part of a balanced diet!

sparky333 profile image
sparky333 in reply topatch14

Yes - they use petrochemicals to extract the oil which is at that point rancid - then they de-odourise it ready for eating which is all wrong to me... can you tell me where you buy your farmer's oil from - I'd like to go there myself... sparky333@ymail.com thanks for that

patch14 profile image
patch14 in reply tosparky333

Hello sparky333 - Google L and AE Munns and Son - they list stockists that take their cold pressed rapeseed oil. Best Wishes

DakCB-UK profile image
DakCB-UK

care.diabetesjournals.org/c... is the source publication (Bad Express! Why not link to it?) but I don't understand why they modified the diets of both groups. The control group was given a whole-grain diet with a whole-wheat bread supplement, so this only tells us something about rapeseed compared to whole-wheat... they also make a claim that the control group "improved" but compared to what? Comparing with start-of-trial or pre-trial readings is unsafe because it's only a 3-month trial and maybe different foods were consumed as the seasons changed and that changed the readings. I'd need to do some serious numbercrunching of the dataset and it's just not published in enough detail for me to do that. Chasing down the authors and the data is a lot of work and this isn't my job. Maybe some nice charity would like to get the data and peer review it? How about it, HEART-UK?

Oh and yes, as I think Penel suspected: "This work was supported by the Canola Council of Canada, ... DJAJ ... has received various funding from ... Canola Council of Canada. CWCK has received support from ... Canola Council of Canada" - not necessarily enough to dismiss it completely, but yes, be wary.

Not what you're looking for?

You may also like...

Olive Oil instead of Statins

I saw on the programme 'Trust me I'm a Doctor' Series 4: Episode 3 that taking 20ml of raw/cold...

Statins

A lot of negative things are said on this site about taking statins. I blame myself for not having...

Statins

I read so many posts on here about how statins are bad for you, serve no useful purpose and you...
weee profile image

Statins

Over the last 2 years since having a heart attack and one stent implanted I've had 2 different...
colingee profile image

Statins

I have been on 3 different statins with in the last @9 months.. Always muscle pain but with this...

Content on HealthUnlocked does not replace the relationship between you and doctors or other healthcare professionals nor the advice you receive from them.

Never delay seeking advice or dialling emergency services because of something that you have read on HealthUnlocked.